Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-4839682-20150311155356/@comment-1916997-20160107194058

Lady Junky wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: Lady Junky wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: Lady Junky wrote: No, let's not change what he said. He never said ALL DVD/Blu ray scenes should be canon. He said all DS from S4 DVD/BR and onwards will be canon. For the first 3 seasons, he never said "they should be" just that "they are supposed to" and that he must double check. So no, scenes from S1 to S3 are not canon and are not considered as canon.

So no, everything you will work on won't be canon. That's really splitting hairs, Lady. We should consider them "most likely canon" at the very least. No we won't. Because they are not canon, and because Adam himself said that he must double check them. So no, that"s not "really splitting hairs", that's just following what Adam is saying. We're fans, we're not up to decide what is considered as canon and what is not. That's why we don't include scenes from S1 to S3 on characters pages. Not canon. But that's the thing, Adam basically said "as far as I know they should be canon, but I would have to double check". He's saying they are canon, as far as he knows. The phrase "double check" indicates he believes they are canon. That's what he would be double checking. Saying they are "not canon" is simply not true. That implies it was confirmed to not be canon. But it was confirmed that they are, pending a check, canon. Like I said, "most likely canon" is what we should consider them. Again, we won't consider them as canon until we have a confirmation. That's what was decided and that"s how we will work. Supposition are definitely not confirmation. Then, it is not the place for that.

I created a thread, so we can get more opinions specifically on what to do with them. I always here about these decisions that were made, but I have never actually seen when, where, or by who they were made.