Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-24304025-20150202171011/@comment-26159109-20150307174733

Eruciform wrote: YayMona wrote:

Gusey1397 wrote: I think I've worked out clues for Zelena not actually dying. In 'Kansas', we've all been focusing on her death in Storybrooke, everybody has forgotten her first death in Oz from Dorothy, revealed in the same episode. Here are the two clues:

1) Glinda told Dorothy that now Zelena was dead, her magic would be reversed. However, when Zelena was defeated, the flying monkeys turned back to humans. It was almost as if Zelena realised she'd have to fake her death so the flying monkeys would have to turn back to their original forms.

2) When Dorothy 'killled' Zelena, she turned into a pile of clothes and melted skin. This then turned from a green smoke back into Zelena. When Gold killed Zelena, she randomly turned to clay/china and smashed into a pile of rubble. Then a green smoke appeared and what was left of Zelena disappeared.

My theory is Zelena knew when she was beaten that Gold would kill her so prepared to fake her death again. THat's why these plot holes happened in 'Kansas' Your theory makes a lot of sense, she might have had enough magic left in her to fake her death and then reform once more. I agree. It makes a lot of sense considering in the actual book, water killed the witch but here, Zelena recovered so she's a lot tougher than that.

My theory is that she can't be killed as long as the pendant isn't destroyed.