Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-4839682-20140320220703/@comment-7443211-20140321042223

Applegirl wrote: GothicNarcissus wrote: MasteroftheHat wrote:

Bottom line, I say no to merging identites created by Regina's curse (with August and Neal withstanding as well) but yes to characters who were carried over by Zelena's curse. Like Robin Hood and his men. No new identities there, just new clothes and technology exposure. I agree to that. Besides, Zelena implied that no false/new memories were implanted, as she said "everything in this world is a bit new", which means no knowledge of the LWM was implanted.

Also, I'd merge the Malcom and Peter Pan pages. Like, for instance, Cora assumed a new identity upon arriving to Wonderland, but we don't have a separate page for her and the Queen of Hearts. I disagree with merging of characters who were carried over by Zelena's curse. I believe the premises of why we even have separate counterpart pages is because of the cursed effect, and the characters being cursed by Zelena's curse could follow the same standard as Regina's curse, even if the curse's effects were not exactly the same.

Malcolm became a different person by being changed due to magic. Cora simply swapped realms and gained a new title as Queen of Hearts. While I do see your point, the characters taken by Zelena's curse didn't have the same kind of identity crisis as opposed to the folks from the first one. I agree that the seperate pages would be effective as far as the cursed effect goes, but they don't really have a new identity that differs from their personality from wherever else, therefore it would be a bit of a waste to have a page for someone who carries the same indentity the WHOLE time, just in a different land. Robin Hood is still the same guy with the same identity, just in different clothes. At least, that's just the way I see it.