Thread:Nightlily/@comment-2153169-20150928180008/@comment-5465982-20150929140609

I don't think it'll create problems like Lady said. And there is no need for users to know all dialogues from the episodes. Lady Junky wrote: When users try to find pictures, they go to the galleries and they can very easy find the picture they want right there. I really don't think that users, if they wanna find a picture, will click on "Alter the Story" so they'll see the names and search through all the names of the images to find one name which matches with the picture he/she had in mind. Who does that? IF they wanna use a picture, so they do need to know the name, then I guess they'll click on the image and copy the name or maybe hover like Lily said or open the image in another window which will also show the name. Lady Junky wrote: The name is indeed confusing if you don't know that it's a reference to the dialogue of the scene. But I think most users don't care about the names and don't even know or notice the name if you don't need it, they only care about the picture itself. And if they need it then they prob just copy the name. But if that is a problem for the users, then maybe we should add to the policies that confusing names are not allowed or something, although I think it's not really necessary, but yeah. Lady Junky wrote: I'm not old xD. I think we're already a strict wiki and indeed a lot users have problems because of the sources :). But force them extra to check dialogues? When you take a screencap you know what they just said in the dialogue, no? xD So it's not difficult at all I guess..
 * With the current policy, the name is supposed to describe the picture. When an user wants to find a pic in one our list, like a gallery, they will only find a list of dialogues from the episode, which would never help them to find easily the pic they want (unless they know perfectly the transcript of each episode?). When someone is trying to find a pic, especially a new user, they will want a description of the pic, they will have the idea of the scene in their heads, and they will try to find it. So, if the name is a description of the pic, it is gonna be easier. Not with dialogues.
 * Again, that's like we're asking our users to know perfectly every transcript. Like really.
 * With dialogues, we have a lot of confusing situations. And the best exemple is this one: http://onceuponatime.wikia.com/wiki/File:116PrinceJames.png The pic is clearly named "Prince James". All people, who do not know about the potential new name format, will never guess that it is a reference to the dialogue of the scene. When it'll see Prince James in the name of the pic, it will naturally think that the pic is of or related to Prince James; which is not the case at all. Yeah we see a bit of Charming, but seriously, that's nothing and not the main point of the pic. Clearly, this name for this pic is too confusing.
 * A lot of users already had problems with our image policies, especially because of the sources. This is a good thing, do not make me say what I did not said ^^ But, for a lot of people, it is already hard enough to upload pics. So now, we would also force them to check dialogues of their pic before the uploading? I find that quite discouraging, for a situation which could be quite easier. If we continue to have too many hard policies about the pic, well nobody except the "old" users will continue to upload. And worst, it could give the image that we are a too strict wiki, so it could create some fear to some new users.

So I actually don't really see any problems for the users. Maybe that confusing thing but the current policiy also allows those names :s.