Thread:Lady Junky/@comment-26967699-20180420193902/@comment-2153169-20180420195309

That's something that should be discussed then.

As I talked about it with Lily, there is absolutely nothing suggesting that the Blind Witch could not be a member of the Coven before the events of 717. Yes, she went to live to the NEF after these events, but again it means nothing. Living in the NEF and being part of the Coven is not the same thing.

I am the one who changed the history section of the BW to reflect that. And the Coven history does not mention the events of Oz, so I don't know which history section supports this, as you mentioned it.

There is no way to know for sure when she joined them, so rather than speculate about that, I personally think it is safer to go with what we know. The BW was a member of Coven, at some point in her life; that's sure. And the possibility that she was already a member is real, so I think it is better to not ignore it :)