Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-10663213-20180306175318/@comment-35348769-20180419195256

Lady Rapunzel wrote: Alena765 wrote: Lady Rapunzel wrote: Alena765 wrote: Lady Rapunzel wrote: Alena765 wrote: Lady Rapunzel wrote: Alena765 wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: Alena765 wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: Alena765 wrote: I can't believe what I read here. I'll never prefer such a vile character as Nook over Killian. Killian is so much better than him! He has five seasons of redemption and it's so perfect! Unlike Nook. God, he did NOTHING to redeem himself. He's only suffers due to the loss daughter, bur he does nothing. And redemption in 5 minutes, really? However, he planned to kill Killian and rape Emma, very cool. He didn't even think about the daughter. And he's definitely not a smart character, unlike Killian.

All comments in support of Nook come from people who hate Killian, everything is clear. Just don't forget that Nook is one f the reasons why this show was cancelled, bc peaple hate him and they will forget about him when it's all over. Killian and WishKillian are literally the same person in different versions of the same EF. People who hate one and love the other (in either direction), kind of don't make sense. Basically, it means you don't actually love or hate the character as an individual, you love or hate the idea of Emma's love interest. Is it serious? Dude, you're wrong. They are completely different! They have a completely different past (and to be precise, WHook doesn't have a past at all because he was created by the wish in episode 6x10). If you believe everything they say on the show, I feel sorry for you because you clearly don't see the logic.

Killian Jones is the only one and we love him. We don't see him as Emma's love interest. We hate WHook because he's an insult to his character. Killian Jones is not such an idiot and Killian Jones will never do that. If you hate Killian and CS, well, that's your problem. The whole Wish Realm being created in 610 has been disproven in Season 7, where we see FBs to things that happened between the Wish characters and other realms (such as WHook and Gothel concieving Alice). It is you who is not using logic, because the show clearly shows us this fact. Season 6 shows that everything here is not real and I agree with it. WHook is not real, nor is his rapist and daughter. Actually, that's wrong. In the time 610 aired Adam and Eddy said that in the second the Evil Queen granted Emma's wish the Wish Realm became real. So nope, it is not "fake." They said they weren't real people! So, following your logic, Regina is the killer of Wish Snowing. Because it's "real people". And you forget the fact that Regina and Emma themselves have repeated many times that it's not real. It's not like Regina and Emma were real experts with the Wish Realm. It's not like they knew everything about it (beyond Emma's memories as Princess Emma). This article was published on December 3, 2016, and that was revealed by the own writers. What are you even discussing about? The writers themselves on Twitter said that the WW and the people who are there aren't real right after the episode. So what are you talking about? Have you even bothered yourself to read the article? It's from December 3, 2016, by the time the episode aired (one day before it, actually). I believe what was written by the writers themselves on their Twitter accounts, where they told EVERYONE that WW isn't real.

This conversation doesn't make sense. Your evidence is meaningless for me, my evidence are meaningless to you.

At all, I told my opinion about WHook and this not will change. He's not the same person as Killian. You can't have an opinion on a inaccurate fact that you have evidence that is not real. But okay. I'm just losing my time with this discussion tbh. There are screenshots from the writers of the show telling that 'Regina didn't commit murder against Wish Snowing because Wish people aren't real' also there's others like if the curse would've never been casted, what we watched on 6x11 and 6x12 wouldn't have been the real stoyline after those events.