Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-7526254-20170430003451/@comment-25926288-20190809213211

NeonshineX wrote: Hello, I hope ther're still fans out there in 2019. I don't get season seven. I think, they messed up some things. Maybe you can explain it to me? For example, it is said, that (the wish realm?) evil queen ripped out the hearts of young henrys parents and that's why Henry wants to kill Regina. But the wish realm queen already started to become good, when she saved the other characters in a former season. (Afterwards she & wish realm Robin fell in love) -> so, is the Evil Queen who killed Snow and Charming from another realm?? And young Henry is the Henry, who rembembered the call from grown-up Henry? And grown-up Henry remembered the call too, but not the hatred for the Evil Queen? Very confusing. But the oddest thing: Why can Rumpelstilskin inflict wish realm Rumpel by killing himself? They have nothing to do with each other. I wonder, why a wish realm Robin can exist, when the real one is dead. I can't wait for your answers and explanations .... Nope.

Regina went to Wish Realm in season 6 and killed Wish Henry’s grandparents. This is why Wish Henry wanted to kill Regina.

Wish Realm had a Wish Regina/Evil Queen but she was banished and was only seen in 7x07. Every other instance was Regina.

Henry calling past Henry was just a bootstrap paradox “aka this happens because it had to happen”.

As for Rumple and Wish Rumple.....never answered. Speculation is that Emma’s wish duplicated the Darkness creating Wish Rumple, but still maintained the connection.

My theory: Magic works via energy signatures. Wish Rumple and Rumple’s magic share the same energy signature and thus treats itself as the same.

Ex. When Henry sent the message in a bottle to Hook, it went to both Hooks because they both technically are the same person.