Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-1916997-20171222202521/@comment-2153169-20171223045416

CoolDudeAl wrote: Lady Junky wrote: Regina is not a member of the Coven. The members list of this group is not the list of people who cast the DC. Yes, they needed a eighth witch... because it is part of their ritual. It does not make Regina a part of their group.

If we want to put the Coven as casters + Regina as coerced to help them, fine. It would work. But Regina has absolutely nothing to do in the list of the Coven members.

Again, this is a list of people who belong to the Coven, not the list of people who cast the DC. You are literally the only person I have seen on this thread and the Coven's page who feels that way about Regina not being part of the Coven. Last I checked this wiki goes with group consensus. If everyone else agrees that Regina was part of the Coven of the Eight to cast the curse, that is what the page has to say. Then, you're wrong I suppose ^^ What I am reading on the thread is that people are mixing up "members of the Coven" and "people needed to cast the Curse". That's not the same thing.

Being forced to help someone does not make it a part of the group. The Coven of the Eight is not a page to list people who cast the curse. It is to list the witches that are part of the Coven, the "sisters" as Gothel calls them.

Now, unless someone really want to argue on the fact that Gothel is considering Regina as one of them... Contrary to Zelena, which we know was a potential candidate for the Coven, Regina has always been their ennemy. I highly doubt that Regina felt being a part of them, or even the other way.

Again, we have to clearly distinguish "members of the Coven" and "people needed to cast the Curse". Not the same thing.