Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26971388-20160506013943/@comment-26443838-20161122172134

Hmcooper4 wrote: Definitly not Emma. Putting aside the situation with Cruella (which even being justified still taints the heart somewhat), you have all of her street rat actions from growing up (including stealing her beloved bug) to consider.

Also, the darkness itself may be gone, but that does not free her from her actions as the Dark One. She ripped out the heart of her son's girlfriend, which actually puts her in the same league as Cora (though not fully, since Emma didn't kill Violet, just controlled her), and that was before she had succombed to the darkness. And she sped up Zelena's pregnancy and threatened cold blooded murder. Not to mention that she almost left Baby Robin an orphan, just like Regina did to her, or what Isaac did to Lily by making the Charmings and the Apprentice condeming her (even before the Charmings undid his damage by reuniting mother and daughter after Emma failed), or when Hook left Liam 2 as an orphan (before Nemo took him under his wing). Like all those villains, Emma almost completely became one of the most dangerous of all villains, an orphan maker.

Some of the pure hearted folks I saw were Snowing. I mean they were the only ones were able to go through Glinda's door. Which seems to signal that that little darkness didn't last long.