Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-25375217-20150325163457/@comment-2153169-20150326023013

DatNuttyKid wrote: ..........................................i feel like no one is actually listening to me

In THIS INTERVIEW, Kitsis (I forget which one is Kitsis, lol) says that "yes", Emma is the Black Swan. That makes her a character from Swan Lake.

As far as I can tell, there's no official proof that Emma is the Ugly Duckling, and that makes her not a character from Ugly Duckling.

That's my logic.

I agree with Eskaver. Moreover, in THIS INTERVIEW (yeah it is funny to do that :P) mentioned by you DatNuttyKid, Kitsis said Emma is the Black Swan if she becomes evil. As far as we know, Emma is not evil (yet?).