Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-26151936-20150409231229/@comment-26392556-20150413110321

BroKarl wrote: I dont get it Nicholas. They didnt go to the Apprentice to send Lilly away.They went to him to save Emma. Thats wht they brought him the egg. Are you saying that the Apprentice tricked them ? And if so,why? Does he benefit in some way?

And the second question is..... if he tricked them into beleiving he was transferring Emmas magic to the egg/Lilly so Emma could be saved, they why dont they beleive Emma was saved ,if he tricked them?

Lets say  it didnt have anything to do with Emma. Then why were Snow & Charming involved? They risked their lives to do what he asked ...and they get nothing ...not even "I tricked you" ?

Why would Snow,Charming OR the Apprentice, for that matter,want Mals child to be sent away in a portal? What would be their reasons ? How would they benefit? Why did they go through all of that? Are you saying none of their efforts were to save Emma?

Im trying to get to, why you think it has nothing to do wuth Emma ? I can accept your explanation if you can answer these questions. My crazy theory is that the Sorcerer was reborn as Lily *cough* *star birthmark* *cough*

So to get rid of "him", the Author forced the Apprentice, who didn't know what happened, to send the child away

But why did he need Snowing to involve ? Maybe he thought the Apprentice was not as strong as Maleficent ... Moreover, in case she cast a sleeping spell/curse, Snow was still not affected since she had been cursed before

While Snowing thought the spell transfered Emma's darkness to Lily, but instead it just opened the portal to Our World

That's how I see it :)