Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-32423680-20180825233912/@comment-26967699-20180828000147

Great idea! But I only agree with it if we do RedCoatOfficial’s suggestion. See Hook’s status. It is said “Alive”, not “Alive but formerly deceased”. So we write nothing on Hook’s infobox. Other way, it would be very confusing.

By the same logic, for example, Rumple’s infobox will only include the last time he died: Sacrificed his own heart to save Hook. For Pan, it will be “Stabbed with the dagger by Rumple”. For Milah: “Heart crushed by Rumple” etc.

We don’t need to write anything on David’s, Doc’s or Hook’s page as they are alive at this point. We can see full details on the List of Deaths or the history sections.