Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-33910478-20171209120733/@comment-25926288-20171209122456

Or.... Oh Hades, you are right.

Rapunzel was trapped. Rapunzel left and separated Marcus and Cecelia. Marcus moves on. Rapunzel trapped Gothel.

Hook helps free Gothel, Gothel gives birth to Alice and then leaves. Alice, years later, goes to Wonderland.

So, Alice had to have lied, or...the writers didn’t do enough oversight. Unless we are to believe that Marcus moved on, then post-Gothel’s trapping, went to search for Cecelia again. But that makes it more muddled and makes Marcus worse.