Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-34360784-20180116101248/@comment-1916997-20180116161116

Lady Junky wrote: Eskaver wrote: There are some inconsistencies in the WR as not everything was the same.

Occam’s Razor says that Hook’s parents are the same. However, the wiki prefers certainty over speculation.

Plus WR is an anomaly. We don’t know when WR spring into existence and at what point did the characters begin. Ex. Is there a Wish Cora? If so, did she go to New Wonderland or a Wish Wonderland? New Wonderland is nothing like Wonderland of before. What about Wish Zelena and Wish or New Oz?

Basically, we don’t even know if those versions actually existed or Hook, etc sprung into existence with those memories. If we don't list them, it is because a community discussion already happened on that matter, and most of people voted and decided to not list them.

And basically, most of the arguments was what Eskaver just explained. They are inconsistensies between the EF and WR, so we chose to be careful and wait a real source on the issue. I agree that their are some weird things regarding EF VS WR, but who's someone parents are is not one of them. Wish Henry is the prime example of this. Even though it makes almost no sense from a story perspective, Emma and Neal are still Henry's parents. So I don't see how Hook (who's birth would have still been hundreds of years before the WR scenes we saw), would not be the child of Brennan and Alice. Anyway you look at it, it doesn't make sense to not list those as both Hook and WHook's parents.