Board Thread:Rant and Rave/@comment-25733960-20171029001047/@comment-28162607-20171029114713

Eskaver wrote: Aine1989 wrote: re: Belle+mirror communicating, that is not enough. She still ived out the rest of her life with only Rumple and Gideon for company, even if she spoke to her family via mirror. She gave up her life for him. That is not healthy. And its not like she can have private conversations with them if he's always eavesdropping.

I am just going to say it; if Emma did this for Hook half of the people on this and the toehr thread would be singing a very different tune. You're assuming that Rumple is eavesdropping. You're also assuming that Belle never left the house. If we went with what was shown, these people never shower or go to the bathroom.

If Emma and Hook decided to go live with their child in another world and we saw a short montage of their life before Emma died, I'd be fine with it. I wouldn't think any different as I would assume they cut some stuff out. (Which for Beauty, from filming pics, they did) I'm pretty some fans would be upset that they killed off Emma and Hook, and go on about how Regina now is the sole parent of Henry, etc. Well it fits perfectly with Rumple's character for him to eavesdrop. It also fits perfectly with their relationship that she simply never hears from them again.

I would be of the opinion that even if she did call them and Rumple did grant her her privacy, thats not enough. She still went 50-60 years without ever seeing her family and friends again.

Are you really saying that if Emma decided to ditch her family and live forever with Killian and baby Swan-Jones you would not be angry?