Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-27060727-20160824022100/@comment-25926288-20161027213928

Avatar Beta wrote: I'm actually with Regina on this one, regardless of her motives. Hook has shown himself to be ill-fitting in the role of surogate father{Baefire is proof}  and he HAS hurt the Charmings before, the Underworld being the most recent. What? Hook has shown how great a dad he'll be! What do you mean offscreen?!

Sarcasm aside, EQ is right. She approached him with intents to manipulate (and not scare) and all she's doing is exposing people's secrets. (Which is ironically what she hates)

As discussed in Hook-Emma thread, Hook recently has shown positive things, but a ton of negative things in the way of their relationship. Hook and Henry seem to get along fine. They do several activities together (mostly offscreen). But Hook recently almost killed his family (and him! Hook actually talked to him directly too! (I think)). He was sad Hook died and Hood, but that's likely do to amicable bonding and mostly his respective mother's happiness.

Henry tries to defend Hook, but he not all gung-ho. This random secret doesn't help. Sadly, I think that if Emma finds out, it'll change little.