Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24892318-20140610050421/@comment-6175354-20140807185827

Ktmae1234 wrote: I brought up the theory that he traded the Jolly Roger to Blackbeard on another thread a couple of months ago and I got shut down.

I think it would be a great storyline. Hook would have to deal with the fact that he traded the thing he loved most to the man he almost killed, the man who stole his ship from him in the first place, and the man who's taunting caused him to betray his honor. The "Blackbeard survived and Hook traded the Jolly Roger to him" theory, seems like the type twist the OUaT writers would pull. Considering how much Hook was in love with the Jolly Roger, it makes sense he traded it to someone who wanted to humiliate him. Though more than likely, the audience will never learn who he traded his ship to.