Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-34360784-20180116101248/@comment-1916997-20180117050920

DatNuttyKid wrote: I agree that we cannot list Alice and Brennan on the other Hook's pages.

How do you know that everyone in the Wish Realm has the same parents? All we saw is that Emma and Henry did. No one else was given a family tree. There is absolutely no evidence for that assumption except inductive reasoning (I think I'm using that term correctly) -- because it was true once, it MUST be true every other time.

Except we know inductive reasoning doesn't apply to the Wish Realm. Using inductive reasoning, Snow, Charming, Emma, Hook, and Pinocchio have all aged for the 28 years they would have been under the curse, so, therefore, everyone must have aged for those 28 years. And yet, Robin of Locksley exists, the same age he was after being frozen for 28 years. Furthermore, his history is different as Marian died before he became Robin Hood and they were never married.

It's always safer and more encyclopedic to not assume when there is no clear evidence. And in this case, all we have is inductive reasoning, and that's not enough. Ages are very different from people's biological parents, we know ages can be altered with magic, but we haven't seen anything about changing parents with magic. Furthurmore, we have clear evidence from the show that Hook and WHook have the same past, as WHook states it on the show.