Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20170410010002/@comment-261373-20170410034833

I think Malcolm did something that caused her to go evil. Blue Fairy may have been the one whom imprisoned the Black Fairy, but Malcolm did something. I have a theory.

The word "coward" have been use to describe many men in Rumple family. Malcolm, Rumple himself, and tonight Gideon. The Black Fairy was originally good. She and Malcolm did something but Malcolm cowardice cost them, especially her to be fall a part with the Blue Fairy. And to her the only to overcome your cowardice if you embrace darkness. She doesn't care too much about her ex-husband after what he did to her. She turn her attention to her son Rumple and turn him dark. She's behind the series of events that turn him datk. Notice that he was pretty much a coward until he became the Dark One. She wants him to competely dark, unredeemnable.

I think she either want to turn Gideon dark too maybe because she think she couldn't turn Rumple dark, so she gave up on that. Or that she thought if Rumple lost another son (albeit to darkness not like Bael who died) it will cause Rumple to completely embrace his darkness. Either she wants a son of darkness.