Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-2153169-20171014230019/@comment-33386384-20180524212807

DatNuttyKid wrote: I'm conflicted as to whether or not Alice would have been Emma and Hook's kid because I'm not sure what the timeline would be if she was, but otherwise it seems pretty reasonable.

Besides that, I still like the idea of Emma being Scarlet or Anna in Hyperion Heights and being divorced from Rogers.

I definitely don't think Wish Hook would have been involved. Partially because the writers have said he was specifically introduced as a plot device to explain Emma's absence, but also because a lot of the plots with Wish Hook -- specifically with him and Rumple -- seem like they would make a lot more sense if it was OG Hook. I see Gothel separating Alice from Hook & Emma and keeping her in the Tower because she is the Guardian, and maybe Gothel was interested in her magic or something. But i don't think the Poisoned Heart storyline would've happened.