Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-4962906-20151202102456/@comment-27138802-20151202181318

Joshleung wrote: I just dont understand.

Emma fight the darkness successfully.why cant he? It really highlights the differences between Rumple and Hook. Rumple has did some shady things to Belle, but he has never called her names and outright want to hurt her.

Hook did tell her he couldn't fight the darkness. And I think ironically the writers and the character himself is telling us that he never truly changed in the first place. Heck, the only appearance change was messier hair.

How could Emma ever go back to him? She has broken her son's heart, put her family in harm's way that switched on her so quickly. I think it just shows how superficial that relationship is.