Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-34360784-20180116101248/@comment-2153169-20180118133232

Does not change this very basic guideline: from the moment that there is a doubt, we can't add it as a fact. Whatever we choose to believe on this question, it changes nothing. This entire thread and the previous discussion are proof of that. If it was as clear and easy as some pretend it is, these discussions would not happen and would not be so divisive.

There are enough of uncertainties to challenge the info. Meaning that, at this point, without a clear source from the writers, it just can't be resolved.