I'm still not sure on which method I think it should be besides I don't like the current ordering, but Belle absolutely should be added to the list and its a crime she wasn't there before

Zelena too imo, since she's the only main besides those 8 to be a regular for more than one season, in addition to being an important character overall

I agree with the idea of ordering by most appearances.

So I think the most popular orderings are:

Appearances: Regina, Henry, Rumple, Emma, Snow, David, Hook, Belle, Zelena(?)

Credit order: Snow, Emma, Regina, David, Belle, Hook, Henry, Zelena(?), Rumple

I think there might be others but they are mostly rearranging these (I'm assuming no one has any problem for Belle being included but I'm not at all certain for Zelena)

Oh and as for Nick's suggestion for S7, idk my opinions, but if you extend these options to it we'd have (unless we'd want to include major guests Tilly, Gothel, Ivy and Margot in which I case I dunno):

Appearances: Rogers, Jacinda, Henry, Lucy, Roni, Weaver, Sabine, Victoria

Credit Order: Roni, Rogers, Henry, Jacinda, Victoria, Lucy, Sabine, Weaver

And I'd say credit order is clearly the superior option there (although, really neither of them are great) while I probably prefer appearances for the main one

I don't have a huge problem with Regina not being at the top, as long as she's on the list. And I like credit order better.

I also prefer the credit order 

I agree with appearances' order ^-^ 

Currently, we have:

Credit order - Lily, Lola, Nick and PandaPrincess

Appearances - Me, S, Applegirl and LR

Anyone else has any opinions?

I agree with credit order, and having a tab for season 7.