Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-27060727-20171014181959/@comment-25375217-20171018160432

Eskaver wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: Eskaver wrote: They are bad with math, but not that bad. XD Who says it would have to be a math issue though? Zelena's Robin could have been aged up by magic for "reasons". XD Let's distribute some logisitics:

One day in November 2013 or so, Queenie sent Emma to Wish Realm. Hook-w's daughter was already kidnapped by the Witch years ago, or was just kidnapped by the Witch when the realm was created (which every theory you believe).

Any other day in 2013, Zelena was walking around with Baby Robin near evil fairies and cyclones.

Robin Jr can be aged up, but she can't be the Witch (Emma Booth) and I doubt Zelena and rEgina would have let the baby be stolen anytime in between. Think of it this way:

Some years ago, a Witch kidnaps Whook's daughter and eventually curses him.

In November 2013, Emma arrives in the Wish Realm and meets Whook.

Sometime in 2017/18, Regina leaves Zelena and the now-school-aged (from 4 to 6 years old) Robin behind to help Henry in the NEF.

A short time later in 2017/18, a Witch arrives in Storybrooke, snatches up Robin while she's in school, and drags her through a time travel portal.

Some years ago, Robin and the Witch arrive. The Witch raises Robin into a Witch.

Once she's grown, Robin kidnaps Whook's daughter and eventually curses him.

Giving Robin a time travel spell isn't ridiculous since that was her mother's life's work. I seriously hope this isn't the case, but it is very possible.