Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-25926288-20161021174343/@comment-25926288-20161205041738

Mathematicalbooks wrote: Question: I saw a video of Sean filming with Lana in Storybrooke. This Robin will be VERY different to the Robin we know and love, this is Fake Robin, SO if he does end up in Storybrooke, it's not a raise from the dead thing, it's kinda like Earth 2 from the Flash sorta thing. Same people yet different. Idk how this is going to play out. So my question is, does this break the "no raising from the dead promise" from A&E? And if so, Genies can't bring back the dead yet their magic allows Robin to escape the FU. So, this kind of breaks the laws of magic as well. Yeah, but at this rate, the main show has literally broke all the laws of magic (deities excluded).

If they could wish for someone very similar or a clone of the person, then they might as well have had that. What's weird is everyone who's dead in the real world is dead in the Wish realm, except Robin. I'm guessing he was a separate wish made because Baelfire is dead.

I doubt he stays. It's also weird to have twice the characters because they could do some interesting things with that.