Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5965318-20141208022925/@comment-24746469-20141214183457

Saying that Lily is Regina's daughter or even cruella is just ridiculous. There's absolutely nothing that points her character towards that direction.

1. Cruella is older than Regina or so it seems. 2. Lily was not from EF, she was just an ordinary character who ran away from her parents. 3. Regina and Robin hood did not met until she undeed the first curse, so even if they had a baby it probably will be months old. 4. I don't think a teenager from our world would write about magical book from real people she not even met. She is just not able to do it from what we know. And besides the book first appeared during the curse when Henry needed it. I don't she knew about all that stuff. If we see Lily in the present I think she won't be magical neither a villain.