Board Thread:Show-Related Questions and Answers/@comment-184.155.191.147-20130219200757/@comment-6195464-20130219230850

Firstly, I think it's safe to assume it's Henry... considering August isn't a -boy- and wasn't a boy when he pretended to be Bae (which was where the theory stemmed from). Secondly, I don't think (from his conversation with Henry) that Rumple ever discovered how to work out the puzzle, so I don't think he uses the gift. He almost seemed afraid of it.