Board Thread:Rant and Rave/@comment-24593235-20171014032523/@comment-27060727-20171014183652

CoolDudeAl wrote: Farerb wrote: So I guess if Regina just walked around and killed people then it is fine because she did it in the past... It's not okay, but it's a fact about her character. If she already killed 500 people, are we really going to get hung up about 501 and 502, especially when Regina didn't see them as real people when she killed them? The contradiction was when 6x11 aired, A&E said that what Regina did in the Wish Realm did not matter because Wish Snow and Wish Charming were not real. They straight up said they weren't real. They weren't even brushing off another Regina murder, the realm wasn't real so it's like it shouldn't have existed after Emma woke up and left.

However, one episode later, they brought in Wish Robin and proclaimed that he was real. And now we have two wish characters living outside of the wish realm and they're both "real." It looks like they changed the rules of the wish realm to keep using two characters/actors. But I think we all could've come up with ways for them to have brought back Robin in 6B (like if he was a ghost coming to give Regina closure) and Hook in S7 (like having Rogers be the real Hook), instead of them piling on with the inconsistencies.