Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-5895297-20131019194655/@comment-4839682-20131028063002

TNOandXadric wrote: Well, I'm all for crack theories on the internet—what else is it for?—but seeing them canonized is really disconcerting.

It's like the difference between deciding in my head that Grendel was the Duchess's husband/cook because what else am I supposed to conclude from an extended scene in a kitchen in Wonderland? and deciding in my head that Cora and the RQ had occasional violent hatesex because why not?

The first is a legit theory, the second came out of random silliness with my OUaT friend before the pilot even aired. And the conversation where I called the RQ being Anastasia went along the lines of "hah, what if she's Anastasia and that's why they made a big deal of not showing flashback!Ana's face—how contrived would that be?" and then at the end it actually happened.

It just seems gimmick-y instead of based in even the tenuous kind of logic. While all your points are marvelous and valid, this is the Internet. It defies logic.

Whatever crazy thing there is, it already exists, and there's porn for it. And if there's not, there will be soon.