Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-6175354-20131205143032/@comment-4975807-20131224001538

ChocolatEyes613 wrote: DarlingDavies wrote: Can you imagine Neal, if it all plays out this way? "My half sister is a Wicked Witch???". Neal would want kill himself, when he finds out, about his long lost half-sister. Rumplestilskin better pray, that he and Peter Pan stay dead.... because there would me a lot people who would kill them, all over again.

Applegirl wrote: I'm invested to believe Cora was already pregnant with the WW at the time she pulled out her own heart, (or perhaps she found out a little bit later?) and for the sake of not having a reminder of the love she lost, she gave up her first born (to who, I don't know). And hey. Green skin. I wonder where the WW got that from? ;) Agreed.... it is quite possible, Cora was already pregnant with Rumplestiltskin's child, when she ripped out her heart. There is nothing, that would contradict it. If anything, the events of the 2.16 flashback, support this theory. There's also the possibility Rumple didn't know about his own daughter if Cora kept it such a well guarded secret.