Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-26261153-20150720230151/@comment-25926288-20150801125454

Kingfan22 wrote: Nightlily wrote:

Kingfan22 wrote: The personality- I don't view amnesia as a personality trait, it's a health problem. I wouldn't call aids, cancer, or diabetes personality traits because they're not. Now you are splitting hairs. Yes, amnesia and anxiety disorders are not actually personality traits, but for a fictional character, these things are character traits. It's part of their character. And for a fictional character, character traits and personality traits are closely related. Cursed Belle, had different character traits, in the form of amnesia and anxiety attacks. She was a different person. The pages should remain separate. Your right, character traits are related to personality traits, but they aren't the same thing. From all the information I get from the thread the two things that warrant a separate page are different identities and different personalities. I don't think Belle French has either. I think her amnesia phase has more to do with Regina intentionally not giving her a new life, rather than it being her new life.

Also her identity during the entire first curse and at least some after was the same as her EF counterpart. So, she didn't have a different identity either. I think lacey is her counterpart because that's the persona that emerged after Regina finished cursing her.

I'm ok with lacey becoming the SB counterpart page or merging the pages. Same here. Keeping the pages separate and it should be Lacey and Belle. Both Belle and David had amesia during the first curse and we didn't call David's cursed self, John Doe or Prince Charming. David received his crused memories and become David Nolan, same with Belle whose cursed identity was discovered to be Lacey. Belle French isn't actually a real person. The newspaper probably put a last mname on her because they knew her father, Moe French, and newspapers usually puts last names on people.