Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20160502010041/@comment-26159109-20160504124620

Eskaver wrote: The problem with the test isEmma would have saved anyone regardless of who was put on flames from their group.

Imagine if it was Henry, her parents, Regina, and even Belle. She'd save them all, so that test was more of a test of greed/ambition than TRUE love.

She wouldn't have saved Belle though or any character that the viewers don't care about.