Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24589671-20140506183123/@comment-24907061-20140507192146

Arctucrus wrote: ChocolatEyes613 wrote: Toma Cre wrote: So if Hook meets himself in the past, then the present him should be able to recall that particular meeting right? So did he recognise Emma when they first met in EF?

And he should have literally foresaw that punch coming and dodged... To me it looked like present!Hook punched past!Hook. Due to the time-paradox, it is very possible that Hook knew he would fall in love with Emma, the whole time. Remember, he said, "I was hoping, it'd be you", and more recently "I came back, to save you".

ChocolatEyes613 wrote: Ktmae1234 wrote: I hope he didn't know. There's something special about falling in love the first time and I'd hate to see his experience tainted with the foreknowledge of what's going to happen. Think about it this way.... the time paradox would also put a new twist, on why Hook was so dead-set on killing Rumplestiltskin. It would not just be for personal revenge, but to preserve everyone's future. It means, everything Hook ever did - good or bad - he did for Emma. His promo poster read, "Believe that a pirate can be a hero". Loving how you're thinking Choc!

Wow! awesome theory! And yeah, I guess it would be all for Emma!