Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-7526254-20170430003451/@comment-27934866-20181002012109

Schroeswald wrote:

1. Take that up with the wiki but we have the WR in the UR currently. This would mean that the NFTL is in the UR, presumably she loves Ella and Lucy, both NEF characters and this just breaks your arguèment apart. 2. This is possible and I understand this argument for faster NEF time. This once again hurts the case you were making because this means it is after the DC was cast no paradox needed.

3.See above

4.I agree that Regina hadn’t left when the DC was cast, once again the OP case is hurt by your argument.

5.We have no clue how long they were gone in Storybrooke time but this again hurts your case.

6. The Final Battle takes place in 2015, Henry is 14, see Lily’s Timeline for that. Those Gold, Belle and Gideon dates are correct.

7. I agree with that

8. We agree on this point.

9.You said 18-19 around the time he calls for family aid you have him at 17/18 when he left Storybrooke, I agree with your new aging or something similar.

1. I know the Wish Realm is on the UR page, but like I said there's no difference between the Main Reality, and the Wish Realm except Regina never cast the Dark Curse in the Wish Realm so besides the history none of the other realms would be any different in appearance. However I did look at some photos of the United Realms and the tower where Alice was trapped, and the Troll are present.

2. The Seattle events are late 2017 that much has been confirmed. Henry gets a phone call in early 2018 from his older self, plus Adult Henry confirms he got the same phone call when he was younger so you've got a Predestination Paradox. February/March is around the time of acceptance, rejection, and waitlist letters so this would be around the time of his graduation. So he wouldn't be due to leave Storybrooke yet since the Seattle Curse is broken shortly afterward and he's on a graduation trip with Emma and Regina at the time. Since school starts in September he would be 16/17 at the time he leaves because Henry's birthday is October 15th. This causes some confusion with the time of Hope's conception because we'd actually be looking at late 2018/early 2019. Early 2019 would be the more logical explanation because when Emma tells Henry she's pregnant, she's no more than 3 months along. So if the 1 month = 1 year is correct that would make things even more logical because Henry would be 21/22, and as you said he wouldn't of grown into a full grown adult after 2 years.

3. See above.

4. Regina wasn't in the NEF that much is clear. However if she'd of united the realms immediately afterward then it would be like Season 7 never happened. One possibility that has been bugging me is could she have united the realms without upsetting past events? Another possibility that hit me while writing this is well the United Realms look like the ultimate version of Disney World but only certain areas from the realms are present e.g. Regina's Castle, Charmings Castle, Emerald City etc. Is it possible that the area's in the United Realms are copies taken from the realms they originate from?

5. Robin's 18 when she summons Gothel, and when Regina goes to find her and Zelena at Emerald Acres Farm, Robin tells Regina she's 25. However when Robin and Alice go to get help from Storybrooke she tells Zelena that it's her 5 year old self in the car which seems a bit unlikely since she was born late 2015

6. I have checked Lily's Timeline and everything points back to the late Season 7 events happening before the events of A Pirate's Life. Fiona does say that Henry is 14 I grant you, the only logical explanation I can think of is that her curse has changed reality slightly where the inhabitants of Storybrooke are under the impression Henry is only 14 whereas Henry retains his memories.

7. Case closed.

8. Case closed.

9. The reason I said 18/19 is because there are several young characters played by older actors. Plus Tiera Skovbye is 23 but she plays 18 year old, 25 year old, and 27/28 year old Robin