Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-6175354-20170720184833/@comment-2153169-20170728021439

CadoDoan wrote: Lady Junky wrote: CadoDoan wrote: ArcaneDust17 wrote:

I feel the same way with the whole "Dark Swan" mess in season 5. A single person should not be able to be the Savior AND the Dark One. They really screwed that up in season 5. Either Emma's Savior status should have protected her from being possessed by the Dark One, or she should have been stripped of her Savior status the moment she became the Dark One, and a new Savior should have been chosen. They totally screwed the pooch on that whole Dark Swan idea back in season 5. (Not to mention that Jennifer Morrison just does not have the acting chops to play a villian. Her entire Dark Swan performance was just painful to watch.) Let's not have a repeat of anything like that again, thank you very much. Oh really? I am not a fan of 5A either, but the one thing that kept me from not being so bored was Jennifer's performance. It was also the reason when I realized how talented actor she is.

I agree that a person should not get all those power. But by the time of S5, there was only one Savior, and she was THE Savior, not A Savior. Yes, Emma was the Savior, but not because she was born to break the Curse (contrary to what Fiona said), because she was borned to be the Savior. Actually to me, they screwed up everything in S6 by making Aladdin a savior and that other people can become a savior due to unknown reasons.

Not saying it is possible, but I think both of you forget one recent detail.

That interview where they mentioned "different authors and different books". It tends to prove that Henry is the Author of Book 1, and so someone else is the Author of Book 2. Meaning that Henry's Author powers would be completely useless in Book 2, and so he would not be owerpowered. Clearly from what we got, Henry is not the Author of Book 2 and so, has zero power on this book. So, if he happens to be the Savior of Book 2, it would not be added to his Author's status.

Basically, in Book 1, Henry would have his Author powers. And in Book 2, he would be the Savior. No additional powers there.

Again, not saying it is possible, but we can't deny the possibility too. I hope you're right. It would seriously be a dumb move to make Henry the Truest Believer, the Author and the Savior at the same time, even though the first two happened xD

So, you're saying an Author can only be an author of one book. This could happen. But I don't think the book example will work for the Savior situation. Because if I'm not missing something, being a Savior has nothing to do with the books.

Well, "I'm saying". That's what A&E said in that interview ^^ And the Savior's situation is different. Not related to the book, but still. From what we got from S6, a Savior has a very specific threat/ennemy related to him/her. Like for Emma, it was the Black Fairy and the Final Battle. So, not a question of a book, but if Henry is the Savior, he would be the Savior against another threat/ennemy, which would be only from Book 2.