Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-26443838-20161212210741/@comment-25926288-20170331161838

And all of that's fairly dramatic when she can use magic. I can buy what you're selling and it's fairly reasonable, but in my mind, with three magic wielding sorceresses in tow could easily locate Hook to make sure he isn't dead or something.

It seems weird that Emma would be quick to react with "Oh well, he's gone forever. Clearly, he abandoned me." I mean, she told Neal she wished he was dead and Neal still tried.

Like, have someone check his ship or something to see if he's okay. I'm like not the biggest Hook fan or CS person, but I can't see this as anything comparable to "I wil always find you". But I'll have to wait for the episode to see it in full context. The scene just paints it as if Emma has packed his stuff away and has given up all hope in what looks to be a few days at best.