Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-25491743-20151002171811/@comment-2153169-20151204084516

FrancisPaul wrote: There's another thing here. Emma never used dreamcatchers on Merida.

Yet she could return her memories using one.

What wiped Merida, Arthur, Violet etc. memories was the curse. The dreamcatchers were just a way for Emma to return the memories before the curse was broken. It seems pretty reasonable that, even without dreamcatchers, TLK would return everyone's memories. I don't think we watch the same episode. You did not see Emma adding a dreamcatcher in the curse? She merge them, like that the Dreamcatcher's effect could be used on everyone. That's why she has so many dreamcatchers in SB actually.