Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-27060727-20170222030619/@comment-26159109-20170502065708

JennaMae wrote: ChocolatEyes613 wrote: I just rewatched some of the clips, from when Emma and Mary Margaret first meet Hook. While, on the surface it looked like they did not know each other, it is actually fairly ambiguous. It is definitely a retcon.... but the writers probably felt the audience would assume, Marry Margaret and Hook were lying to the others, about their past. I felt the same earlier when I rewatched, however, Adam has been reassuring people on Twitter that yes, Snow and Hook DID meet for the first time in season 2. So that suggests they really did have no recollection of one another and there's an explanation coming.

Besides, why would MM lie to the others?