Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24304025-20140602194616/@comment-4877635-20140603184203

FrancisPaul wrote: Yes, it is! XD Unfortunately, it isn't canon. The most obvious telltale sign is that Dr. Whale received a letter from Eric saying that he had just found out his girlfirend was a mermaid but Ariel was never in Storybroooke when the curse was broken and he didn't find out she was a mermaid until after they returned back to the EF. The secon curse didn't take Eric or Ariel so at no point in the show's timeline did Eric know Ariel was a mermaid when they were in Storybrooke.