Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-25337271-20141030124727/@comment-1894786-20141109213229

DarKingdomHearts wrote: Edward Zachary Sunrose wrote: Andrew Robbins wrote: Well, I think this is an interesting thought. I don't think Ice Anna deserves a page but I think that she should be listed in the Magic page. As for the Ice Warrior, I already listed him on the Storybrooke Characters page, but I can't list Marshmallow because since the name Marshmallow is never given onscreen it's not considered canon. Overall, I don't think a page should be created for the ice creatures/snowmen, but I think that they should be listed in the "Magic" page (like Ice Anna). The entire Frozen movie is confirmed by A&E to be canon in the world of OUAT, so Marshmallow is definitely Marshmallow, since that is the same creature and that's its canon name in the movie. That can't be Marshmallow as it was created during the first movie. So how can the ice monster Elsa created in the first episode also be Marshmallow? Unless ice powers include teleportation it isn't Marshamallow (but certainly is based of it) Well, we know Elsa's power can give life to ice creatures (Olaf and Marshmallow). We also know that Marshmallow was destroyed when Hans stormed the ice palace. So a simple explanation could be that Elsa can take one consciousness (the original Marshmallow, who was extremely protective of her) and place it into any ice creature vessel. It looked exactly like Marshmallow, so you're definitely overthinking it. We don't know how ice magic works and we know it's certainly not alive. She probably just revived the first Marshmallow out of nothing.