Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-1916997-20171222202521/@comment-6302057-20180430021524

RedCoatOfficial wrote: We still need to come to an agreement on Regina everyone.


 * 1) Was she the Eighth Witch of the Coven of the Eight during the casting of the Dark Curse.
 * 2) She doesn't count because she was forced.

This discussion has been ongoing since December and we only have like a month left on the show now. We need to reach an end.

I vote option #1. It's not really a matter of one or two, it's both.

She was blackmailed by the Coven to fill the eighth position in order to cast the curse. She was there for the purpose of casting the curse, but she was not actually a member of the Coven.