Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27291392-20180519135938/@comment-26967699-20180519182038

RedCoatOfficial wrote: CadoDoan wrote:

RedCoatOfficial wrote: But if that’s the case where did Pan come from? He was in Neverland at the time of the curse and he ended up in the Wish realm. So if there’s no wish Neverland, where did he come from? I'm tellng you. They don't have the same memories, or the same life. Even if Pan said he was Neverland, Pan just thinks he was in Neverland, due to the fact that it does not exist.

So the answer to your question "Where did Pan come from?", he came from a wish. He just happened to be in the Wish Realm like all the wish characters. But my point is, i get what you are saying, but the wish started from when the curse was cast, correct? If so, Pan would’ve been in Neverland at that time so how did he end up in Rumple’s castle. I get the whole fake memories thing but where did Rumple retrieve him from if he would’ve been in a Neverland? Because their lifes are also not the same. Just because our Pan was in Neverland at the time of X, doesn't mean that Wish Pan were also supposed to be in a version Neverland at the time of X.

After the wish is made, Pan just popped up in the Wish Realm, with the possible fake memories. Because as I said, the history of the Wish Realm and the lifes of the inhabitants are faaaaaar more different.