Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-15736398-20140815200340/@comment-15736398-20140816033350

The problem with the idea you're putting forth is that, when it comes to Emma's age, A&E have been realistically consistent on that front from the very beginning of the series, and have built all of the other concrete dates we have for the series off of that one basic fact (how old she is and when she was born). Suggesting that she was 'estimating' in her conversation with Ashley as to how old she was when she had Henry or that the information we have about her isn't actually important when it comes to establishing a chronology and continuity for the series is to dismiss all of that consistency as being irrelevant, thereby undermining the entire narrative framework of the series as it's been established to date.