Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-1916997-20180306163804/@comment-27060727-20180403150916

Eskaver wrote: Can we figure this out?

So, Emma, Age 35, saw her son leave. Emma waited until she was 47 (Emma was roughly 30 when Robin was born) and now she’s 48 and have her baby.

Emma also was roughly 29/30 when Neal was born, so Neal was 18/19 at Hope’s birth.

Right? I'm going to still assume Emma is at/under 40 at the time of Hope's birth. Don't know how, but I don't think they'd have her pregnant near 50 - I just don't see it.

And if I am to believe that, I'm going to also say that Neal is still a young child and is closer to Hope's age than Robin's. (Maybe someone will be able to confirm this today) This entire season, fans have been theorizing numerous time travel/progression theories to explain away the inconsistencies - perhaps the writers will throw us a bone and something will actually come into play. What they've established about Robin is what we have the most trouble reconciling with everything else, right? She's the SB transplant with the weird aging.