Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-1916997-20150926195527/@comment-25926288-20151002125901

NH, I think everyone here knows I'm not a Hook fan, but I'm a logical one. I rather he fade away into oblivion, but he's not.

You are ignoring the fact that Hokm was on the roof, called Emma, jumped, then had a scene with Emma. Clearly he is alive. I would hope he broke every bone in his body, but that's not what happened. Anyway, they would never let s death be spoiled. How do I know? They tried to close off the set when Peter Pan and Rumple died. Other deaths are in a studio, etc.

They already said Hook is good at surviving and we already see that he's talking to Emma afterwards. If he was dead, I'm sure he wouldn't be alive talking to Emma. Logic ftw!