Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-1916997-20180306160338/@comment-25733960-20180507184009

JennaMae wrote: Eskaver wrote: I’ve got it guys (besides Robin Hood) maybe the Wish versions are the Real Versions because they are “Both”! What happpens to the real happens to the Wish (or close enough).

I can see them pulling that while having a blatant contradiction (...or Robin isn’t actually dead because #Hope). This isn't a serum situation though. Like where does that leave a character like Wish Hook, whose journey has veered pretty far from OG Hook's? Wish Hook was injured in 7x02, that did not happen to OG Hook. And they couldn't just "combine" again.

In one of the leaked call sheets, they had listed Sean Maguire as "Wish Robin Hood." Which is strange, because from what we've been told (and that one description from the leaked 7x21 sheet), it's likely a dream sequence where Regina sees OG Robin...but then why would they listed him as "Wish Robin" on the call sheet considering there's an actual Wish Robin? And Sean said that he only filmed one scene. I'm confused. Actually, this could be an explanation about how they are going to deal with mess of having multiple Dark Ones in an arc about getting rid of the Darkness

It seems, the Wish can't actually replicate something as powerful as the Darkness. So, now Rumple and W!Rumple share the Darkness.

I think it's like Dark Swan and Dark Hook: They were 2 separate Dark Ones but the Darkness itself was still one.

This would confirm again that the Wish Realm was created by the Wish in 6x10, something that has been said before (6x11, 7x02) but for some reason some people want to believe the Wish Realm already existed before 6x10