Board Thread:Rant and Rave/@comment-28162607-20180220221000/@comment-28162607-20180221173451

AJDSOUAT wrote: This conversation happened in "Price of Gold".

Emma: I was 18.

Ashley: When you had a kid?

Emma: Yeah.

But this presents conflicting infromation because for Emma to be 18, Henry would've had been born sometime between October 24th, 2001- March of 2002. Henry told Emma he was 10 in the Pilot but at the maximum age he could've been would 9 and by the time of "The Cricket Game" Henry turned 11 and that episode takes place in March. I've came to conlusion that Henry lied about his age and Emma conceived Henry 3/4 months before her 18th birthday. So Henry lied about his age and yet Neal was still able to work out that he was his? And Emma was still able to work out he was hers? And that means he hit puberty at 10. And not only did he lie about his age, but so did Regina and Emma, who both reference Henry's age.

There is also the conclusion that Emma lied about her age slightly to save some dignity in front of a total stranger.