Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24674051-20151117184714/@comment-24674051-20151118201040

are we SURE that the hat, stars, and heart are the counterspell. The hat and stars, maybe. but the Heart? How would Ingrid have gotten that information? WHY would she even care about that information? I think she pulled something out of the air to make her deal with Rumple.

Also, the Apprentice used the hat without the heart to seperate the Darkness from Rumple.

But none of that explains HOW EMma hid the fact that Killian was the second dark one for the few days in Storybrooke that have passed. (I don't expect that there was any effort to hide this in Camelot).