Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20171014005708/@comment-30389283-20171015160021

DatNuttyKid wrote: AlbOuat wrote: I actually don't know how to react to this episode. I love Colin, he is a great actor and did an amazing job but... Why couldn't just let him go along with Jennifer? What is the point if Rogers isn't the Hook we've known for years? I don't get it. And why exactly would it have made more sense to create another entirely new character?

Wish Hook is no different from Cindy, Tremaine, Drizzle, Alice, Tiana, etc. -- he's a brand new main character for the requel. But by going with Wish Hook instead of Captain Jack Sparrow from the New Enchanted Forest played by Zelda Williams, they got to keep a talented, fan-favorite actor who loves the show instead of having to cast a brand new one and get the audience to love them and the new character. I didn't say anything about a new character. I just don't understand why they created this complicated storyline when they could have just wrote off both Emma and Hook together.