Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-24304025-20150718173803/@comment-2153169-20150718181046

I disagree with a lot of things you said.

First, "we have consensus to count Smash the Mirror as two episodes". That was not a question of consensus. STM counts as 2 episodes. A&E made it clear during the comic con. That's not a choice of our community, or a consensus, it is like that. End of the discussion xD We just did a consensus about how to write the intro sentence.

Then, "we must adapt the appearances template". No? I mean, to me, we don't have necessary to edit as much as you suggest the appearance template. In this case, it is a question of how we treat the information from STM. It is different from the consensus I asked, cos in your case it is a question about how we work. Concerning the episode count for each character, we have too. If STM is 2 eps, we have to count it as two eps for the characters.

And clearly, I disagree to divide the case of STM. First, because we're trying to make the templates similar and I do not think it is possible to divide horizontally the case; it would be unclear since we have to precise the title of the episode AND which part is that case. Too much info for a such little case.

Moreover, if we split the appearance case, I personally do not the point to keep STM as one page. I mean, if we split the appearance template, we have to be as precise as the template everywhere else. So, to me, we would need to split also the cast list (which is basically the same), but also the summaries on characters pages & the trivia. And basically, if we arrive at this point, I really do not see the point to keep STM as one page, which was decided.

I would have an much easier suggestion. Just change "Smash the Mirror" on Appearances4 to "Smash the Mirror, Parts 1 & 2". I mean, we decided to treat the information from these episodes as one two-hour ep; that's why we decided to have one page. IF we begin to split something, well... This is again the whole discussion about splitting or not STM.