Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20151207015752/@comment-26159109-20151211212044

Eskaver wrote: Farerb wrote: Eskaver wrote: Farerb wrote: ChocolatEyes613 wrote: Eskaver wrote:  However, my whole point was that Hook's Eureka moment was not earned. Was it that is was not earned, or could have been written better? There is no doubt, that the scene could have been better. As it relied solely on Colin's performance, rather than being well-written. Yep. His performance but mostly his good looks. They would have never gotten away with it if it had been Rumple and Belle instead of Hook and Emma, and the formers are far superior actors than the latters. Far superior? Well, I think they all are decent actors at the lowest, but I think Belle isn't anything higher than Emma, mostly because writing and accent XD

Also, because of the taget demo they shoot for. No wonder there will be a teen horror show in the works. Emilie is one of their strongest actors, they just don't do anything with her. It doesn't mean that Jennifer is bad, she's good. But I think that Emilie is better, IMO. Well, perhaps so. I always think it's Robert Carlyle that uplifts Emilie (since we all know Belle interacts with noone esle), but then again he brings up everyone.

Loved the Emma and Rumple scene at the end of the episode even if Rumple is on the Loop-de-loop. I liked it and hated it at the same time.