Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20160321010032/@comment-25926288-20160323174407

Hmcooper4 wrote: I think we'll have to agree to disagree here. Hook looked like a suave womanizer, which is what he was.

Keep in mind where Killian was at this time. He was probably only 1-2 years (at most) into his pirate career. He was not seeking revenge against a Dark One that killed his lover. He was living a care-free life, which included catching the eye of any and every fair wench that he came across. He was still fresh from his Military background, so some of the aspects of chivalry and honor associated with that background are probably still somewhat towards the surface.

The Killian that was portrayed in this episode matches what I would have expected from the above situation. I would agree on most parts, but the "suave womanizer" is emphasized as much. I just checked the Facebook page and they uploaded that clip and captioned it "How chivalrous". This is a man that took a wife from her child (in a sense). And he looked like the better man in the episode.