Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-3393671-20141109223833/@comment-5106672-20141201035118

We have to consider four things.


 * As far as we know, the new Curse did not create counterparts (as in fake identities). For one thing, except for the missing year everyone was still themselves. For another, none of the characters who escaped the first Curse, such as Robin Hood, have stated anything about fake identities, so it is safe to assume it worked differently than the first one, just as a means of transporation.


 * The second Curse was not meant to take away the memories. That was a side effect put there by Zelena, and even though she used the potion not to forget the last year, she was still cursed and transported to Storybrooke like everyone else. She only escaped her own forgetting spell which was a surplus to the Curse itself.


 * Non-human characters (Dwarves and Fairies) were turned into humans as in the first Curse, but I don't think that applies to this specific case. Zelena's victims were humans under a spell. I think it probably kept intact because Storybrooke did have magic from the start this time around.


 * Regardless of point 3, we have one precedent of a cursed counterpart in non-human form, which is Maleficent. So, by logic, anyone transported by the Curse, regardless of their current form at the time, should be listed as a counterpart, like Maleficent is.

Therefore, I'm all for having an Aurora (Storybrooke) page created and, eventually, a Phillip (Storybrooke) one too if he shows up and we have something to write about.