Board Thread:Show-Related Questions and Answers/@comment-25974054-20150105192131/@comment-25733960-20150919015616

Eskaver wrote: Stovers wrote: If being outside Storybrook is the answer, then Neal never would have left Emma and Henry. He would just go with them to New York. Regina would have given them a memory potion to accomadate that. It's a plot hole. Neal wouldn't have to go back and then the story would stop with them living cursedly ever after. Agree. It didn't make any sense.

Same with Hook and Tink