Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20171014005708/@comment-28162607-20171017131153

Edward Zachary Sunrose wrote: DatNuttyKid wrote: The only thing that makes me wonder whether or not this was a real, constantly existing parallel realm is that there wasn't an Emma. Unless Emma actually replaced the other Emma.

This should probably be its own thread, though... I'm inclined to believe A&E about the wish creating the Wish Realm.

Therefore, the world was created around the real Emma, so there was never a Wish Realm Emma to begin with. There technically was one, because Real Emma has those memories, but she embodied the same space and body as the Real Emma, so she may as well have never existed.

And as for Robin not aging, he may very well have been old and gray when Emma's wish created the Realm. Or he may not have been there at all. But it's extremely obvious that he was rejuvenated/created when Charming wished for the Queen to get everything she deserved, since she ended up with Robin at the end of her arc. I am more inclined towards the thoery that  Robin is young and foxy (if you'll excuse the pun) because it was Regina's/EQ's wish. Which is why Killian was a bumbling boozer, because she is always making  fun of his alcoholism. Its why Emma was a weakling because Regina thinks she is weak and has to be forced to be strong. And its why Robin was young and hot, because thats what she wanted him to be.