Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-25926288-20151224174750/@comment-26443838-20160104125139

CoolDudeAl wrote: NickyHelp wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: NickyHelp wrote: And as usual or always, fandom ends up wrong. You say this all the time, and yet you are never able to tell us, when exactly was the fandom wrong about anything? I'd love specific examples. Because when I think about what people predict, it is almost always right. I read others said so. That's why. And besides, whatever A&E said from hotseats, they always came true.

When they begin saying "who says" in questions when questions like from:

'''Will it take more than a bucket of water to kill the Wicked Witch? '''

''' Horowitz: Who says we're going to kill her? '''

Clearly saying she is not finished yet.



Or

'''Will Killian (Colin O’Donoghue) play a role in bringing Emma back from the darkness? '''

HOROWITZ: Who says she’s being brought back from the darkness?

Clearly saying she is not in any darkness, and he does not help her. She does herself and avoided it. Except when Hook makes her apologize for what she did wrong to her parents. What a fool she had been. Making her realize that they were only protecting her twice. And making her end up guilty and stupid.



None of them were sarcasm.

So clearly this one:

'''If they can bring Hook (Colin O’Donoghue) back, is there a chance they can bring anyone else back? '''

HOROWITZ: Who said they can bring back Hook?

<p class="MsoNormal">is not different or sarcastic. And might come true. Okay, well just because people have said the fandom is wrong, does not make it so. Furthermore, saying "who said..." just means that they have not specifically stated what was in the question. It does not mean Hook is not coming back, just that they have not said he was, and the question implied he is. If they answer the question, they would be confirming the implication of the question. Because they don't want to do that, they answer the question with a question. But trust me, Hook will be back. Yes we do see him in the underworld. But that does not mean he will be back from the dead. Not saying he won't.