Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-24304025-20180528222236/@comment-2153169-20180528225033

FrancisPaul wrote: Lady Junky wrote: If we don't know if they appear or not, then we don't list it on their pages. Simply as that. That's how we did until now.

We can add recaps like Nat did for sure. For the rest, we don't fall into speculation. Not allowed. 1. I admit that icons, categories and infobox should not be changed, but I do think that a small note under the appearances section would be fair. It IS an appearance afterall. But fine, it's not a big deal. I'm 100% okay if we add nothing.

2. Still, no matter what we do about history, appearances etc., we should remove the others too, not just Smee and Pinocchio Well, a discussion is still happening about the other, no? In the comments, I mean. If community decides against it, sure. But I don't know what was the other's positions about this issue.

For the rest, it is not really an appearance if we don't know who's appearing :) ^^