Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-2153169-20171120155605/@comment-2153169-20171128225744

FrancisPaul wrote: One line that I think might mean something in this discussion is Emma saying that she has all of Princess Emma's memories, including Geppetto's death. This confuses things even more, leaving us with options a) the memory is fake, but the event is real; or b) both the memory and the event are fake, meaning WGeppetto never existed.

The memory is fake, but the event is real. Pinocchio knew it too. Let's not forget that Emma took the place of Princess Emma in that Wish Realm. The wish gave her all memories that Princess Emma is supposed to have at this point (so all memories until she is blowing that candle).