Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-5679696-20171014203438/@comment-26394456-20171017213229

SeanWheeler wrote:

DatNuttyKid wrote: So, Sean, what would you like to suggest as an alternative? I mean, you're the only person so far who disagrees, but if you would like to try to convince us to side with you, maybe you should give us an alternative rather than just trying to badmouth Killian's idea. My alternative is redirects. I mean, they work about the same way. And if we go with Killian's idea, would all redirects be turned into these kinds of pages? Captain Hook and Killian Jones would be good alternative names for the Hook page. Zelena could have Wicked Witch of the West as an alternate title. If this comes to pass, would there be any use for the traditional redirects anymore? I feel like you're not reading the responses to the redirect idea. In order to use redirects, we would have to pick a page name to redirect to, and since there is no apparant community consensus on how we should name the pages, this is a better option, as the pages can be accessed through both names.

I'm guessing you are going to argue that in Killian's system, the same thing occurs, and yes, I will not deny that there is still there is one page that will be the master page. However, he has stated he will clear the editing cofusion up as he further develops this system.