Since alot of the items are types of clothings, I suggest an 'Articles of Clothing' Category. These are all the items that would fit into the category:
(Baelfire's Shawl, Concealing Gloves, Crown Jewel of Agrabah, Cyrus' Talisman, Emma's Red Leather Jackets, Enchanted Cloak, Enchanted Cuffs, Enchanted Helm, Genie Bracelets, Jefferson's Hat, Magic Gauntlet, Oz Pendants, Protective Necklace, Regina's Engagement Ring, Ruth's Engagement Ring, Sea Bracelets, Six-Leaf Clover, Sorcerer's Hat, Tracking Bracelets, Wraith Amulet)