Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-2153169-20171120155605/@comment-27060727-20171121054539

8Rob wrote: If the Wish Realm always existed, then WHenry must have biological parents

If our Emma and W!Emma merged when she was teleported there, then she is now the mother of WHenry

Right? o.O Yeah, I was thinking about this the other day. Even if the original Emma "replaced" Wish Emma at that point in time, Wish Snowing was still on course to have Wish Emma when Wish Regina didn't cast her curse, and Wish Henry still had to have parents. There's no way there was never a Wish Emma.

I also think it's highly unlikely that the writers intend for the EF2 to be another wish realm - they would've made it more explicit to begin with. I don't think Gothel or Rapunzel/Tremaine are wish characters. The writers just haven't been thinking any wish-related stuff through and its frustrating because they can't just leave the audience to come up with random things to explain away the inconsistencies for them.