Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-1916997-20151012011036/@comment-25926288-20151015005935

Everyone! Listen up!

http://captainswan4e.tumblr.com/post/131099326649/ouat-plot-holes-add-one-more-to-the-list

The cutlass Hook had was Milah's and that was used to awaken Rumple, when in actuality, Rumple took Hook's sword that touched him when he was a man.

Add this to this season being the biggest retcon-discontinuity filled season. Good catch by the poster.

So, technically they still got it wrong.