Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24892318-20140530013558/@comment-24892318-20140530221336

Yes. Emma is obviously to blame for Marian. Remember, however, the conversation between Hook and Emma. He passionately made the case that Marian couldn't stay in the EF because she might give birth to a mass murderer or run over one of the dwarves. What was Emma to do? Kill her? No, she kidnapped her instead, with Hook's blessings and help. I just believe he deserves some of the blame because if it weren't for his conversation with Emma, Marian might be back with her family in the EF. Of course, that would have been a whole different time line, with its own consequences, so...