Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24589671-20141208022047/@comment-24138799-20141209144720

DarlingDavies wrote: Another though on Shattered Sight. I watched it again last night and pinpointed something that confused me.

-After Emma and Ingrid nearly get run over by the car, they then discuss powers and magic and special qualities. When Emma rejected this from Ingrid, there was no magical memory pulling. So did Emma continue growing up w/ memories of that specific day and that specific conversation? IF SO, why does she seem so surprised when Henry finds her, many years ago in S1, talking about how she's magical and special? (Well, it's obvious why.  B/c they didn't know then they'd be doing this arc.) BUT why not address it last night? Even when they showed us the flashback of Emma entering the ice cream shop, she knew Ingrid. She was NOT happy to see her.

Long-winded way of asking, Did Emma always remember the conversation on the side of the road about her being special and about magic? My guess, she repressed the memory...