Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-25762747-20160102074246/@comment-25926288-20160102124713

I think the major issue is that the whole curse reversal doesn't add up, without plot holes.

Logically everyone from a magical world got sent back, because that's the only reason why Bae didn't go with Emma. However, we ;earn that Ingrid was in Storybrooke, so she had to have went back and got recursed, but the Apprentice we have no clue. But then again, we no Rumple knew where the Apprentice lived, but that could be coincedence. The Apprentice would be cursed simply because he has a house, new clothes, and records in SB.

Logically if we count every curse, then everyone pretty much would be a cursed character.

If we limit it to SB-establishing curses, then Aurora and Phillip should be cursed too, regardless of what state they were in. Why? Because Maleficent is cursed and both times she was in a different form- Dragoin and ashes.