Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-26443838-20151103053835/@comment-27138802-20151104142006

Shadows Vale wrote: Eskaver wrote: What Shodows Vale might be getting at is that Rumple being the Dark One had a price and that was his son, so with all the foreshadowing and Rumple speeches, Emma should lose a loved one as well (permanently) That's exactly what I'm getting at. Thank you.

If the price for Emma is for Hook to die, that ain't happening. The writers are more likely to kill Emma off before they do Hook. I really think is much ado about nothing. Even if Hook dies, there is a 100% chance that he won't stay dead. What a smack to Henry when he wanted to bring back his father, the Apprentice shoot him down. But somehow his mom's 6 month boyfriend can return.......

I think these theories is an attempt to Hook more importance on the show than what he is because, even if you really really like him, subconsciously people know that he is a lampshade that really doesn't contribute much than anything on the show than giving Emma kisses and taking credit for other people's hard work. Therefore, coming up with theories so that Hook's mythology will actually have an impact on the overarching story currently happening.

Theories so far debunk -Hook is a true hero and will pull Excalibur.......Rumple did it. -Hook is the true king of Camelot....No he is not. -Hook dad is going to be "THE" Davey Jones...A&E said no.

Can't wait to see more speculation. Especially since there are rumors that Hook's name is on Excalibur. Hook was one of me and my husband's favorite characters, but OUAT just can't keep a good thing. Colin said he missed playing Season 2 Hook. :(