Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-27060727-20171014181959/@comment-25926288-20171018135239

ChocolatEyes613 wrote: Eskaver wrote: I do love witches, but I seriously doubt Robin is the Witch of NEF as she was around for several years, while Robin is like a toddler currently (plus they can't coexist). Time supposedly runs faster in the NEF.

I agree that Robin being the Witch would be a bit of a copout, but Gideon also seems to be an adult now. Besides, OUaT just loves when its villians have mommy-issues. Not to mention, everyone turns out to be related to Henry somehow. The thing is Robin is literally an infant as Hook-W has a daughter that's already kidnapped by a witch. Robin would need to travel back in time after aging up, which is ridiculous. (In other words, regardless is Hook-W's daughter aged naturally or sprung into existence by the wish, we literally saw baby Robin toted around by her mum. XD)