Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-1916997-20150928191127/@comment-91424-20150928193456

The cook in "The Dark Swan" is definitely Tony from "Red-Handed" and the other episodes. The only time we see a different cook in the diner, is in "The Jolly Roger".

Granny identifies him as Tony, so that's what we should go with. The show is our number one canon, and trumps anything the writers say. And let's not forget, that Jane Espenson is only human. She can make mistakes.