Talk:Wish Realm/@comment-26967699-20180513221428/@comment-2153169-20180513225544

Because, Kitsis says it clearly? "Alternate Enchanted Forest". Not alternate FTL, with another Agrabah, Arendelle... The show never suggested anything in that way, same for the writers. We have no reason to go into that speculative.

Also, there is no need to try to give some logic to a wish. There is none. The show pretty much established that part. It is perfectly possible for the wish to only copy the EF.

Finally, there are not simply writers, they are showrunners. They created the series, the series says what they want to say. Which means, in terms of canon, show = showrunners. All canons work like that; when the creator says something, it is as important as what they created. Which means, if Kitsis and Horowitz says something abouta completely untold point of the series, then their word is as important as the series.