Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-2153169-20170909025746/@comment-25375217-20171030190126

Eskaver wrote: From 7x05 synopsis, Eloise Gardener appears to be the Missing Girl that Rogers/Hook-W is looking for.

Even more confusing! Perhaps Eloise is really just Rapunzel, but that would be a bit  underwhelming, given filming spoilers. I'm still holding out hope that Eloise is the Mystery Woman (coming later) and that Lady Tremaine is Rapunzel. Okay, so going by definitive (confirmed on the show), apparent (confirmed by occasionally faulty press materials), assumed (backed up by things seen on the show or in press materials), and speculated (loosely backed up by things seen on the show or in press materials), we have: So, therefore, we can safely deduce that Alice, the Witch, Rapunzel, and Tremaine are all the same person!
 * Definitive: Whook is looking for his daughter
 * Definitive: Rogers is looking for a girl
 * Apparent: Rogers is looking for Eloise Gardener
 * Assumed: Eloise Gardener is the Witch
 * Assumed: Alice/Tilly is Whook's daughter
 * Speculated: The Witch is Mother Gothel
 * Speculated: Rapunzel is Whook's daughter
 * Speculated: Tremaine is Rapunzel

...Something's off here.