Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-2153169-20170909025746/@comment-27060727-20171030190834

DatNuttyKid wrote: Okay, so going by definitive (confirmed on the show), apparent (confirmed by occasionally faulty press materials), assumed (backed up by things seen on the show or in press materials), and speculated (loosely backed up by things seen on the show or in press materials), we have: So, therefore, we can safely deduce that Alice, the Witch, Rapunzel, Eloise Gardener, and Tremaine are all the same person!
 * Definitive: Whook is looking for his daughter
 * Definitive: Rogers is looking for a girl
 * Apparent: Rogers is looking for Eloise Gardener
 * Assumed: Eloise Gardener is Whook's daughter
 * Assumed: The Witch is Eloise Gardener
 * Assumed: Alice/Tilly is Whook's daughter
 * Speculated: The Witch is Mother Gothel
 * Speculated: Rapunzel is Whook's daughter
 * Speculated: Tremaine is Rapunzel

...Something's off here. Haha, I was about to say, "Wait....the show is trying to convince the audience that Alice is the main candidate for Hook's daughter....."

Which is highly unlikely to now also be Eloise if she'll be addressed separately in the scripts. Unless Alice takes some other drugs and gets a whole other cursed identity.