Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20151207015752/@comment-6175354-20151210021848

Toma Cre wrote: He accomplished what they all set out to do at the beginning - get rid of the darkness in Emma. So not really in vain. If it came down to a choice between getting rid of all the darkness for good and saving Emma, pretty sure that Hook and the rest would choose to save Emma. Perhaps.... but that does not change that fact, that Emma feels betrayed.

Regina and Mary Margaret have been selfish in the past, when it comes to saving the ones they love. Which is probably why they are being supportive, of Emma's decision to share her heart with Hook. It is Emma's fault, Hook was condemned to the Underworld. Has she let him go in Camelot, his soul probably would have moved on.