Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-34360784-20180116101248/@comment-1916997-20180120022914

FrancisPaul wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: FrancisPaul wrote: I just want to add that, even if we eventually get a source saying "Real Hook's mother is named Alice" it won't be enough to add that WHook's dad is Brennan or dad WLiam and WLiam2 exist. That will only happen if we get an explict souce stating "Each and every family tree and name is exactly the same in EF and WR". Then we can add WBrennan, WLeopold, WCora, WJonathan, WZelena, WEveryone See this is what confuses me. Can you explain to me how anyone's parents in the Wish Realm can't be the same and still produce the same biological child as the EF version? I just don't get how anyone thinks that makes sense. Who says they are the same biological child? Same actor ==/== same DNA.

We've had dozens of actors portraying different characters. Your talking about the same character being played by different actors because of age realted things. Which actor on Once (not counting bit part actors) have played multiple parts on Once? I mean do you really think Hook and WHook have different biological parents and would be played by Colin? No, that makes no sense.