Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-2153169-20171120155605/@comment-25926288-20171128144204

CadoDoan wrote: Guys, seriously, it's not working...

As I said earlier, the best way to work this out is to say that WR always existed, with some differences of its own, like Stealthy being alive, Marian being dead, EQ being defeated etc. It is not the first time the writers lied to the viewers. I know you guys are just trying to fallow the writers, but it becomes more and more complicated and impossible. It's not impossible at all.

I'm one that quickly notes a retcon (I mean, they seriously tried to squeeze a flashback inbetween a continuous scenes in Swan Song).

Saying that:

WR was created by a wish, Emma lived out 28 to 30 years of her life in the span of a few hours.

...is not that complicated. The Dark Realm worked in a similar way. Fiona kidnapped Gideon, raised him for 28 years in a span of a few hours.

WR and NEF appear to have very fast time flows (A lot of years pass by in little SB time). Hook could have easily jumped between realms with little to no distortion because nothing says otherwise.

This is a lot easier than saying that WR always existed and that WR Baelfire went to WishLWM, WR Zelena to WishOz, WR Hook to WishNeverland, etc.