Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-1916997-20151012011036/@comment-25926288-20151015012615

Edward Zachary Sunrose wrote: Obviously the black one is Milah's, as we've now noticed... But how do we know Hook didn't steal his sword back during season 2, or he got it back during a confrontation?

Maybe it was meant to be Hook's original cutlass and they used the wrong prop. LOL Unless it's in a future flashback, then it stands as is.

In season 2, Hook would have been dead going into Rumple's shop., The only thing taken was ironically Bae's shawl.