Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5679696-20160516030608/@comment-5106672-20160516042137

Killian Jones wrote:

ONCEFanandHappyHippo wrote: Well, the Evil Queen was Regina's identity before the curse, but the two are present at the same moment, so the Evil Queen in An Untold Story isn't Regina's Enchanted Forest identity, she's Regina's evil identity. I propose that we create a new page and perhaps title it "Regina Mills (Evil Half)" and *maybe* rename the current page for Regina "Regina Mills (Good Half)". No, the Evil Queen is not Regina from the past, it is Regina's uncursed identity. That doesn't necessarily mean "past" or even "a different time". We have been swapping between the pages as she moved from one to another. So far it has been due to the Curses, now we just got another version. And now they are at the same time. This is a bit of a technicality, because Regina retained her original identity to begin with. She probably had some fake memories implanted (at least to the extent of knowing how the LWM functions), but she never lost her identity to gain a new one. We can't make a clear distinction like for, say, Archie and Giminy, or Mother Superior and Blue. Regina Mills and the Evil Queen are effectively the same person – or at least they were until the serum.

With this said, the entries on the subject would be very small at the moment: my suggestion is thus to write them temporarily on the pertaining pages (i.e.: the showdown on both, the trip back to SB on Regina Mills', the showdown with the Dragon on the Evil Queen's) and wait for S6, when we see the two of them in action, to make a final decision.