Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-5679696-20150105234331/@comment-4975807-20150106010440

I definitely agree with Killian's view for the third option, in which we do have pages for major items/locations/characters as well as pages for minor items/locations/characters that play a signifcant part in the episode/episodes they appear in.

I absolutely am against extremist page creators (the first option) because this wiki could very quickly come a clutter space for 5000+ pages with most of them not being very revelant to the wiki as a whole. For my own definition, I would say characters in this category that do not desere a page :

A) Have no given name (Example: Characters with press release credited names like Peasant 1, Black Knight 1/2/3/4/5, etc) or, B) Do have a given name, and either did not speak a single line or only spoke like two-three lines in the episode he/she appeared in (Example: Trish from "The Doctor", Hans brothers, Honora - the mute maid Rumplestiltskin killed after she saw the Dark One's Dagger, the Royal Doctor that tended to Queen Eva when she was sick,  etc). In my opinion, there is also the C) option, which is that characters that are only mentioned, and who have not made a physical appearance on the show (unless the character is officially confirmed to appear in an upcoming episode) should not get a page, either.