Board Thread:Show-Related Questions and Answers/@comment-2153169-20150328222518/@comment-25926288-20150415180018

I like your theory. I would totally want it to be true. For some odd reason they want us to believe a powerful and sentient shadow, The Shadow, Guardian of the dream world, Neverland, would want to be subservient to him, even if Malcolm brought it into "existence" or at least the physical plane.

My headcanon is that The Shadow ripped Malcolm's Shadow and then went on a 300 year vacation. I would wonder why a being like The Shadow would be defeated by some insignificant coconut candle (which makes zero sense because when he comes fire blows out, he was next to a fire when ripping Greg's shadow, he's out during the day). Plus, he doesn't talk and just follows orders. The only time the shadow should merge with Malcolm is when he had Henry's heart and was draining Neverland of all it's power.