Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-141.114.141.147-20130322034037/@comment-75.147.221.93-20130322191253

In my opinion the only thing that Geppetto did wrong was forced Blue Fairy to lie about the amount of people who can go through it. There is little to excuse that he could give that can excuse for that action except apologize. Which he was doing when Mary Margrette punched him. I don't think it was right course of action for her to punch the man, but I do understand why she did it.

To find out there was a way for her to be with her daughter, would make anyone angry, but I don't think her knowing that the wardrobe could fit 2 people would have changed anything. In the end of the day she along with the entire enchanted forest needed Geppetto to make the wardrobe. Unfortunatly in order to get him to do the work, they had to agree to allow Pinocchio to go through it. If they didn't like price he named, they could have asked someone else. Mind you it would be very difficult since there weren't many people around who was skilled in using enchanted wood, but still there was an alternate option.

We don't know how the curse would have affected Pinnochio, and there is a good chance that he would have turned into a puppet. Even if that wasn't the case, at the time none of the character would know how the 7 year old kid would be affected. Honestly people do you really think Snow White would allow a 7 year old kid to be turned into a puppet, because Evil Queen hates her guts. Mind you the choice should have been hers, but if she was allowed to choose I think she would have allowed Pinnochio to  come to our world instead of herself. This is the same woman that allowed Regina to live, even though it would be in everyone best interest to have her be excuted. I am not excusing what Geppetto did, all I am say where or not everyone knew that another person could have traveled through the wardrobe. It didn't matter since the results would have been the same.