Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-5679696-20171014203438/@comment-2153169-20171015202049

FrancisPaul wrote: Lady Junky wrote: Regina must not be named Evil Queen. That would be completely ignoring her entire arc in the series. She evolves and naming her the Evil Queen would just ignore who she is today.

That's why we can't have the original names, characters have evolved since that time. Most of these names are not who they are anymore. Irrelevant, imo. If they continued to credit Ginny as Mary Margaret after she explicitly expressed her desire not to be called as such, I can live with Regina being named Evil Queen.

If that spell in 404 had been permanent would it become impossible to keep the page named Hook because he would no longer have a hook, but a hand?

Whether or not she is good in the current timeline, her original counterpart is Evil Queen, she was credited as such, and we should not eliminate the possibility to use original names for everyone (Snow White, Grumpy, Prince Charming etc.) because one character is no longer a villain. Sure, Evil Queen is not Roni, and Roni is not an evil queen, but, as I said, we can't find a name that suits all 3 Reginas (given "Regina" is not accepted). Evil Queen is perfectly possible as per the suggested options, it shouldn't be ruled off just because she hasn't been evil for 6-ish years.

If you want to ignore all logic behind storylines of the series, it is your choice. Personally, I prefer to take it into account. We want our pages to reflect the current situation - at best - of our characters. No to keep them blocked forever into something which do not take in account their present self.

Your exemple of Mary Margaret has no value. Even if she prefers to be named as Snow White, her official SB name is still MM. So, legally, her name is still MM. Which is why we kept the current page as MM, not Snow White.