Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-25337271-20141030124727/@comment-24769579-20141109113521

Applegirl wrote: WinterWoodsGal wrote:

Applegirl wrote:

JCAdlawan wrote: Why can't we just make a page for Ice Creatures? Or we can only make for Marshmallow. I mean Elsa created Marshmallow, and Marshmallow is part of the Frozen cast.

The Ice Creatures page is an option if the majority of the community adhere to the idea. I joined this thread late, but it looks like the discussion is leaning away from having an Ice Creatures page and towards adding a Ice/Snow section on the Magic page and also putting in a template showing what ice creatures were made and by who. Concerning a possible Ice Creatures page, I wouldn't mind it at all, but I feel it's more unclear what to call the creatures since the three we've seen (Elsa's creation, the Snow Queen's ice warrior as well as her Anna replica) don't look alike at all, so do we know for sure they belong to the same species, or could we say (with certainty) that since they're made from the same kind of magic, so they could be considered a species?

It's highly debatable, but Marshmallow might be considered not an important enough character to have his own page. I say "might" because not everyone agrees that he is important enough, or that he is not important enough to have a page, but the end result of whether he gets a page or not depends on everyone's opinion on the issue. Since this is after Frozen, how do we know that the ice monster is called Marshmallow?

It seems the creature Elsa summoned resembles Marshmallow from Frozen, so I guess that's where people are getting the name from. Fair enough.