Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20161205051618/@comment-24674051-20161206181143

I think I would disagree with that assessment. While David taking the necessary action to possess the lamp is motivated by (A), the actual choice of wish has nothing to do with the Queen's wish. It was simply a carefully (or maybe not so carefully) crafted wish for the Queen to get what she deserved. The results of David's wish should not be considered as the price of the first wish.

Gideon's appearance, on the other hand, is the fulfillment of David's wish, since Gideon is the force that transformed Queenie to a Snake. Unfortunately, Gideon is also the force destined to confront and kill Emma, thus becoming the price of David's wish.

The price for Queenie's wish is likely to be related to either something that happens in the Wish Realm, or something that Emma brings back with her. And if I had to guess, based on the foreshadowing of Queenie at Robin's grave, the price will probably have something to do with Robin.