Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-1916997-20180426084506/@comment-25926288-20180426100057

Well, I’d say ????? because there’s really nothing else to solidify the theory. Maybe to add, we need Alice to have used magic in combination with the backwards watch which let her “see or experience” the past. Not actually in the past because I doubt a random watch and random magic could do that.

I think it’s an oversight issue until they confirm that the watch can move things back in time or at least experience them. Would be a good and properly used macguffin. Other wise, thy legit had two contradicting episodes back to back.

7x08: I knew your mom, Ella.

7x09: I wasn’t even born yet.