Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-6175354-20161010033114/@comment-25926288-20161117163643

DatNuttyKid wrote: Farerb wrote: I don't want it to be Hook. He doesn't need more terrible secrets from his past only to be forgotten and swept under the rug. You mean like how Hook leaving Liam an orphan was never brought up again? Or more like how Regina murdered Graham with no repercussions? Just curious what backstories you find inappropriately done and which ones are perfectly fine. I'm certain it's both. In particular, Hook has this weird thing with secrets for some reason. Regina's not really in this discussion as she didn't kill David's father. Regina has very few secrets undisclosed, where as Hook gets new ones every season. It's funny how even Rumple's wrongs were forgiven by Henry in 5A, but as soon as he goes a little dark, it's reverted.

I'm guessing it'll be shown to be Hook, but then revealed that he didn't kill him.