Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-2153169-20140913181317/@comment-24138799-20141110121452

WinterWoodsGal wrote: Kncooper wrote: Is it just me or do other people see that out of Igrid's two sister, Helga wasn't remotely frearful of her, whereas Gerda was? Before Gerda puts her in the urn that is, she is the one to suggest they visit Rumple and only holds Ingrids hand as a child after Helga gives her an affirming nod. If it wasn't for the duke of "weaseltown" hiding behind Helga, i'd say the two could be equal to anna and elsa in sisterly love. Seems that Gerda's price of magic was getting a daughter with the same "affliction". Am I the only one who saw Gerda as somewhat of a villain/antagonist in the past? Fear does things to people. But it was obvious that Gerda loved Helga more than anyone, and Ingrid just killed her. But remember Gerda did not want to give up the ribbons. Well, I think it's just logical that Gerda loved Helga more than Ingrid. I imagine that, being the 2 oldest of the siblings, Ingrid and Helga had bonding time before Gerda was born. It was just the two of them. After Gerda was born, she bonded most with Helga because they both knew what it was like to be the younger sibling. So I don't think she was a villain so much. Anyway, A&E always know how to make us feel sorry for the villains, don't they? ;)