Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-2153169-20170909025746/@comment-2153169-20171030193926

JennaMae wrote: If Rapunzel is Tremaine, which I'm not totally refuting, where does Hook's story about a witch imprisoning his daughter in a tower and then cursing his heart come in? Was this witch (Emma Booth) imprisoning multiple people in multiple towers? Are there multiple Gothels in this OUAT iteration? Because I certainly don't think Tremaine is Hook's daughter.

The problem is that we automatically assume Girl in a Tower = Rapunzel. But in the latest ep, they implied Alice might be the daughter.

My theory since a little moment now is that the Witch, for unknown reasons, has imprisoned multiple young girls in her tower time after time. Like she'd need them to stay young or do something else, but for that she'd need some young girls and she keeps them in her tower. Rapunzel/Tremaine and Hook's daughter might just be two of these girls.