Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5679696-20161205034133/@comment-24674051-20161219172200

We are trying to discuss the history of the Wish Realm, but lets keep in mind that the Wish Realm did not even exist until Queenie used her first Genie wish. It would not have been effected by the Dark Curse simply because it did not exist when the Dark Curse was cast. the "history" of the Wish Realm inhabitants is completely fabricated, up to the point where Emma enters. From that point forward, it does have a history of its own.

Now, the question about the source used to fabricate the history of the wish realm is somewhat valid, because the inhabitants do have "memories" of events in the past. But I think this may be very similar to how all of the Residents of Storybrooke had "memories" of thier lives prior to the casting of the DArk Curse. In "Welcome to Storybrooke", which is the basically during the first week of Storybrooke's existence, the residents had "memories", albeit false ones.

So the source of the Wish Realm History may very well be from Emma and what she knows of the EF. or put another way, it is the history of the EF according to Emma. Which would allow for some events to be different, since Emma does not know everything that happened. Plus, her own life would be based on her perception of what growing up as a princess would be.