Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-25562474-20141107232540

So I'm not sure where to put this question, or even if it makes sense, but how exactly does true loves kiss work because it seems like there are rules.

1- Do both people have to be in love  or feel love for each other in order for it to work? Emma kisses Henry and breaks the first curse, Regina kisses Henry and breaks second curse. Does kissing Henry break all curses? (Obviously just kidding, kinda). Charming kisses a sleeping cursed Snow White and wakes her.

2- Can true loves kiss work if the kisser is in love and the recipent of the kiss doesnt remember that they love the kisser? Under the effects of a memory potion from Rumple, Snow White kisses Charming (whom she forgot because of said memory potion), it breaks the spell and she remembers him and her love for him.

3- Will the kiss work if the recipent of the kiss doesn't love the person they are being kissed by? Hook kissed Emma in New York and she went all sassy and gave him a boo boo. Her memories didnt return, so does that mean she doesnt love him?

Now to the point of all this, I believe in the first season when Rumple goes looking for Robin Hood and comes across the Sheriff (not Graham, I think his SB name is Keith) says that Robin Hood stole this love from him (Marian). I'm pretty sure word got out that Emma and Hook brought Marian back with them, and that she is a popsicle, so why hasn't he shown up to help? Doesnt Robin remember how he and Marian got together? If Robin wanted to do whatever it took to save Marian, shouldnt he consider going to find her old boyfriend who loved her, perhaps Sheriff Keith could save her?

4- It is possible the Robins kiss didnt work because he loves Regina, but could it also not work because her true love is Sheriff Keith? Why don't they have Roland kiss his mother, but if it doesnt work, give him a  memory potion to make him forget that she is frozen solid?

- End rant  