Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-24769579-20141012015614/@comment-25800654-20141202214553

Yes, that's true, but I still think it's been made clear on the show that someone else having your heart makes you act kind of robotic because you have no control over your actions,so it's kind of the same idea as Rumple being controlled by his own dagger (that's what I get out of it, anyway). Also, I think Hook actually is feeling more regret than I let on in my last comment  - not as regretful as he will be later, but as much as he can be without his heart intact. He did say outright "I'm truly sorry" to Blue Fairy before entrapping her, and when Emma and the others come in later and Hook is hiding behind the counter, we can see he looks really upset,