Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-5679696-20150105234331/@comment-25926288-20150107131221

Lady Junky wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: Anyway, the list:

- Ryan (The guy Emma busted in the pilot)

- Gnome (The guy Regina turned to stone for laughing at her)

- Behemoth (The guy that killed Prince James)

- Barthalomew (The guy who fought with the Huntsman, I think)

- Horatio (The other guy who fought with the Huntsman, I think)

- Mayor Tomkins (The mayor of Red's town)

- Mr. Grace (Paige's "father")

- Mrs. Grace (Paige's "mother")

- Mute Maid (Rumple's maid; named Honora in episode)

- Monstro (The whale that swallowed Pinnocio)

- Raskind (The guy who worked at the foster home Pinnocio and Emma were placed in)

- Gordie (The kid who convinced Pinnocio to leave Emma)

- Claude (The guy who was mean to Belle and later became a guard for Regina)

- Alistar (Claude's friend, I think)

- Abraham (A giant)

- Argyle (A giant)

- Andre (A giant)

- Eva's Royal Doctor (Self explainitory; not sure if we need this one, but somebody made it a dead link)

- Cora's Father (Self explainitory)

- Isra (The woman August slept with before he started turning to wood)

- Quon (The guy who brought August to The Dragon)

- Rivers (One of Regina's guards)

- Berkley (One of Regina's guards)

- Nana (The Darling's dog)

- Rapunzel's Father (Self explainitory)

- Rapunzel's Mother (Self explainitory)

- Woodcutter (Zelena's adopted father)

- Woodcutter's Wife (Zelena's adopted mother)

- Franz (Hans's brother)

- Jurgen (Hans's brother)

- Kevin (A kid in Ingrid's foster home)

- Oaken (The sauna guy from Frozen)

- Madame Faustina (A woman who pretends to see the future)

And for Wonderland:

- Bearded Man (The guy Jafar almost got Cyrus's bottle from; I think in the episode he was called Fazeen Shamed)

- Nazim (A guy in the Catipillar's club)

- Akil (The guy Amara had Jafar kill to test him)

- Gerard (The guy Jafar and Amara got either the lamp or the jug from)

- Mr. Darcy (The guy Sarah wanted to set Alice up with)

- Millie (Sarah and Edwin's daughter, Alice's half sister)

- Ulima (Jafar's mother)

That's exavtly what I thought when I was talking about abussive creation of pages. Gnome? Rivers? Oaken? Akil? Nana? Quon? Seriously Quon? Who is this guy? Nobody remember him! Most of these, while minor characters are extremely minor. Some like Ryan, Ulima, Claude affect the story, maybe even Madame Faustina. But I think the minor characters should play a role in the story and not be just filler. Like I didn't know some of these mentioned had a name. For the Black Knights, we could just have a page for the Black Knights and list some of Them without giving them all there own page. Claude plays a role in Belle's capture and though dead, Hook's travel to Wonderland. Berkeley and Rivers might do a little bit more than the others, but nothing substantial.

Mr. Darcy, while it might be worth mentioning for the Pride and Prejudice reference, shown up one time and was more of a cameo. We shouldn't include pages for the other background characters, like Kevin, unless he appears again or Isra, who to me is simply not at all important. She may have slept with August, but she's largely replaceable.

I think the character, or item, to have a page should affect the plot in someway, may have some speaking part that's relevant, mentioned at least once more if only a single appearance, or any combination of those. Decent criteria before some want to add the villagers because they died in an episode, and appeared twice.