Board Thread:Rant and Rave/@comment-28162607-20180220221000/@comment-28162607-20180222161727

Nightlily wrote: Aine1989 wrote:

CoolDudeAl wrote: Aine1989 wrote: Lola987 wrote: I may be mistaken, but I belive that in Oregon, two people can have consentual sex, if the age gap is no larger than three years. Yes, however Emma was 16/17 and he was 23, and that is a larger age gap that 3 years. Emma was 17 and 10 months (so nearly 18) as has been proven to you countless times. Trying to keep saying she is younger to make your arguement sound more legitimate just proves that you know your arguement doesn't work with the actual facts. Okay 17 then. 23-17=6. Which is still a larger age gap than 3 years. And she was 17 and 2 months. For Henry to have been born in August he'd have been conceived in December. No, because his parents met in 2001. It is perfectly possible that Henry was conceived in early 2001 and born on August 15; he could have been born a few weeks prematurely. It is also entirely possible that the 2001 title card was a mistake, sicne at that point the ouat-universe was 2 years behind reality (ie. season 3b was set in 2012 but filmed/aired in 2014).

And even if Henry was born prematurely (which if he was I am pretty sure we would have been told or the doctors would have told Emma since a baby being born a month early may have problems and he'd have been moved to a NICU) that would make Emma 17 and 4 months when dating Neal. Which is still 17.