Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25617908-20151208202256/@comment-27213286-20151209070529

I think she means literally split her heart in half like Snow did, from they way they were talking that is what it sounded like.

I don't think Neil will be in the underworld because I think he will be in the "heaven" option. He was always a good person and every dead person I have seen in the previews has been a villian. Dark Ones are dark by default and Hook had to take the darknes back to the hell in which it came from so he had to go to the Underworld no matter how much he started to redeem himself. I don't think it ever got as far as love with her and Graham, I think he died before it was able to get that far so he won't be a problem if he is there.

Lastly, Charming's body had no wounds on it that killed him not did he die from any disease. He died because he had his heart was crushed by Snow. Charming still had a perfectly healthy body to put half of Snow's heart into. If they were to put half of Emma's heart into Hook's body he would just die again from the stab wounds that originally killed him.