Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-1962215-20140317132636/@comment-24894881-20150917041228

I still think "Kill counts" is too simple to use as a conclusion because you are still leaving out context of all the characters and collectivising them. For example, it's virtually impossible for Pan to kill as many people as the others, because he resided on a small island with barely any population. But once he was in Storybrooke he planned on killing all the protagonists and taking control over the whole town, his true evil was showing then. Also Cruella's context must be taken into account on the fact she wasn't able to kill.

I think judging it on psychology and redeemable qualities is more fair, and in that department, Pan and Cruella win it easily.