Board Thread:Show-Related Questions and Answers/@comment-24138799-20131106211135

So, when the Lost Boys captured Neal, they already had another prisoner hanging in a cage in the trees. Who do you guys think is in there? I've got 2 theories.

1: Wendy. Since she'll be in a couple of future episodes, she might be there. She might have wanted to rescue Bealfire from the Shadow, so she summoned him. Peter got furious when she got back to Neverland without his permission, so he locked her up as a punishment.

2: Eric. What if he found a portal to Neverland on his voyage and tried to claim the island for his own. Peter wouldn't have liked that so he killed Eric's crew and imprisoned him. He could have had a feeling he might use him for something. I know Regina told Ariel that Eric is in Storybrooke, but I kinda get the feeling he isn't. And if he isn't, that means he wasn't in the Enchanted Forest or the Land Without Color when the curse hit. Regina wouldn't know about the portal he found, so she would just assume he got transported to Storybrooke like the rest.

So, these are my theories. Do you agree with them or do you see it differently? Please let me know. I love reading other people's theories, however absurd. 