Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-4427410-20151029170105/@comment-25926288-20151029182706

The lack of rational is funny/ Emma's not going to return a car that Neal stole and then gave to her because it was like a decade ago. The Second car probably was Lily's or noone's and they had to stop theft of the bug.

Secondly, they can't rent a car because technically it would be taking a car for someone who doesn't exist and paid with money that doesn't exist in a town noone knows exists.

Like it or not, Emma and David are the law enforcement of SB. Emma and David can go after Cruella and Ursula because they went to a shop and something went reported missing as they left the shop. David took the staff from Bo Peep and tried to find a missing person. If he returned it? We won't know, but I'm sure she has it back because it's not like he said he was taking it forever. Plus, it was a weapon that Bo Peep used for extortion, which is a crime.