Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-26159109-20151007195419/@comment-25926288-20151125132744

Farerb wrote: Eskaver wrote: My gosh, that was wonderfully acted.

"Hi" by Robert Carlyle was hilarious and almost meek sounding. Like a nervous fan, lol.

Loved the interaction, but Hook still wanting revenge....I would say it makes no sense because he gave up a long time ago, but then again Rumple......with the Darkness inside, did more evil deeds towards him and the one person that he cares about besides himself. And I wouldn't have had a problem with it if Hook hadn't given that whole "I was a villain, he was a victim" speech to Emma in 503. I will give them a plus if the writers didn't write in absolutes. It would just mean that Hook has never forgiven Rumple, ever!

You see it when he denies Rumple the rights to forgiveness that he was willing to give Emma claiming that it isn't "Emma", even though, he would know that DO Rumple isn't the same as the Rumple he knew before. He even still calls him "Crocodile" at every turn and not in an endearing way.