Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-1962215-20140316231135/@comment-7720627-20151221025335

And! he only DID that to get his dagger back from Zelena, so he could be out from under her control over him... bc as logn as she posessed it, she had total control over Rumple, hense the street fight Zelena gave Regina, only that she lost the fight when Regina gave her heart to Robin to hide, only he lost her heart to Rumple when he almost killed Roland. Hence bc of the dagger been under Zelena's control, her reign ended after Regina defeated her w/light magic. So that's why Rumple seduced Zelena, and if he was Jonathan. Rumple would've remember unless Cora conjured up some memory potion and tricked Rumple into drinking it, and thats how Rumple didn't know. Besides others have said previously. That would be gross and very horrific, bc this IS NOT GameOfThrones and if were, more main characters would be dead by now. justsaying