Talk:Rocinante/@comment-24304025-20180507170246/@comment-25375217-20180722163922

I don't see how Pongo/Cinder is the same circumstance? First of all, the discussion over there is unresolved. Secondly, though, every appearance of Pongo is definitely Pongo -- even if he's played by a different dog. This is kind of the exact opposite circumstance, where it is definitely the same horse "actor" but never said to be Rocinante. And honestly, I still think if it was Rocinante, Regina would have actually called him by name.

Cinder should not be credited when it's obviously not him, but that really doesn't have anything to do with whether or not Rocinante appeared in the Underworld.