Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-14210692-20131022025420/@comment-11464223-20131025160616

LarytheCucumber wrote: I do keep thinking they might be brothers, but the way Peter said, "Like your wife, Milah... Even your own father." suggests that at least, Rumple's father isn't Peter's. Exactly. This is what I've been thinking.

It almost makes me wonder if the showrunners put it there to sway people OFF the idea that they're half-brothers, only to introduce that they are later on. :o