Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20170313005929/@comment-25926288-20170324193008

Seasrmar wrote: I just rewatch the episode. Crazy theory here. What if August has ulterior motive for showing Hook the storybook pictures? This does not take away that Hook killed Robert. But what if he doesn't like the fact Hook is with Emma? He may like Emma himself, being with her all that time and want this  fact to destroy their relationship. Or he is just being  protective of Emma and he wants Hook to prove himself even more by telling her the truth of what happened? His reaction  to hearing that Emma was going out with Hook was of surprise. The episode featured Pinocchio lying and his nose grown. Sure it may a homage to the animation, but what if it parallel August lying now. Well, not really lying, just have an ulterior motive. The pages don't really show that Hook killed Robert. It simply sparked Hook's memory  that he did kill Robert because he recognized him.