FANDOM


  • On the characters of Snow, Emma, Henry, David and Zelena, they have all been listed as being portrayed by "Special Guest Star" , as that's what they were for the last season (for Henry, Im refering to Jared Gilmore). I think this should be reconsidered, because, they, for have been "starring members"¬†longer than they were "special guest stars". What are the opinions of others?

      Preparing Editor Spell
    • What the... I didn't even notice, but you're right! It should definitely be changed back to "starring cast member", for the reason you describe... I don't get why that was changed at all.

      Thanks for bringing it up! I don't really think we need a discussion to change this; I'm changing it back right now. If, for some reason, a lot of people protest, we can re-evaluate it, but I'm changing it for now.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Awesome. What are your opinions on Ruby, Graham and Archie? I think Archie is fine, I'm not too sure about Ruby, and with Graham, even though he only appeared in 9 episodes, he was a "main" for 7 of them.

      Also I forgot about Belle + Neal.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I've updated Graham, Ruby, Neal and Belle.

      Graham was a starring cast member in 7 out of 9 episodes, so he should be starring cast. Archie was only a starring cast member for a few episodes before he was "demoted" to guest star, so I agree with you, he should remain guest star.

      Ruby was a starring cast member for 29 episodes and a guest star for only 7, so she should be starring cast. Belle was a starring cast member in nearly every episode where she appeared.

      As for Neal, MRJ was a guest star for 12 episodes and a starring cast member for 16... So he should be starring cast.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • When was MRJ bumped up from guest star to star? I heard it was around s3/the beginning of 3b but I'm unsure.

      This show is wack when it comes to casting titles. Wasn't Rose a guest star initially then s7 ended up being arguably more about her than Dania/Ella?

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • MRJ was bumped up to starring cast at the beginning of Season Three. Rose was only supposed to be in five episodes¬†(So her last episode should have been "Pretty in Blue"). But she ended up appearing in fourteen episodes.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Nightlily wrote: Ruby was a starring cast member for 29 episodes and a guest star for only 7, so she should be starring cast.

      Meghan was a guest star in season 1, she was just clearly more important than all of them, and August and Archie. It should by 12 and 24 putting her as a guest star.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Schroeswald wrote:

      Nightlily wrote: Ruby was a starring cast member for 29 episodes and a guest star for only 7, so she should be starring cast.

      Meghan was a guest star in season 1, she was just clearly more important than all of them, and August and Archie. It should by 12 and 24 putting her as a guest star.

      Hangs head in shame... You're right; she was a guest star in Season One. Sorry, my bad!

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Nightlily wrote:

      Schroeswald wrote:

      Nightlily wrote: Ruby was a starring cast member for 29 episodes and a guest star for only 7, so she should be starring cast.

      Meghan was a guest star in season 1, she was just clearly more important than all of them, and August and Archie. It should by 12 and 24 putting her as a guest star.

      Hangs head in shame... You're right; she was a guest star in Season One. Sorry, my bad!

      Don't worry, I've done so much worse in forgetting things, often involving people I've met and not just watched on TV.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • A Spy in the Mirror
        Preparing Editor Spell
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.