Board Thread:Show-Related Questions and Answers/@comment-5963744-20130403160708/@comment-6040657-20130404164558

Tuxer wrote: 217.216.32.102 wrote: Interesting theory... and there's that other picture, in which Emma, MM, David and Neal are looking with surprise in Gold's shop.. What they are looking at? Henry's wish or Rumple with a birthday cake? LOL (sorry for bad English). I think it's neither. I think that Rumple brought the memoryless Belle to the shop and Emma, MM, David and Neal are shocked at the slutty clothes she's wearing.

What if Henry's Wish is for Belle to get her memories back, but because of how wishes can be twisted if they are not worded right, the wish brings her Storybrooke Counterparts memories back instead of Belle's... how we get Lacey instead of Belle!