Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-34563899-20180218220444/@comment-91424-20180220010020

Emillian Swanones wrote: Contraceptives (magical or not) would have existed in the EF. There is just no way, Neal, at the age he was (200) wouldn't have known about them. It's also possible he knew about STDs. Both of them would have been aware that Emma could get pregnant, yet instead of using protection he told it would be okay. This is based on when Emma told Mary Margaret (I think) that it'll be okay is a poor form of birth control.

I'm not a fan of Neal, but he never said anything like that to Emma. The scene you are referring to does not exist. You must be misremembering.