Board Thread:Rant and Rave/@comment-25733960-20171209163949/@comment-31619992-20171209234404

Eskaver wrote: Or....Alice lied to spare Ella's feelings.

Timeline goes:

Rapunzel poisons Cecelia.

Marcus presumably gives up on Cecelia after a whole year of searching. Cecelia presumably dies.

Rapunzel traps Gothel.

Gothel has Alice.

It appears that Cecelia had to have died and Alice was nowhere to be around, or she lived and actually moved on. Timeline doesn't fit because we have a Wish Hook who travelled between realms and had a baby in another realm like 30 years before be born by the Evil Queen's wish. Timeline is whatever the writers wanted us to believe this year...