Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26785424-20160317041645/@comment-26785424-20160317194208

Nakis91 wrote: I like that but once again someone will lose his memories? It's getting boring... With my theory, Hook could be saved with ether option, both are bittersweet. If he goes back reincarnated, he would have a fresh start. He'd have no memory of Emma' and none of his pirating days and the stuff (I think) he regrets doing.

On the other hand Hook's in Underbrook, which means he has unfinished business. Maybe it knowing Emma accepted that he dead and can't came back with his memories and that while missing him, will let him go. And Hook will move on to wherever he go's (a better or worse place) keeping his memories of her.

But as Hmcooper4 said in post above, they will try to find a third option. Emma said something about giving Hook half of her heart. I'm not sure if that would work if their in Underworld.