Nick begins hunting down witches in retaliation against them for his sister's death. In investigating the death of Doctor Sage and the attempted killing of Hilda Braeburn, the police detectives learn from Eloise Gardener that the killer is acting out his pain through murder and that Hilda and the doctor both received a heart-shaped box with chocolate marzipan truffles before they were attacked. Nick plants one of these boxes at GJ House Flowers & Gifts, a local flower shop, distracting Rogers and Weaver long enough with a false lead so he can attack Hilda again.
The detectives investigate the candy store that makes the boxes and discover that the last place they delivered the chocolates to was the florist shop. They later arrive at the shop and find a candy box lying on the counter. However, when they talk to the owner, who is the widover of Luanne Hoffs-Drawler, the woman it is addressed to, they discover that Luanne died years ago, revealing the killer set them up. Meanwhile, Nick kills the guards outside Hilda's hospital room and successfully stabs her to death. ("Knightfall")
Eloise comes to see Ivy at at Belfrey Towers. As they finish their conversation, Eloise hands Ivy a pink bag and tells her it was already outside when she came to see her. Ivy inspects the bag, pulling out a heart-shaped box with her name on it, which means she is the next target of the same killer who recently murdered two members of the Coven of the Eight. Ivy remarks that she didn't survive this long to be killed by a chocolatier with a penchant for theatrics and says that she will be fine. Later, as Ivy enters the parking garage, she is attacked by a masked killer, who charges at her with a knife; however, Ivy manages to escape by kicking him with her stiletto and fleeing while he is still down.
Later, when leaving Flynn's Barcade with Henry and Rogers, Nick finds that his car tire has a flat but assures Henry and Rogers that he can handle it. Once they're gone, he begins working and places one of his tools in the trunk, where he keeps the mask he wore while attacking Ivy and several boxes of chocolate identical to the ones received by his victims. ("Sisterhood")
At Roni's, Kelly and her Margot have a conversation Kelly admits to her daughter that she misses her fiancé, Chad. At that, Margot suddenly recalls someone left something for Kelly outside the bar. Margot, believing the gift is from Chad, hands her mother a heart-shaped box with her name on it, but a shocked Kelly realizes she is now the killer's next target. ("Breadcrumbs")
Roni returns to the pub, having procured the right kind of moss needed for a potion to cure Henry, but Kelly reveals Henry left for a job interview in New York. Roni is stunned and wonders why she didn't call her, and Kelly then shows her the heart-shaped box. While she has no idea why the Candy Killer is after her, Kelly considers how being her cursed persona was much easier than being Zelena, who has a past of horrible deeds.
Later, Kelly and Margot go to the police station
, where Rogers notices that Kelly is holding the tell-tale sign of being the Candy Killer's next target. He tries to talk to her about it, and though Kelly only wants to speak with Weaver, he insists she comes with him to the cafeteria so she can answer some questions. However, Kelly lies about needing to make a phone call first, leaving Margot and Rogers to proceed to the cafeteria first without her, while she goes to Weaver's office. Kelly shows the chocolate box to Weaver, who sardonically wonders how it feels for her to finally be chosen first before her sister Roni. When Kelly asks about the killer's identity, Weaver says that his name in Hyperion Heights
is still unknown but his New Enchanted Forest
name was Hansel
, shocking Kelly, who admits that she did something terrible to him in the past and now her past is coming back to haunt her. ("Chosen")