Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5521796-20130130052521/@comment-6845276-20130306060551

Okay, hook gave auroras heart back because he didn't want a woman to lose a heart from him. He didn't want to split the group up. I don't know where you got that idea. If he wanted to win that fight he could have killed emma but he literally bent over backwards to save auroras heart and he spent to whole fight flirting with emma. I do think it was wrong going after belle. But hook is so set on revenge for 300 years. Rumple didn't take it out on hook that Milah left him. He killed Milah right in front of hook. Hook didn't kill belle, he shot her for her to lose her memory. And no I don't have very select memory. Did you hear JMO said when that guy asked "what are the charmings going to do, if emma STARTS looking at hook the wrong way." Jmo said starts. Plus after Ginny comments colin said "what's wrong with that." And the writers said "it was 300 years ago.