Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-1916997-20171222202521/@comment-2153169-20180502212641

Eskaver wrote: I think we are at the end of the day playing with words and speculation.

Do we know that the Eight Witch was reserved for the Guardian? No. Yes, we do.

Even if they do no say it as directly as us, that is fairly obvious by now. Gothel only tried to recruit so hard two persons so far: Ana & Alice. And who's the person she was interested before Ana? Rapunzel, cos she thought she was the Guardian.

Whatever is the spell she is doing in HH, she needs the Guardian who's someone with full magic potential in the LWM, something she lost herself. She needs her spell to work in the LWM, and for that she absolutely needs the Guardian. That's why she was so involved with Ana and did everything possible to get Alice once Ana left.

The Guardian is the last member of the Coven, no matter how we look at the situation. Regina was forced into giving them blood, nothing else. That does not make her, in any case, a Coven member.

Anyways, most of us seem to agree on just adding a note about Regina, stating that she is not a member but was forced into giving them her blood.