Thread:Nightlily/@comment-2153169-20150928180008/@comment-2153169-20150928225942

Well, I'm gonna disagree with that name format. Yes, I do see with it is easier for Lily. But to me, this discussion is a way more important. To me, it is more about what is better for the image moderator or the community. Let me explain my point of view.

I think that the biggest majority of our users - including our most present ones or even me - do not know all dialogues from the episodes. So this format name would create a lot of problems for the users:
 * With the current policy, the name is supposed to describe the picture. When an user wants to find a pic in one our list, like a gallery, they will only find a list of dialogues from the episode, which would never help them to find easily the pic they want (unless they know perfectly the transcript of each episode?). When someone is trying to find a pic, especially a new user, they will want a description of the pic, they will have the idea of the scene in their heads, and they will try to find it. So, if the name is a description of the pic, it is gonna be easier. Not with dialogues.
 * Again, that's like we're asking our users to know perfectly every transcript. Like really.
 * With dialogues, we have a lot of confusing situations. And the best exemple is this one: http://onceuponatime.wikia.com/wiki/File:116PrinceJames.png The pic is clearly named "Prince James". All people, who do not know about the potential new name format, will never guess that it is a reference to the dialogue of the scene. When it'll see Prince James in the name of the pic, it will naturally think that the pic is of or related to Prince James; which is not the case at all. Yeah we see a bit of Charming, but seriously, that's nothing and not the main point of the pic. Clearly, this name for this pic is too confusing.
 * A lot of users already had problems with our image policies, especially because of the sources. This is a good thing, do not make me say what I did not said ^^ But, for a lot of people, it is already hard enough to upload pics. So now, we would also force them to check dialogues of their pic before the uploading? I find that quite discouraging, for a critical situation. If we continue to have too many hard policies about the pic, well nobody except the "old" users will continue to upload. And worst, it could give the image that we are a too strict wiki, so it could create some fear to some new users.

So yeah, to me this discussion is a bit more about doing what is better for the image moderator or the community, especially our new users. And my opinion will go with the community: it is our job to make the wiki as easy as possible for everyone; not to make it full of policies that could affraid our users.

By the way, I do remember that before Lily, Nat was doing some galleries by herself. Yes, not full time but still, she did it by herself and she had no problem. I mean, even before her, all people who did these galleries never got a problem. Yeah, it could mean that it is a little harder for them, but if it makes the situation easier for the others users, should not it be a good reason?

Yeah, keeping descriptions as name for the images would make the situation much more easier for a lot of people. Much more that the number of people would have their situation easier with the dialogues as names. I'm not saying we should not allowed dialogues as names. But as the name format for all pics? Definitely no. Remember, most of the users do not know all dialogues or transcript of each episode.

I may find more arguments later, so I'll do another comment ^^ That's all for now :)