Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-2153169-20170216190723/@comment-29619010-20170515124121

So, now we know for sure that it's Henry and his daughter. I just want to know how Henry ended up like this. If he does have his memories, he would instantly believe Lucy becuase he did the exact same thing with Emma. That means he is under a curse or a spell or whatever it is that altered his memories - much like the one used on him and Emma in season 3. There's another possibility, that after everyone got their happy beginning in the end of The Final Battle, something horrible happened to his family, making him closed off and lonely, thus him moving away from Storybrooke and going to Seattle, and doesn't want to believe that Lucy is his daughter because - as Gold said - some wounds never fully heal. It brings back too many of his old memories. Though, knowing Henry and his rough childhood and his insecurity about why he thought he was abandoned, he would never leave his daughter and his family, which circles back to the possbility that he got his memory altered. This is just a theory of mine, which I'm praying that isn't true, because we all know for a fact that Henry Mills would never abandon his family, and especially his daughter.