Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26241562-20171120234724/@comment-1295345-20171121112050

Tvfanatic wrote: Is it me or is everything relating to the wish realm not making any sense ? At first in my mind, it was a fake world with fake people who started "existing" when Emma was sent there. So it was ok for Regina to murder Wish Snow and Wish Charming because they we're not real.

But now, they talk about the Wish Realm as if it has been existing forever since Wish Hook traveled to another realm in the past to conceive Alice.

So i have a lot of questions now,

Why is everyone ok with Regina murdering in cold blood Snow and Charming ?

When Emma was transported to the Wish Realm, did the Emma from the Wish Realm merge with our Emma ? Did she stop existing ?

Are there a multiverse of different timelines ? Is it like the flash ?

I dont want to be a jerk here. I'm geniunely wondering. I'm open to any sort of explanation. Thanks ! I take it you never saw the interview or the quote made during season 6 when it was stated that the wishrealm was real.

Also why are people talking about that flashback we saw meaning that the wishrealm had always existed? It only exists when it diverged from the prime timeline.

So let me attempt to answer your questions:

They thought it was okay because they didn't think it was real. As to after whook coming proving that it wasn't...yeah, that's a fair point.

I don't think Emma was transported to an existing realm, nor did she merge with a pre existing character or made that character disappear when she appeared. When the wish was made, it made this whole new history for her.