Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-25926288-20161101150057/@comment-24674051-20161117180401

Wow, random thought just occurred...

What if the Murder was not of David's father, but BY David's father? Papa Charming gets into a fight with someone and kills them (or maybe even gets asked to kill the person). This someone is someone important to King George, so he puts their body on his wagon and stages the fake accident, possibly taking great care to make sure the body is unidentifieable (glamor spells are wonderful). And then he comes into possession to a key to the LoUS, and takes refuge there to avoid revenge from George.

Fast forward to present day, King George is on the loose (since anything that happened to confine him in season 2 would have been undone when the original curse was lifted). George finds out that David's dad is alive and free, and is responsible for the death of whoever was killed. So he's out seeking to kill David's father, and David as well.

The theory is only half-baked (maybe just barely thawed would be more accurate), but there it is.