Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-7526254-20150520160921/@comment-25926288-20150812030517

Edward Zachary Sunrose wrote: Nightlily wrote: No, we're not. Sorry, but that's not what the show says. According to Mother Superior's missing person form, she was reported missing on November 12., and the current events take place a few months later. As I said: The policy on the wiki, is that whenever the show creators or cast members say something that is contradicted by the show, then we go with what the show says. The show itself is the number one canon, and trumps anything else. You mean the set dressing that was never supposed to be focused on? LOL Well then why does Heart Of Gold, which takes place just a week later at most, say Rumple is in the hospital on Christmas on his heart monitor? I personally don't put any stock in set dressing (like Regina calling her apples Honeycrisps, when they're actually Red Delicious), and will definitely take Adam's word over props that we weren't meant to focus on. But the policies......

I guess Rumple did a whole lot of walking to New York until he discovered he could just catch a bus XD Unless he made it to Neal's apartment a week before leaving with Cruella and Ursula.....I have no clue. And no celebration of Christmas!!! I'll have to give that some hard thinking. I usually put stock in Adam and Eddy and the writers because they write the show, because otherwise, the show contradict itself. I mean Robn says he met Rumple once, when he didn't. Hook has amnesia and thinks Emma told him about something when he was in the actual scene when it happened. Rumple also didn't "know" the Wicked Witch. I guess when the show contradicts itself....we follow the writers, I guess.