Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-26159109-20151209210031/@comment-25926288-20151210220312

ChocolatEyes613 wrote: NickyHelp wrote:

They said "Every season, we try to evolve Emma a little more." You misinterpreted what was said in that interview. Eddy and Adam want Emma, to take a page out of her parents book. Which means, going to ridiculous lengths to save a loved one.... even when told, to let go.

Remember, Charming did not ask Snow to split her heart and save him. He was willing to die, if it meant that Emma could help save the baby. The same thing happened between them in Neverland. David begged Mary Margaret, to go back to Storybrooke without him. In a way, Snow and Emma believe that love means being together. While, Charming and Hook believe that love means sacrifice. Lol, at your interpretation. Charming thinks Love means being together too. David was being noble all the way through. Hook was a last minute change. Being noble at the last minute doesn't make you noble.

It's like a fireman argument:

If a fireman saves people from a burning building, he's a hero.

If an arsonist sets fire to a building and then has a flash of conscience while the building is heavily burning and hears the screams of woman and children, then goes in to help, he's not a hero.

But this thread isn't about Hook, but Emma.

Emma has her darkness unaddressed and she seemed to accept the darkness as a part of her, but they took that away assumingly.