Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-264749-20130218073608/@comment-6195464-20130220160845

When did we ever know their backstories? It's a completely different situation. You tell me Jiminy's original backstory and I'll concede your point. Tell me the Hatters' backstory. How about Jack?

The difference is, Peter -has- a backstory, an entire BOOK full of one. It's very hard for me to believe they would just change everything about the character, without justifiable cause... simply because they couldn't think of another way to explain his presence in Neverland.