Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-4821842-20141110162131/@comment-9445918-20141209001458

Applegirl wrote: I'm surprised at the revelation that Gerda kept her memories even though she asked Grand Pabbie to erase everyone else's memories of Ingrid and Helga. I thought for sure that Gerda wouldn't be able to stomach being alive and knowing she lost both sisters, but it makes sense that her scroll-in-the-bottle confession is what saved Ingrid in the end.... knowing that Gerda did love her very much and regretted putting her in the urn. :(  I agree. Ingrid is one of the best villains created by OUAT IMO. She is the second villain that made me cry (First was Regina)