Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-67.142.173.24-20130130005341/@comment-6267274-20130208172214

I've been thinking about that too. After some consideration, the lie was pretty evident, and if he was texting, probably Emma would have noticed when she checked the phone. And just think of all the grim thoughts of Grumpy about letting him die. Perhaps she lied as well to let everyone calm down.