Board Thread:Show-Related Questions and Answers/@comment-24942479-20151207104557/@comment-27284036-20151209025619

Good question. I guess it all depends on when/how they were separated but, from what I can tell, we viewers never even see this part. At the beginning of S5E11, Dark Hook claims to have stolen the dagger from Rumple, but (part from the scenes in the Enchanted Forest) the sword has been intact/complete in every scene since the Dark Swan put it back together.

Have I missed something? Would be glad of any info/theories people have to solve this one!