Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20171118020002/@comment-7526254-20171118141059

I'm really confused about the timeline here. When did Alice escape from the tower? She was seen in EF before the ball, before Wish Hook arrived. That means he must have not visited her in a while. At some point, Alice was in WL and met Drizella. Alice was in WL before the ball, but Drizella did not turn evil until after, meaning she must have returned to WL. With the amount of time this would have taken, it is amazing that Hook didn't even know she escaped from the tower.

Alice should be the same age as Emma, but she seems young, meaning she must have been to many different realms where time moves differently.

Connecting the timelines of Wish Realm and EF:

Hook mentioned working with the Evil Queen to get to a land without magic to kill Rumpel, but he never mentioned Cora. He didn't plan on staying behind, meaning the timeline must have changed before Hook met Cora, only a few days before the curse. The other Rapunzel that David rescued should have also existed in this universe. Could she be the one who imprisoned Gothel?

I don't understand this poisoned heart thing. Why hasn't it been done before? Why couldn't Ella's mom tell her husband instead of just running away?

Ella said her mother left her when she was a little girl. Assuming she is close in age to Alice, Alice was likely not in WL when Ella's mother left, meaning she would have spent years in WL before being killed.

If Jacinda gave up Lucy for adoption, how did she get her back?