Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-1916997-20171222202521/@comment-1916997-20180213062111

NickM98 wrote: CadoDoan wrote: I checked the thread, and about the Regina being a member of the Coven, there are only 2 people who are against it, all the other people agree with CDA's original suggestion. I think we can say that it's a consensus. Disagree, Regina's magic/blood was only used by the Coven as one of the ingredients to cast the curse. She was blackmailed into participating in their ritual, but it does not make her a member of the Coven. I for one am not sure where in the thread you got this idea. From my reading it seems there is broad agreement that Regina participated in the casting ritual through her blood being given, but nothing about anybody agreeing that she was a member of the Coven. Cado is right. Here, I'll pull the statements from people's posts:

Esk said:

"Regina should be listed as one that was coerced into being their 8th Witch."

Cado:

"I agree with Esk on both subjects."

TheRose:

"I agree" in responce to Cado.

OUAT: The Darkness:

"I agree with Eskaver's views on the matter."

Tyson:

"Then yes, I’m voting for her being a part of the Coven in the EF. It’s the coven of the Eight. They needed her to be the eighth one."

The other people who commented don't think Regina is nessisarily a coven member, but agree she was used in place of one for the purpose of casting the curse, which I would argue makes her at least a temp coven member.