Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-2153169-20170629021436/@comment-4877635-20170716121254

Since there have been more that one Peter in the show, as  an example, it is entirely possible that there could be more than one person in the Enchanted Forrest since Merlin's time to have the same name. Just saying that is how I am processing the 2 Cinderella's thing. She is clearly younger than Ashley's Cinderella as many years have passed since Season 1 :)