Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20161205015930/@comment-27257290-20161207032956

8Rob wrote: -It's a fabricated world. So, all of them kept their names.

-We don't know what happened with Baelfire in the WR. He probably went to Neveland and at some point returned to the Enchanted Forest. (I bet he came with Hook)

-Oh but he did something useful. He wished Regina to get what she deserved. And she got Robin back. She also got to crush Snow's heart! So, that means she deserved both love and get her revenge!

-Because Emma lost Hook at the end of 5A. She know how it feels. If Regina went to hell with her to help her bring Hook back, then I think Emma can stay for a while in the WR for Regina. -OK so next question. If Robin can be alive in the WR why can't Neal? Surely Emma would have wanted that in her wish, or at least Hook (not the real one).

-Regina didn't get Robin back. She got a Robin who neither exists nor knows her. I wouldn't say she deserved to kill them. Also wishes normally take an instant effect, no? All other wishes in this episode, and in season 1, came true straight away. Why did this wish choose to work through other people, like EQ getting turned into a snake by Gideon instead of Aladdin? I find it hard to believe that if it weren't for David's wish, Gideon would have acted differently.

-Emma was trying to convince Regina to jump into the portal, and they had limited time. Letting Regina look at a fake Robin does not equal helping Emma bring her true love back to life.