Board Thread:Show-Related Questions and Answers/@comment-5521796-20130201015632/@comment-4260948-20130202175102

We know he didn't go to Neverland - That's why Rumpelstiltskin made the curse come to OUR WORLD!!!!! So he could find Baelfire, who was in our world; if he'd gone anywhere else, Rumpel would know.

So, he's in our world and not Peter Pan.