Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-2153169-20170909025746/@comment-24264679-20171111150416

Eskaver wrote: Lol, must we debate Wish Realm again.

Wish Realm is realm in a parallel universe (or book) that was accessed to by a wish. If genies can't bring back the dead, change the past, etc, they surely can't create an entire realm of people.

Wish Realm has no realm issues. Princess Emma simply must have merged with Emma...because magic. This is the same show where we had two Evil Queens, Spirits of Dark Ones, Rumple and Neal merging, etc.

The Writers said many contradictory things, so I'm pretty sure WR is a realm in a paralell universe

In Aladdin the Genie could reality warp but yet couldn't break the laws of Magic. That is what Once based the Genies powers on. Not bringing back the dead doesn't mean you can't reality warp. Two different things. Genies were portrayed as having powers over the Cosmos in the Aladdin movie. Thus you can bend the Universe to your whelm. However due to whoever created them they made it a rule that 3 types of wishes couldn't be made. However with the right wording and trickery you can get past those 3 rules.

Also pretty sure the magical forest is an extension of the Wishverse. WishHook knew Lady Tremaine yet no information about this realm or characters in this realm were possessed by any of the original realm(Non Wishverse) characters. There was never a storybook written on this realm. Henry had travelled to multiple realms before ending up in the magical forest.

The Wishverse is an entire Universe based on what if Regina never cast the curse.Unless you are a fanstasy buff you wont understand how it works. Realms can exist both in the same Universe and other Universes. So the Magical forest could exist within our Universe or the Wishverse Universe. Both Universe are real and posses History. Thus if Lady T and WishHook existed in the same Universe they would have been able to have history with each other. However our Hook never would have had any history with the Wishverse characters prior to the creation of the Wishverse.

If you are a science fiction or Fantasy buff this is pretty simple to understand. If not then you will be confused as hell.