Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20171014005708/@comment-25375217-20171016223433

CadoDoan wrote: ArcaneDust17 wrote: Aine1989 wrote: Soooo Rogers is Wish Realm Killian. Who still exists.

Meaning everyone from the Wish Realm is in fact real.

Meaning Wish Realm Snow and Charming were real. And Regina killed them.

Awesome. Depends. Maybe the Wish Realm works the same way video games do. In a video game if you kill a character it doesn't matter, because they are not real. However, what if, by some kind of magic, the characters from that video game find a way to step into our world? Once they step into our world they then become real. Perhaps that's the way the Wish Realm works. Maybe, the characters that are from the Wish Realm, are not real as long as they are in the Wish Realm. But the moment they step into another realm they become real. I like your example, I must say :D But I think the reason they call them "not real" is because they were created by a wsh. They are actually alive and kicking xD It's really about the definiton of your "real". If you ask me, they are not. I can't call some people who were created by magic as real. Hook is also not real to me so.. :P Except now we know that they weren't even created by the wish. Hook wouldn't have a history with Lady Tremaine or a daughter (who's old enough to play chess) if they didn't.