Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26643527-20160404160929/@comment-24674051-20160404173540

We don't miss the point of the posts, and we are certainly not attacking you or laughing at you. I would respectfully suggest that participation in the threads requires the growth of thicker skin. because we will discuss any idea posted (not just yours), and comment on both the merits and drawbacks of these ideas. It's not personal (if it starts to become personal, that where Esk and I come in with our troll axes)

I looked at the post you started. the concept is interesting, but I don't see that as a direction the story will go.

First, as was pointed out, Neal is in a better place, a place that he is happy. Why would he be reincarnated?

And second (assuming that it is a lie based on the fact that Bae would not be reincarnated), why would Hades choose this lie as a motivating point for Rumple? I will concede that Hades is presented as a trickster, but he is also clever in his use of lies and half-truths? And in this case, Rumple would see right through the lie, which would actually not be a help for Hades.