Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6810329-20160911021344/@comment-24674051-20160914174227

Also, we're missing Poseidon from the list.

I also agree that all Dark Ones (except possibly Current Rumple, and maybe Dark Swan) should be the same tier. I put Dark Swan higher because Emma showed that she could wield both light and dark magic as the Dark One, something that none of the other dark ones could do, and Rumple still has not shown the ability for.

Emma also needs to be either A+ or even S-. When everyone else's magic went wonky in the UW, both Rumple and Emma had no problems with their magic.

I also agree that it is somewhat difficult to rank the mages, since we don't see everything that they are capable of.

having said that, this is how I would list them:

S+: Zeus, Hades, Poseidon, Goddess Ursula (maybe?)

S: Current Rumple, Dark Swan, Merlin, The Author

S-: All other Dark Ones, Emma

A+: Peter Pan, Zelena, Jafar, Apprentice

A: Cora, Ingrid, Amara, Blue Fairy, Maleficent

A-: Regina, Anastasia, Fendrake, possibly Black Fairy (based on reputation provided)

B+: Jabberwocky, Elsa, Ursula, Cruella, Blind Witch

B: Fairies (Tinkerbell, Silvermist, Nova, etc), Cyrus & his brothers, the Genie, Belle (Her potioncraft puts her on the list), Jefferson (limited ability, but what he has is quite useful)

Magical Creatures & Demi-beings: Red (and all Werewolves), Ariel (and all mermaids), Hercules, Tiny (and the Giants), Medusa, Siren, Cerberus, Chernabog