Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20171014005708/@comment-25375217-20171020003828

Edward Zachary Sunrose wrote: DatNuttyKid wrote: ChocolatEyes613 wrote: 8Rob wrote:

The W!Evil Queen created in that land with wish while the SerumQueen was in SB. There was no Evil Queen in the Wish Realm, only the pre-programed memories of her. The information about Wish!Hook's daughter heavily implies that the Wish Realm always existed and the Serum Queen's wish merely provided access to it rather than creating it. There are some other continuity issues resulting from this -- specifically, Robin -- but it's what we have to go by right now. Henry was 13 at the end of Season 6, and is presumably in his early 20's in these flashbacks (since he left home after high school, or at 17-18, and he had to age enough to go from Gilmore to West), meaning a decade could've passed during which Wish!Hook had a daughter.

And the flashbacks themselves are at least 10 years before the present day since Lucy obviously hasn't been born yet and she's 10 in the present day. So Wish!Hook's daughter could be up to 20 years old at this point. Hook had his daughter before he met Emma. He was cursed by the Witch to not be able to love, then when he met Emma he thought she might be able to break the curse.