Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20170306015934/@comment-25926288-20170306021512

Mathematicalbooks wrote: Since Robin's dead soul is speculated to be in Wish World!Robin by Emma, would there be any hidden memories of his past life still in Wish World!Robin? Depends on Genie magic, but I'm pretty sure genies can't go deal with matters of life and death. Only a deity can, or some special magic in which it's a life for a life. Problem with that is the whole powerscaling problem Once has. How can a genie (or Author) have magic that can create whole realities, but can't "bring back the dead"?

I wager that WR Robin is just a copy that just happens to be there because David wished for him to be there. Or fate. Or plot.