Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-26785424-20151013025944/@comment-25926288-20151030144751

Ray Donovan wrote: Eskaver wrote: Hook's denial of loving Emma and her darkness when Emma did love him and his darkness is something to be mad about. However, I view him in a slightly better light as the person that still sees Emma as a type conquest (him saying otherwise was a forced part, Show, don't tell). He even said he loved to break down her walls. He loves Emma for what she does for him and if Emma changes (as people do) he drops her like a hot pot and tells her to cool off.

Overall, Hook went from innuendo pirate with a small bond with Emma to a lost puppy dog to angsty bad boy.

Robin is growing on me when he has a scene without Regina. Let Regina carry her mirror around and he'd be pretty much the same. Robin clearly showed a little apprehension of having Regina find out that he's happy because of how irrational she can be. Then what does he see in her besides the motherly instinct, sass, and beauty..,.......nothing else, it seems. We have no clue what Regina sees in him besides a Fairy told me.

But Robin I do like a bit when he's separate. New to the board but THANK YOU for pointing out Hook's hypocrisy. He hasn't changed that much himself. His relationship with Emma is more about himself an dhis happieness, and the writing supports this. Hook is  a boring character now that his only existance is a love interest. Even Colin in an interview months ago admitted how much he missed playing Season 2 Captain Hook.

Well, you're welcome. The theme of the past couple of seasons is apparently hypocrisy. Apparently all the characters are hypocrites from Regina to Hook to Emma to Snow to David to everyone major.

Fans seem polarized between tow characters, Regina and Hook. They love one and hate the other when in fact they are pretty much going the same way in terms of redemption but take time to switch off plots. I think it all comes down to either bad writing or confused morals and ideas of romance.