Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-6175354-20161010033114/@comment-24674051-20161117181524

Ok, first we don't know what the writers will or won't do, so let's not even bring that assumption into the equation.

second, Regina has absolutely nothing to do with this thread, as she is not the one that did anything to Papa Charming, nor does she seem to have any information on the matter. (though I do wonder how Queenie was able to ascertain that tidbit of info... but that is a seperate topic.)

As I've said previously, I don't think it was Killian. While the method of murder is consistent (Stabbing), Killian has very little opportunity (though granted not no opportunity), and no motive that we are aware of. And Killian staging a fake cart wreck to hide the murder is simply not his style. Someone may want us to believe that it was Killian, but none of the facts add up.

I actually posted a different theory in the "Murder Most Foul" thread where I suggested that Papa C was not the murdered, but possibly the killer. and he might have good reason to stage a fake wreck, particularly if he has means to disguise or otherwise hide the identity of the actual murder victim. And running away after killing someone to hide actually does make sense, particularly if they could hide somewhere like the LoUS.

Point is, maybe the topic of this thread is asking the wrong question.