Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-2153169-20170909025746/@comment-27060727-20171015062555

A lot of people on this show have been framed as "orphans" and "people who want to fit in" somewhere. I don't think that description by Rose indicates much. And I think someone above mentioned this, but Tilly is in HH and has interacted with Rogers, so surely he'd know if she was the missing girl? Would he not have a picture in a case file? I'm assuming he won't find his daughter until the curse breaks, and it hasn't as of 7x09.

If you were a GA viewer who did not know they had cast a Rapunzel, I'd think she'd still be a top guess after hearing Wish Hook's story. A witch trapping a young girl in a tower? And the chess piece is a tower.

Now, earlier on, I did think Rapunzel could've been Tremaine's daughter. Her last name is still "Belfrey" and the other cursed last names this season clearly call back to their real personas. And she works in a fancy tall building that could be a modern "tower" of sorts. So I'm still suspicious and I'm not ruling out her being Hook's daughter's mother, but it's a weird theory lol. If Tremaine is to be everyone's villain, perhaps she conspired with a witch and is a villain to Rogers as well. They wouldn't say if Tremaine cast the curse, so that makes me lean towards no, but she ended up with a powerful cursed life so someone must've been on her side.