Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-6175354-20161010033114/@comment-26443838-20161117183113

Farerb wrote: NickyHelp wrote: Farerb wrote: DatNuttyKid wrote: Farerb wrote:

DatNuttyKid wrote:

Farerb wrote: I don't want it to be Hook. He doesn't need more terrible secrets from his past only to be forgotten and swept under the rug. You mean like how Hook leaving Liam an orphan was never brought up again? Or more like how Regina murdered Graham with no repercussions? Just curious what backstories you find inappropriately done and which ones are perfectly fine. So do you take me for a Regina apologist? No, both of them did terrible thing, both of them are terrible people, whose relationships with the herocrites don't make sense. I'm still waiting for them to go to an anbiased policemen and confess their crimes like murdering people and actually pay for them if they feel so bad about it. Retribution is still a part of redemption and they didn't do it so they are not redeemed. I guess that's the difference between you and me. I think that redemption is only a matter of forgiveness. I don't see the reason to go through a million punishments if they already have admitted their crimes and shown signs of not committing them again, it seems like unnecessary torture for someone who already has to deal with the emotional strain of what they did.

And I'm sure Graham and Merlin understand it, oh wait, they can't cause their dead.

Please watch Angel. And murdered by cold blood. I didn't see any forgiveness for Hook and Regina for that. Probably not yet. And after all, A&E informed that if ever that Emma finds out that Regina murdered Graham, she would take the issue with it.

It's not going to happen. The writers aren't going to acknowledge Regina killing Graham or Hook doing anything wrong because it conflicts with Emma supposedly being about Justice, well she's not anymore but they don't want to address it, especially not directly, because they are bad writers who have no idea of the concept of justice and redemption. Emma doesn't seek justice regarding them and they are "redeemed" because like DNK says they say they are heroes now and that's what matters or whatever, which is nonesense. You don't know that.