Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-5118208-20141108143108/@comment-25077005-20150514044930

Edward Zachary Sunrose wrote: Dark Fantasy1990 wrote: GothicNarcissus wrote: Well, so far the only humans with confirmed innate magic are: Emma, as a product of True Love. Zelena, who was wielding magic as a days-old-at-best baby. Elsa and Ingrid, who have their own special brand of elemental magic.

All the others, either the thing was not addressed, or they had to be trained. We never saw Cora or Regina accidentally unleashing magic before they met Rumple, even though we saw both in situations that could have triggered it, if they had had it in them. Wath with Eva exposing Cora's pregnancy to Leopold? Or tipping her when they next met – the latter would have especially been enough for her anger to burst into magic. Similarly, Regina's distress at Daniel's death could have triggered her magic, had it been innate; instead, she later had a great deal of problems with it, for instance when it was first brought to Storybrooke. Also, Anastasia seemed completely non-magical in the Enchanted Forest, and we've seen non-magical people, such as Belle and Neal, casting spells, although with all the ingredients prepared by magical people. Thus, I think we can be quite sure magic is an acquired skill, with very few people being born with it. About the Elsa-Ingrid magic thing. I think only the firstborn of Arendelle is born with powers. That's just a theory. It's never confirmed why Ingrid has powers, but Elsa's are directly implied by Pabbie to be Gerda's price to pay for stealing Arendelle's memories of her sisters. All magic comes with a price. So Elsa could've probably been born without the powers had Gerda not done what she did. I posted a thread of the Arendelle firstborn theory that might explain it to you.