Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27255668-20151207215419/@comment-3398493-20151208131929

Guys I think Rumple split Excalibur and the Dagger before giving it to Emma. Then Excalibur looked as if it was whole because of the magic he used on it. But Rumple had the REAL Dagger all this time. This explain this. This also means that Emma is still a DO since she can hear the Dagger and Rumple ONLY showed one side of the Dagger. I bet in the other side it's Emma's name on it.