Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-1916997-20171009223757/@comment-31722073-20181109151346

Alice (Wonderland) VS Alice (701)-Come on, I love Wonderland but Tilly is just so much more fun in the role, about half of OG Alice being good is being able to act next to Michael Socha (who is just amazing).

Ariel (306) VS Ursula (411)-The story is pretty much equally good but Ariel is more fun than Urusla.

Aurora (201) VS Princess (721) VS Briar Rose (102)- Well duh, do I need to explain this?

Blind Witch (109) VS Hilda (712)- This would be a tie but in the Underworld the BW is so much fun.

Charming as Rapunzel's Prince (314) VS Wish Hook as "Rapunzel's" Prince (707)- They just cared about the story in 707

Cinderella (104) VS Cinderella (701)- They are pretty much the same in quality.

Clorinda and Tisbe (6x03) VS Drizella (701)- Drizzy is would beat all the stepsisters and every single Cinderella character (minus Rumple) combined. Clorinda (603) VS Red Queen (Wonderland) VS Anastasia (703)- I mean the Red Queen wasn't a great adaptation of the wicked stepsister but she is so much better as a character.

Daniel as Frankenstein's Monster (205) VS Gerhardt Frankenstein as Frankenstein's Monster (212)- It was a more Frankenstein story.

Elsa (322) VS Ingrid (402)- It's really more one story where they adapt each other.

Fairy Godmother (104) VS Fairy Godmother (701) VS Rumple as Fairy Godfather (104)- Hehehehe! The FG's have like no personality and Rumple has loads of it.

Gretel (109) VS Gretel (715)- New Gretel is more fun as a character than the original one. Hansel (109) VS Hansel/Jack (708)- Jack is a more interesting character and does more than Hansel.

Jack (213) VS Jack (708)- I think Nick is a bit better of a character based on more appearances.

Lady Tremaine (603) VS Lady Tremaine (701)- Rapunzel Tremaines is much more developed than the original one and Gabrielle Anwar does a great job.

Maleficent (102) VS Unnamed Dragon (721)- Well duh, Mal is better than the unnamed dragon.

Manifestation of Rapunzel's fear (314) VS Witch/Mother Gothel (703)- I mean Gothel is a character.

Phillip (201) VS Handsome Prince (721)- Third obvious adaptation to win.

Prince Thomas (104) VS Prince and Henry Mills (701)- When a character is cared about he is better than when he isn't. Rapunzel (314) VS Lady Tremaine/Rapunzel (701)- Exactly the same as Lady Tremaine. Robin Hood (219) VS Robin (710)- I like them both equally, they are equally amazing. Rumple as the Beast (112) VS Phillip as the Beast (211)- Rumple wins, Rumple always wins. Ursula (306) VS Ursula (4x11) Vs Regina as Ursula (306)- I mean Ursula is really good but Regina is actually adapting the story and Lana milks it.

Woodcutter (109) VS Ivo (717)- Ivo spends time with Zelena which wins almost every contest.