Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24589671-20141222210529/@comment-24589671-20150104223848

MagicKaty1 wrote:

Hmcooper4 wrote: Ok, let's think this through. Killian is 300 years old (give or take). He started out as a respectable Leftenant abord a fighting ship. His older brother was a Captain in the King's navy (no small feat there). How do we get from there to Blackbeard is Killian's (and Liam's)  father. Blackbeard would have to be well over 300 himself. and I just don't see the son of a Pirate becoming an officer in the Navy. Let alone 2 sons becoming officers.

I just don't see it. And since Killian said that his father abandoned him, that would probably give him the impression to NOT turn out like his father. So if BB is Killian's father, it seems unlikely that Killian would become a pirate after the example that his father gave him if he was BB.

I don't think Edward is Killian's father, they didn't seem to have that vibe to me. I've no doubt we will see his dad sometime but I don't think it's Edward.