Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-28011742-20170329211301

I personally think that Emma was being overly dramatic. One, if anyone should be doubting their partner's trust issues, it's Hook. Emma has hid TONS of things from him---why should this one thing be the source of their split? And two, this literally happened in the far past. Hundreds of years ago, when Hook was a different man. It doesn't even affect her, for gosh sake. Hook made a mistake years ago that doesn't really affect them at all; why is she so out of character about this?

I'd like to hear other people's opinions about the new development. Am I the only one who feels this way? Could the writers have approached this differently that didn't make Emma seem irrational? And is there anything else going on with their breakup that you'd like to mention or discuss? 