FANDOM


  • Shouldn't Sir Henry be in the family tree of Regina and Emma?

    1- Alice, for example, is Nook's daughter, but not Hook's. We could say the same of Sir Henry and Emma, ​​but the truth is that Emma does not have a Wish Realm counterpart. She had just lost her memories and been transported to that world. Later she recovers and she does not stop being his mother.

    2 - Originally, Sir Henry hated Regina for having killed his grandparents. However, after the end of the seventh season, it is shown that he forgave her and now considers her mother, making her adoptive mother, right?

      Preparing Editor Spell
    • There was a conversation awhile ago (I think it was deleted IIRC) and for Regina since we don’t know if Henry was legally adopted we won’t add it. Emma on the other hand is harder we can’t add Wish Snow, David and Henry to her but we have to add it to them, limitations of having a two-dimensional family tree.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I don't think she needs to have adopted him legally if they both consider themselves mother/child. About Wish Charmings, we may be able to add them and put a note that they're parents only on Wish Realm.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • It would look weird to add them though, also legality is part of the format of our trees, you must biologically and/or legally be their parents, that's why the spinsters aren't on Rumple's page (Lady's full explanation is in the comments of Sir Henry).

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Schroeswald explained it enough. As they said, Lady also has a perfect explanation of why Henry cannot be added to Regina’s family tree.

      About Emma...We don’t even know the all details about Wish Princess Emma. We know that the wish really created a world whose time is faster than NEF or LWM. But we don’t know if there is really another Emma, or if there is, we don’t know what happened to her after real Emma replaced her place (if that’s the case).

      As you can see, lots of “if”s. I disagree for Emma

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • CadoDoan wrote:
      Schroeswald explained it enough. As they said, Lady also has a perfect explanation of why Henry cannot be added to Regina’s family tree.

      About Emma...We don’t even know the all details about Wish Princess Emma. We know that the wish really created a world whose time is faster than NEF or LWM. But we don’t know if there is really another Emma, or if there is, we don’t know what happened to her after real Emma replaced her place (if that’s the case).

      As you can see, lots of “if”s. I disagree for Emma

      I would love to see Emma have a Wish Realm doppelganger

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • OitoTrintaDois wrote:
      Shouldn't Sir Henry be in the family tree of Regina and Emma?

      1- Alice, for example, is Nook's daughter, but not Hook's. We could say the same of Sir Henry and Emma, ​​but the truth is that Emma does not have a Wish Realm counterpart. She had just lost her memories and been transported to that world. Later she recovers and she does not stop being his mother.

      2 - Originally, Sir Henry hated Regina for having killed his grandparents. However, after the end of the seventh season, it is shown that he forgave her and now considers her mother, making her adoptive mother, right?

      It's like to Regina, he is still her son no matter what version he is.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Schroeswald
      Schroeswald removed this reply because:
      Trolling
      23:59, February 9, 2019
      This reply has been removed
    • A Spy in the Mirror
        Preparing Editor Spell
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.