Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20170501005830/@comment-25375217-20170501212350

Last time there were weird inconsistencies and plots that don't make sense, we found out a few episodes later that it was because the Black Fairy had Gideon's heart and every weird thing he had said was just a terrible lie from Black. So perhaps Black is just a bad liar.

Has anyone considered that those memories she showed Rumple might be fake? Since she said the reason she gave up Rumple was her darkest secret, but she didn't give him up at all - he was taken from her, which shouldn't be a dark secret. It should be something she'd willingly tell Rumple to get him on her side. Maybe he really is still the savior and she gave him up for a different reason, one she'd actually consider dark and might make her start kidnapping children and such.