Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20161205015930/@comment-25926288-20161205042333

Avatar Beta wrote:

Cons:

1. The wish reality doesn't make much sense. There shouldn't be a Henry there and Baefire shouldn't be his Dad. If this was the case, Rumple shouldn't be lamenting the failure of the Dark Curse. he should be attempting to escape and recouncil with the son who found his way home.They should've cast a teenage version of Emma's brother in Wish Henry's role instead.

2. Wish Emma is too delicate and craven. I'd like to think Snow and David would've raaised a tougher daughter than that.

3. As much as I enjoyed the lack of CaptainSwan, why couldn't Emma have remembered herself by saving Henry? Wanting to address them,

1. I think it used everyone from the current reality and then manipulated somethings to make sense of all of it. So, copying real Henry meant he still had to have the same father as Emma wouldn't wish him out of existence. I don't know if Rumple knew his son was in the land. He really didn't seem to be bothered much by that. Poor Prince Neal, because he doesn't exist in Emma's wish realm.

2. There's no wish Emma. It's just Emma. Given what Snow was like, I think they are about the same. With Snow and David stopping all evil, I doubt they had any worries.

I don't understand the third point. I thought she sort of remembered because she didn't want Henry to be so dark.