All posts by

I agree with what others are saying. Keep it only in the impersonators category. Like others have said, that was not Rapunzel Tremaine with Hook, it was Gothel in disguise. No matter how much she looks like her, it’s still Gothel.

Agree. Even despite he past mistakes, he’s been very inactive for like a year now.

Did we ever reach a consensus on this?

^On the cast list though it links to the person they're impersonating.

Another suggestion, I think for linking (I.e. in the History section or the Cast lists), we should link it to the person impersonating them but have it listed as the person they are impersonating. Example Gothel|Rapunzel - Zelena|Maid Marian.

And @Schroeswald

1. I personally vote for listing it on the impersonated characters page. For example: if we have the the images of Gothel as Rapunzel in Lady Tremaine's, it’s odd because that wasn’t her and it could confuse people into thinking it’s her.

2. Probably. I mean, Zelena was known as Marian almost a whole season.

3. I don’t see a problem with doing that. They technically are playing them.

Agree

Not sure if it was intentional, but I could see some similarities. But I haven’t read the book or seen the film either.

Do we know when Our Decay took place season wise? Like I said H&G definitely took place before 3B but Hansel and Gretel were teens and Jack seems to be Henry's age.

I think they mean when Gideon was living in Gold's shop under the curse. I forgot about that.

Or Favorite Arc in general?

Idk how to separate S1-2 because they didn’t really follow the arc format but

Neverland arc/S3A

Oz/Time Travel arc/S3B

Frozen arc/S4A

Queens of Darkness/Happy Endings arc/S4B

Darkness/Camelot arc/S5A

Underworld arc/S5B

Serum arc?/S6A

The Final Battle arc/S6B

The Cinderella/new curse arc/S7A

7B had a lot of arcs but I say the overall arc was Coven of the Eight/Candy Killer.

Favorite Seasonal/Arc Villain?

Regina/S1

Cora/S2

Maybe Tamara and Greg

Pan/S3A

Zelena/S3B

Ingrid/S4A

Rumple and the Queens/S4B

Dark Swan and/or Nimue/Hook/S5A

Hades/S5B

Evil Queen/S6A

Fiona/S6B

Coven of the Eight/S7

So apparently we've reached consensus on Fiona. Now we need to discuss Emma and Henry from Fiona's curse and Henry from the Coven's curse. And anything else anyone wants to mention.

As for the other Storybrooke's under the fourth curse, idk because it’s moreso like they were re-cursed. They didn’t gain new identities but just got their old ones with altered memories involving Emma being locked away and Fiona being Regina. I'd say we can edit it all into their original cursed counterparts. Same with the ones in the EF. They didn’t gain new identities, they were cursed back into their old ones from the EF.

Btw guys: Be specific about which Henry. We're discussing both the Final Battle curse Henry and the Hyperion Heights/Coven curse Henry. Although I think I disagree on Final Battle Henry only because his situation is similar to in Season 1. Although, to be fair, Regina legally adopted him, while he was cursed as Fiona's son so idk. S7 Henry definitely needs one. He was given fake memories.

I’m sure we need to wait on more people but it seems Fiona and S7 Henry are pretty much agreed on. Emma still seems undecided.

Agreed. This isn’t really any different than Jack/Hansel and they’ve never had two.

Belle images.