FANDOM


  • who?

    mabie she is ava and nicolas's mother

    or page's

    or alice's

    or even morrain

    i know there crazy idears but your thoughts...

      Preparing Editor Spell
    • Not to be that person but...


      *Maybe *Paige *Morraine *They're *Ideas *Nicholas


      You could also capitalize Ava, Morraine, Nicholas, Alice, Paige, and the I.


      Wait, I'll just show you.


      'Who? 'Maybe she is Ava and Nicholas's mother, or Paige's, or Alice's, or even Morraine's. I know they're crazy ideas but your thoughts?

      That is a cool idea, really. I hope she is. Then they should have Emma and Lily meet again.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I don't think she's old enough to be any of their mothers.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Hhhm... I see. Well she should come back anyways.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Ruby ridinghood wrote: I don't think she's old enough to be any of their mothers.

      Just remember, Paige/Grace was around ten when Emma was born.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • If theories are true then Cruella would be a Grandma.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • It's not possible to be Alice,because she lives in the past

      It,s not possible to be Ava & Nicholas,because they were alive when Emma wasn,t born.

      Paige is from Enchanted Forest,too so she was born too when Emma wasn't.

      Honestly I think Emma and Lily are going to meet again and Lily is going to be an adult and if she will have a son or a daughter im not sure they are going to be a part of the Fairy tale world. 

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • X-Men Are Cool wrote:
      If theories are true then Cruella would be a Grandma.

      Cruella is not Lily's mother

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I know I didn't believe it anyway I was just saying.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Where was it even said that Lily has a daughter?

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • WinterWoodsGal wrote:
      Where was it even said that Lily has a daughter?

      Could just be a theory, and it wasn't said anywhere at all.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • More importantly who is Agnes Bruckner going to be playing?  My guess is that she is Lily grown up.  They look enough alike and this character will be in both "Lily" and "Mother" I would love Emma and Lily to see each other again and interact in Storybrooke.  Any thoughts? 

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • WinterWoodsGal wrote:

      Ruby ridinghood wrote: I don't think she's old enough to be any of their mothers.

      Just remember, Paige/Grace was around ten when Emma was born.

      my theory is Lily was working with the queens of darkness to get people on there side but she failed so for a punishment she went over to the lwm with cruella and ursella but before that she got turned into a child, so she then befriended emma to get her evil step by step by robbing shops then breaking into places but it failed so now she is the same age as emma and has a child. so it could be with...

      Jeffereson

      the Woodcutter

      Alices father (edwin)

      Morains mother

      ect


        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Sweetie, I'm sorry to do this to you again but...

      'My' should be capitalized.

      Queens of Darkness.

      Their, not there.

      Cruella and Ursula.

      Emma.

      So.

      Jefferson.

      The Woodcutter.

      Alice's father, (Edwin)

      Morraine's mother.

      But wait, how would Lily have a child with Morraine's mother? Or did you mean Lily is Morraine's mother?

      Also, I do still see a small flaw. 

      Lily was an adult, then she was turned into a child, then back into an adult and then had a child is what you're saying? Because every child you listed was still a EF kid.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Annaisthebestestbanana wrote:
      Sweetie, I'm sorry to do this to you again but...

      'My' should be capitalized.

      Queens of Darkness.

      Their, not there.

      Cruella and Ursula.

      Emma.

      So.

      Jefferson.

      The Woodcutter.

      Alice's father, (Edwin)

      Morraine's mother.

      But wait, how would Lily have a child with Morraine's mother? Or did you mean Lily is Morraine's mother?

      Also, I do still see a small flaw. 

      Lily was an adult, then she was turned into a child, then back into an adult and then had a child is what you're saying? Because every child you listed was still a EF kid.


      I meant Morrain's father and I meant she had a child in the EF and is now in  Storybrooke spying on Emma, so her child is now revield because no one ages in Storybrooke

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Just because Peter Pan was made into a boy again does not mean that every character after him is going to have the same issues.  I doubt that Lily is even from the EF.  Not to say that she does not have some kind of connection (I'm still holding out that she's The Author) but saying that she was made a kid and came to our world with the QoD is just a little too far for me.  Beside they've already done the "age reversal" thing.  Doing the same things over and over does not make good writing or keep an audience.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Ouat man wrote:
      Annaisthebestestbanana wrote:
      Sweetie, I'm sorry to do this to you again but...

      'My' should be capitalized.

      Queens of Darkness.

      Their, not there.

      Cruella and Ursula.

      Emma.

      So.

      Jefferson.

      The Woodcutter.

      Alice's father, (Edwin)

      Morraine's mother.

      But wait, how would Lily have a child with Morraine's mother? Or did you mean Lily is Morraine's mother?

      Also, I do still see a small flaw. 

      Lily was an adult, then she was turned into a child, then back into an adult and then had a child is what you're saying? Because every child you listed was still a EF kid.


      I meant Morrain's father and I meant she had a child in the EF and is now in  Storybrooke spying on Emma, so her child is now revield because no one ages in Storybrooke


      Ooooooh that makes more sense, I could see that in Once's twisted storyline.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Ivo1011 wrote:
      It's not possible to be Alice,because she lives in the past


      Alice is from a different world not the past (alothough in the timeline of the shows who knows).

      I don't think Lily's kid is one that already exists in Storybrooke. But as for Lily's (biological) parents i'm not too sure. Idk if Cruella will be her mother, but i feel like she does have a connection to either the author or sorcerer (or both).

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • It was said that Lily has a daughter. This can be seen on Lily's offcial page on this Wiki. It is under "relatives." 

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Mercy.Xavier wrote:
      It was said that Lily has a daughter. This can be seen on Lily's offcial page on this Wiki. It is under "relatives." 

      thanx 4 that no honestly some people should read pages before joining a discusion

      I don't mean to sound harsh kncooper

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I just went and checked Lily's page, and if it did ever say she had a daughter before, it does not now. The only entries under relatives that I saw was for Maleficent as her Mother (now confirmed), and her adoptive father (who has yet to be given a formal name that I am aware of).

      While it would not be surprising that Lily had a daughter (seeing as she is the same age as Emma), I have not seen anything that officially makes that statement.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I really don't see the point in Lily having a daughter. 

      By the way, did we ever find out what Paige's bike was doing on set?

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • unless lily's daughter and henry started dating lol!

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • That has been mentioned once before, about Henry dating Mal's Granddaughter.

      and I think David's reply to that would be "And we thought thanksgivings sucked before..."

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • It did say Lily had a daughter, but yes, it must have been taken off.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Ouat man wrote:
      Mercy.Xavier wrote:
      It was said that Lily has a daughter. This can be seen on Lily's offcial page on this Wiki. It is under "relatives." 
      thanx 4 that no honestly some people should read pages before joining a discusion

      I don't mean to sound harsh kncooper

      that's OK because i didn't write what you quoted ...

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • If she has a daughter then the daughter may be living with her right now. The daughter may be made to be Henrys' love interest.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Gnattygan wrote:
      More importantly who is Agnes Bruckner going to be playing?  My guess is that she is Lily grown up.  They look enough alike and this character will be in both "Lily" and "Mother" I would love Emma and Lily to see each other again and interact in Storybrooke.  Any thoughts? 

      I think this too... :D

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • what if lily had a one night stand with neal 

      and got a daughter

      who falls in love with henry even though their technicaly half siblings 

      Write It!

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Please... Just no.  That reminds me of the awkwardness I felt when finding out that Luke and Leia were twin siblings.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Yeah let's stay away from incest, that would make Once too dark.

      it reminds me of that show "twisted" that got cancelled and the cliffhanger ending was that the girl's boyfriend was her older half-brother but she didn't know that  ... too wrong.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Ruby ridinghood wrote:
      I don't think she's old enough to be any of their mothers.


      She's as old as Emma, who has Henry.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Also, I've heard a rumor that the upcoming charachter Autumn might be Lily's daughter.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Agnes Bruckner is adult Lily. (Check Lily's page for the reference). Autumn was, as we figured, a red herring name to keep us guess as long as possible. (Though, truth be told, I don't think any of us are that surprised at this point.)

      And I'm really not holding my breath that there is another child. That would put Lily's and Emma's stories eeriliy similar. As if they aren't similar enough already.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • maybe parker Magnuson lilys son

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Possibly, but I think I would lean more towards someone connected to Young Lily and/or Young Emma.  Primarily, based on what has been set up so far, the last time Lily and Emma interacted was when Lily's father came to get Lily. So, since both of the Young versions of Lily and Emma are in this episode, unless they fill in more of the Minnesota happenings (which I can't really see much more there, tbh), they are going to need something to provide some cohesion.

      I could see this unknown young man being maybe a common friend/acquaintance to both girls.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I think there might actually be a charachter named Autumn. Her name is still under New Guest Stars.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Or it could be the codename of Adult Lily :)

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • She might actually have a son named "Zach" based on a new character on IMDb's page for the episode "Lily".

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I have this crazy theory maybe because i just saw Romeo and Juliet, but if we see the whole scene, the importance of Lily´s daughter will be because of Henry. i remember that in an interview they talk about Henry and his posible love interest.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I think that the whole "Love Interest" was just speculation, since at the time, Lily was described as a recurring character, and was cast as a teenager (near to Henry's age). Now that we know the young girl that Emma briefly befriended is, in fact, Maleficent's daughter, we should discard the idea of a Love Interest for Henry (at least for the moment). Just my opinion, though.

      As for Lily having Children, obviously it is possible (given she is the same age as Emma), but I don't see that happening either. I think Zach is probably a young friend from the LWM that knew Lily (and or Emma, since Abby Ross is listed as a Guest Star for the episode).

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • A Spy in the Mirror
        Preparing Editor Spell
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.