Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25703966-20141117114535/@comment-24138799-20141124125001

TheSamTrickster wrote: These theories are just ridiculous, I mean theories are good, but people you should know what a good theory is and what a bad theory is. Henry being the sorcerer, how can he exist if the future has not taken place yet, you can't be well ahead of you past, if that make sense, but you know what i'm saying. And having the sorcerer as the author, I crossed it out long time ago BECAUSE:


 * If the sorcerer manipulated these characters  to get something, it doens't make sense because if he is indeed the author, if he is already that powerful to influence someone else's life, he should be able to get everything he wants.


 * If he is the author seeking for power, it's not hard to write story about rumple or any dark one, write that he himsefl will be the dark one's undoing and kill rumple with the dagger and become the dark one if he needed that more magic.


 * If he is the author, why won't he just write about himself gaining so much power via his own calculative, and great writing imagination.

The theory that he wrote these stories because he wanted something to happen which in turn get him something he is seeking is bull. lol. This is probably the most common response I get "It happens because he wants it to happen" just to reinforce the notion that he is indeed the author of the book. lol. For one thing Mary margaret made the most sense out of all of you. She said the book gives people hope, and Regina said the book is imbued with magic. So It makes more sense that the book provides help to those in need via givng them hope.

Scenario #1, The book popped out of MM's closet when henry needed hope the most.

Senario #2, The book popped out when Henry needed to believe in season 3.

Scenario #3, The book magically placed a page of alternate story about regina and robin hood in hi satchel, and this took place after MM told Regina to hope, that she is in charge of her own destiny. She told regina that the reason she became a villain was due to the choice she's made, and THAT DEARIE, is true. Now Regina has been trying to change since season 2, and now its paying off. SO IT MAKES MORE SENSE TO HAVE THEMSELVES AS THEIR OWN AUTHOR ,rather than someone writing their destiny, MM hinted at this Theme so many times. omg get over that Sorcerer is the author just because he is so mysterious. I was thinking the Sorcerer was the author, but I recently started doubting that theory (only because it was getting too obvious, though, but your arguments are a lot more convincing XD). But there is just one small thing. A&E stated somewhere (don't ask me where, I don't remember) that the author of the book is someone we are going to meet and not someone we already know, which kinda rules out Regina, or Snow, or Henry, or whoever... Though I love your theory about the characters being their own author, I don't think that is going to be the case. But still, thanks for getting me over my doubts about the Sorcerer. I don't have any idea who it can be though, but I won't make any theories of my own. I just want to be surprised when they find him/her...