Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-24846659-20140813193020/@comment-413929-20141031074808

Personal theory here; It might be long.

This thought concerns character choices, the effects of the choices made, and the questions of can they live with the choices they're to make We all know that Ingrid wanted a family, or at least someone to love her for who she was. Instead she was seen as a monster for trying to impose others to love her. So she either flees or was trapped to begin with and put in the north valley.

Now; when Ingrid told Elsa that it was Anna who put her in the urn, this could go two ways. One, it could be an flat out lie, or two, it might have been the choices Elsa had been forced to make. Let me explain; It is hinted somewhere that Ingrid takes dire extremes to ensure she gets what she wants. So she has Anna trapped in the urn, and the urn given to Hans to put somewhere out in the open for Elsa to find. Then, when Elsa has to make a choice, free her sister and get trapped in the urn herself, or destroy the urn and her sister. What choice do you suppose she'd make ?

Say she frees Anna from the Urn, in doing so the magical properities of the urn take hold of Elsa and suck her inside the urn, sealing her within. Thusly, her choice puts her there. Her sister was her choice, she chose her sister over Ingrid, and thus paid the price. BUT; when this occured was BEFORE Charming and Snow ever met. Which apparently could mean anything from a few weeks to a year that Elsa was in the thing,

I am going to assume that out of fear Ingrid fled Arendelle and went to the lan without magic {America} to be a foster mother to children where she met Emma. Thusly the circle continued.

Take in time travel; and then Hook and Emma are in the past, apparently at the point wherein just before Elsa is placed in the imps vault, or just afterwards when Hook moved the thing. Ingrids hopes of having a family to love her shatter in the exact moments of Hook moving the urn.

Just a personal theory on the topic