FANDOM


(Created page with "I'm going to say '''yes'''. While I think it makes sense to have separate counterpart pages for those affected by a curse (Regina's Curse and/or Zelena's Curse), I also thin...")
 
 
Line 1: Line 1:
I'm going to say '''yes'''.
+
I'm going to say '''yes'''.
   
 
While I think it makes sense to have separate counterpart pages for those affected by a curse (Regina's Curse and/or Zelena's Curse), I also think it'd be simpler to combine pages for Nealfire and Pinocchio/August because neither of them were ever cursed. The undoing of Pan's curse brought Neal back to the Enchanted Forest, yes, but because he wasn't ever affected by Regina's curse, that's all the undoing of the curse did for him. It did not revert him into a child because he was never touched by Regina's curse, so that aspect of her curse completely skipped him when it came to undoing Pan's curse.
 
While I think it makes sense to have separate counterpart pages for those affected by a curse (Regina's Curse and/or Zelena's Curse), I also think it'd be simpler to combine pages for Nealfire and Pinocchio/August because neither of them were ever cursed. The undoing of Pan's curse brought Neal back to the Enchanted Forest, yes, but because he wasn't ever affected by Regina's curse, that's all the undoing of the curse did for him. It did not revert him into a child because he was never touched by Regina's curse, so that aspect of her curse completely skipped him when it came to undoing Pan's curse.
  +
  +
Also, the alias thing. Baelfire and Pinocchio both assumed false names as adults, but in essence, they are still the same people that came to the Land Without Magic as children. That's like Cora going to Wonderland and assuming the name "Queen of Hearts".

Latest revision as of 22:50, March 26, 2014

I'm going to say yes.

While I think it makes sense to have separate counterpart pages for those affected by a curse (Regina's Curse and/or Zelena's Curse), I also think it'd be simpler to combine pages for Nealfire and Pinocchio/August because neither of them were ever cursed. The undoing of Pan's curse brought Neal back to the Enchanted Forest, yes, but because he wasn't ever affected by Regina's curse, that's all the undoing of the curse did for him. It did not revert him into a child because he was never touched by Regina's curse, so that aspect of her curse completely skipped him when it came to undoing Pan's curse.

Also, the alias thing. Baelfire and Pinocchio both assumed false names as adults, but in essence, they are still the same people that came to the Land Without Magic as children. That's like Cora going to Wonderland and assuming the name "Queen of Hearts".

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.