Thread:Nightlily/@comment-2153169-20150928180008/@comment-5679696-20151010222942

I have also read the conversation, and I would like to express what I understand from it.

Netflix does not want users using proxies or however someone could gain access to Netflix's services offered in a different area. However, this decision is Netflix's and Netflix's only, and it is not supported by the law in any way, therefore getting the legal vs. illegal matter out of the equation. It is then, clearly expressed that Netflix does not want their users doing this. According to Netflix, it's against their TOU.

However, as I have stated in the past, and now supported by this conversation, using Netflix of a different country is a problem, but it's a problem between Netflix and someone as a Netflix user. It is completely external to Wikia and that person as a Wikia user. As long as there is no legal claim over the different services offered in different areas, I personally think we don't have a claim on it either.

So, to adress the problem directly, I would like to repeat my example. If you steal an OUaT DVD set from a store, it is clearly a problem between you and the store. That does not mean you can't upload screenshots taken from those DVDs.

ABC, on the other hand, seems to have legal claims over the twitter posters, which is why we can't use them. The very action of uploading their posters is what is illegal, making it a Wikia problem. So anyway, that is my opinion about it. Hope it helps.

PS: I don't think we should upload images if the quality is really bad, which sometimes happens with Netflix. But if it loads in HD, I don't think it will be a problem within the Wiki, even if it might be an external problem.