Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-1962215-20140316231135/@comment-1894786-20151208205647

QueenCeline wrote: Anubis16 wrote: Ok, this is a weird theory, but what if Rumple WAS Jonathan and he got Cora pregnant to prevent her from being with Leopold as part of his plan, what do you think? Problem; Rumple didn't even know Zelena existed until she found him. When she claimed herself as Cora's daughter, he believed she was lying until he tested her. Besides that, if he were Johnathon and he knew Cora's first-born would be powerful, why would he abandon her, instead of marrying her and raising their daughter, thereofre putting the much-desired child under his authority and watch? This. That would make no sense for Rumple as a character, or timeline-wise.