Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-28162607-20180101191335/@comment-31231929-20180101211641

I think that all the redemptions on the show have been good (I'm not counting Rumple in here since I think that his redemption is ongoing), but that Killian's was the best overall. If the show had ended with Season 6, I think Rumple's redemption would be the worst. I like the fact that even though the time spent redeeming villains and how villainous they've been has varied, all the redemptions arcs have centered around three things: realize you've done bad things, stop hurting people, start helping people. I think the best short-term redemption arc was Ingrid's and the best long-term arc was Killian's. I think the second best redemption arc overall was Regina's.