Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-5679696-20171014203438/@comment-26967699-20171015101315

FrancisPaul wrote: DatNuttyKid wrote: Calling Roni "Regina" is as inaccurate as "Evil Queen". Once the curse breaks, she'll be Regina again and then we can talk. But right now, she's Roni. Calling anyone anything is inaccurate.

The Original EQ will be in the page, and it's inaccurate to call her Roni.

That's why I made the "credited birth name" suggestion, because any other name would be choosing one version over another.

Also, people keep saying that we will rename back to Regina once the curse is brokwn. Well, if Regina is a valid option then, when the curse is broken (IF it is, because we never know if it will, what if they cancel the show etc. etc.?), why isn't Regina a valid option now?

If the show ends without breaking this curse, then we will have a page named Roni because of 22 episodes while she was Regina for 130+?

And, more importantly, why does the "temporary naming" idea feels appropriate? It would generate endless renames. What if a new curse comes and Roni gains the name Susan, then we will rename it to Susan? Then the curse is broken and she is back to Roni? Or Regina? I mean, there have been numerous curses and cursed characters are getting cursed all the time. I don't think this "more recent name" thing will be anything other than a temporary solution with possible need to be rediscussed over and over Actually, we don't know Roni will take her former name aka Regina after the curse is broken. Maybe she'll want to be called Roni. We don't know that for sure. Even after the first curse is broken, Cinderella uses the name Ashley, while on the other hand Thomas uses Thomas.

The thing is that '''we have to use credit names. '''Because that's in the policies. In order to suggest the "birth names" suggestion, first we'll have to suggest to change the policies, then we can suggest that. But right now, for Regina for example, we can only use these names

- Evil Queen

- Regina Mills

- Roni

Same for other characters.