Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-6036560-20130206000351/@comment-5355525-20130210054026

I was under that same impression as well. Not only that, but Hook describes "Jack" as a man who fought a terrible war, defeating all but one of the evil giants."

When they come up on the skeleton with the sword with Jack's name on it,... it was spelled "Jack",.... Jaquelin would have been spelled "Jaq" if the sword belonged to a liberated woman who slays giants and beasts of all kinds, and owes no man anything!.... least of all, the masculine spelling of her name.....

It seems to me that a legend involving a woman giant killer would be more about it being a woman more than the giants or other beasts she kills. How could a legend like that ever be mistaken or confused for being a man? Those kinds of things were expected of men, not women,...so when one legend did arrise of a woman giant slayer, the emphasis would have been put on her being a woman, not a man. imo.....

So we're to believe Hook got his story wrong?....