Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-6175354-20161010033114/@comment-24674051-20161020174052

Other than "The writers think this is a cool idea", what reasoning is there to have a sea captain be a Shepherd Daddy? Charming's farm is nowhere near the ocean. admittedly, the town where he went to trade could be a port town. but even then, we're talking about Nemo, who is not just any sea captain. and if he's anything like the literary version, he lives for the sea. So I'm just not seeing Nemo being David and James' father.