Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-28011742-20170329211301/@comment-25926288-20170329215836

How does this relate to spoilers? I'll move it to the character discussion board upon this notice.

1. Emma was dramatic, but that's the show in a nutshell. I think they forgot that Emma just had a secret like eight episodes ago. He wasn't mad about it, eventually left it up to her alone. Emma apparently can't reciprocate this action. It's as if DO-Emma is still around.

2. It happened like 50 years ago, not 100, but that's just technical details. It should matter to David, but Emma sort of shafts that away assuming David will be fine with it (which we saw how he almost killed George, I think not). Only Hook actually thinks about her parents in relation to him.

3. Emma isn't ooc. She's just "moved by the plot" or as the plot demands. If the secret was about Hook thinking he was simply unworthy because of his unchanging ways, then they'd still have him kill Robert and just ignore it.

4. Emma should have decided to work with him on it, but give a sigh of exhaustion or look upset. This sigh could make Hook go on a soul-searching journey to see if he really wants to do this together as he did in 6x14 and the rest is up to the show.

5. They aren't broken up. All Emma said was pretty much, "Hook, take some time and think about what you've done. Then, let's work on fixing your mistakes." Hook overreacted a bit when he was going to actually leave her for an indefinite amount of time as it was clear that she expected him to take a day to think over it.