Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-28162607-20180101191335/@comment-25926288-20180101215333

Aine1989 wrote: This is irrelevant to the thread but when I saw Bish I thought you were saying "female dog".

On the response, I totally agree about Regina's middle as you so called it but don't like the ending because I don't feel it was deserved.

On Hook, I disaagree about your opinion on his two moods. Every season bar 5 he had the Enemy/Victim From His Past to face; Ariel (well not Ariel really but ya know) Ursula and Liam 2. None of these arcs have anything to do with Emma.

And on Rumple, I also agree about the start. Season 2 and 3A could work as the foundation of a redemption arc, but equally it works as a foundation for a "power addiction tragedy" story. Unfortunately, the writers tried to go with both; they did the second one for most of the show then threw in a rushed redemption in 6B which cancelled out the past 2 seasons For Regina, I dont argue that it’s deserved, but it being a good representation of the result. Like Rumple, the end result looks perfect, but they jump across a few lanes.

With Hook, the comment about his two modes was in jest and a reference to in-show remarks about his “attachment” to Emma. I don’t relate his redemption towards Emma but a personal one and it just so happened to have its middle handled poorly (not as up and down with either Regina or Rumple, but one can hardly call it good).