Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-2153169-20151015134011/@comment-4821842-20151110031824

Elexorien wrote:

ChocolatEyes613 wrote:

Elexorien wrote:

They never showed Merlin dying..? OUaT also never showed him in Storybrooke, and the heroes got his voicemail.... both imply that Merlin is dead. I do think you're jumping the gun here, but it is possible.

If Merlin did die, then Emma would have had to be the one that killed him, since only the Dark One has the power to kill Merlin. Here is my theory, Merlin is immortal but so is the Dark One but the Dark One can be killed if they are killed with the dagger, so my theory is that Hook killed Merlin with the other half of Exalbiur and became the new (light one?) but of course he doesn't remember because Emma took their memories