Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-28162607-20170103120839/@comment-25926288-20170106154040

You are making up ages. The present day in season 2 was 2012, the flashback said 11 years ago (2001). Neal and Emma were still together in 2001, according to several flashbacks. Emma find out she was pregnant in prison in 2001. Flashback (3x22): Emma and Neal go on that "date" he mentioned in 2x06 and it says Portland, 2001. Emma was 17 when Henry was conceived. (and as NightLily said). So, we seem to mostly agree that Emma was 17.

Flyers about Neal do not count as a valid source for his age. It also says he was born March 23 and in New Jersey, so why would we take any of that as fact?

Using a photo manip as a concept is fine, but those depict 16 to 19 year old Abby Ross and 35to 39 year old MRJ, which isn't even close to even what any of us are discussing.