Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-7526254-20170430003451/@comment-31722073-20180930210948

Katchin wrote: 1. The Wish Realm has the same history as the Main Reality up to when Regina was supposed to have cast the Dark Curse so there wouldn't be any difference between either realities version of Arendelle, Oz, and Wonderland but there are differences in the New Fairy Tale Land because it's from a different version of the book. So my impression of the Light Curse is the realms of the main reality are united, and everyone from a different reality who shared a piece of their heart is brought to the United Realms because not all the dopplegänger's Henry mentions at the beginning of Season 7 are present. Several characters from the Land of Untold Stories now reside in Storybrooke so that would explain being able to merge it. On the other hand Jack is originally from Oz, and Dr. Facillier knew Regina when she was the Evil Queen.

2. It's Emma and Killian's daughter that does it for me because she was conceived after Henry left Storybrooke, an event that can't take place any earlier than late 2017/early 2018 (because the Seattle events in Season Seven take place in late 2017 and Henry had not left for the New Enchanted Forest yet), Hope is a baby by the time of Regina's coronation, which happens after the United Realms are created. I know 17/18 is graduation in the USA, but it is possible to graduate early.

3. Again the baby.

4. Regina wasn't in the NEF at the time Wish Rumple was defeated, Zelena tells us she was on graduation trip with Emma and Henry. When Regina goes to the NEF is when Emma tells Henry she's pregnant and again Hope is only a baby at the time of the coronation.

5. According to Robin's biography her and Zelena relocate to another realm where time moves faster and they return to Storybrooke shortly before Regina goes to help Henry in the NEF, my mistake I forgot about the Spell Book. She summons Gothel after Regina went to help Henry in the NEF, and after saving Robin, she and Zelena relocate to the NEF for 8 years. Only a few months had passed in Storybrooke by the time Zelena and Robin returned from this realm where time moves faster so the realms wouldn't have been united when they relocate.

6. Henry is 16 at the end of Season 6. As I mentioned 17/18 is graduation in the USA, but it is possible to graduate early. Gideon is only a baby at the end of Season 6 and it's Gideon's first birthday when Mr. Gold says to Belle that they go travelling. Gideon is 10 when Mr. Gold tries to get rid of the Dark One's Dagger, and they spend the next 8 years finding a way to get rid of it.

7. I know it wouldn't of taken more than a year to cast the curse because Regina finds the Dark Curse Scroll in the Wish Realm after defeating Wish Rumple, and as I've said the Wish Realm has the same history as the Main Reality except it isn't frozen for 28 years so they move at the same speed.

8. I know the show isn't being revived anytime soon which is a shame because the United Realms was more of a beginning than an ending. However if the show was revived and Regina's coronation is before Mr. Gold and Belle relocate to the Edge of Realms then somebody could warn him of the events that are yet to come. So Belle doesn't sacrifice herself to fulfil that prophecy because after 10 years as a happy family I didn't see the point, and Mr. Gold doesn't sacrifice himself to defeat his Wish Realm dopplegänger plus he could find a cure for the Curse of the Poisoned Heart. I agree some of the realms they visited no doubt move at different speeds.

9. His biography does say late 20's early 30's. I agree he wouldn't grow into a different actor in 1 year. 23 Lucy's Birth, 31 Drizella's Curse, 34 Curse Broken is the best I can think of so far.

For the record. I'm sorry I left it on three threads, each thread was more recent than the other, I was unsure if it would've been noticed. 1. Take that up with the wiki but we have the WR in the UR currently. This would mean that the NFTL is in the UR, presumably she loves Ella and Lucy, both NEF characters and this just breaks your arguèment apart. 2. This is possible and I understand this argument for faster NEF time. This once again hurts the case you were making because this means it is after the DC was cast no paradox needed.

3.See above

4.I agree that Regina hadn’t left when the DC was cast, once again the OP case is hurt by your argument.

5.We have no clue how long they were gone in Storybrooke time but this again hurts your case.

6. The Final Battle takes place in 2015, Henry is 14, see Lily’s Timeline for that. Those Gold, Belle and Gideon dates are correct.

7. I agree with that

8. We agree on this point.

9.You said 18-19 around the time he calls for family aid you have him at 17/18 when he left Storybrooke, I agree with your new aging or something similar.