Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-28162607-20170103120839/@comment-91424-20170106224451

Aine1989 wrote: Except his birthday cannot be in August since he was 11 within 6 months of the pilot!!!

Established age from earlier in the show takes priority over a thrown in Lost reference from season 5 that the wrtiers clearly didn't think through

Except that the "established age" that you are referring to, was never actually established - I've stated, again, and again, that we don't actually know how much time passed between Valentine's Day 2012 in "Skin Deep" and mid season 2. And you already know (because it's been pointed out several times) that the date is not based on the Lost reference alone, but also on the year they met (2001) and Emma's age when she gave birth to Henry (eighteen).

Oh, and about the three exclamation points: there is no need to shout, we read you perfectly well ;-)