Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25878580-20141216100555/@comment-25878580-20141216110544

Mesmermann wrote: Good theory, but I think Lily isn't a magical character. At least not when she met Emma. I'm dying to find out what the star means. The star is the key to who she is.

I thought the same thing until I read some of the A&E interviews about the show was going to handle Cruella. They openly said they are giving her magic even though historically she didn't have them. Also Meg isn't particularly magical either so either way it could work. The only reason I am holding out that she has an other world counterpart is that birthmark. Super weird