Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25417848-20150512005654/@comment-4453062-20150512033356

The main plot hole with the whole Shady Snow and Charming twist is that this secret never came up during the Echo Cave scene in Neverland. In the Echo Cave, you're supposed to reveal your deepest darkest secret. I would think what they did to Maleficent and Lily would be that deepest darkest secret. The only explanation I can think of is that you had to reveal "a" secret, but it didn't have to be a specific one.