Board Thread:Show-Related Questions and Answers/@comment-24243167-20131224102233/@comment-4975807-20131231034543

Tristan Shelton wrote: If you all would look at both counterparts of Rumpel you would see that it says he is still alive in the Enchanted Forest but dead in Storybrooke. He's still listed as "alive" on Rumplestiltskin's page because the wiki counts counterparts separately even though he is the same person as Mr. Gold. Mr. Gold is counted as dead because Rumplestiltskin technically died as Mr. Gold and not as his FTL counterpart. Same deal with the Huntsman and Graham. He died as Graham, so Graham is counted as dead. The Huntsman is still considered alive in the past sense since he is Graham's former identity.