Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-2153169-20170909025746/@comment-25926288-20171104125947

CoolDudeAl wrote: My issue with Eloise being Rapunzel is then who is Lady Tremaine and why does she have a bad relationship with the Witch? The only thing that works is that she is the mother to Rapunzel, but that didn't seem to fit her and WHook's relationship in 702, and besides then Tremaine has 3 daughters, which seems excessive, especially since Ana is going to be brought back. I don't know, it's confusing, because Eloise seems like she hints at Rapunzel, but so does Tremaine. Maybe Alice really is WHook's daughter, although that means she will have 3 names: Alice, Tilly, and Eloise. That's a bit much with Alice, lol.

I'm still on the LT = Rapunzel until it dies, but more and more points to Eloise = Rapunzel and Tremaine being a big nobody.

I think we still might have a switcheroo where the episode will be about th Witch and Rapunzel, Hook comes along, but he comes to visit his daughter which is revealed to not be Rapunzel. Sort of like fake-out.

Other than that, Eloise is definitely Hook's daughter and Lady Tremaine has a million hints to be Rapunzel. If LT isn't Rapunzel then they are pretty much costing the character so much potential. Like if LT is Rapunzel, then One Little Tear can have a double meaning and be even more tragic.

The issue with your theory CDA is that it givens to much to Alice. If Alice is Hook's daughter than I guess it would cut down on the large female cast that we're getting. XD But, we do have an Eloise to deal with.