Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-27060727-20180128024732/@comment-31147694-20180331221126

CoolDudeAl wrote: Kunica wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: Kunica wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: Kunica wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: It 100% isn't Chad, Chad is just a LWM person. Maybe but with writters you cant ever be sure,evean if they confirmed it on Twitter or another webiste or previous episodes.They can do another twist that disregards about what they previously stated in concerns of Guardian or a LWM character,right now since Anastasia is no longer the Guardian many people think the next one is gonna be Lucy or Alice but why chouldent be a male version,besides both Lucy and Alice have some lets say "flaws" that make them unfit for a Guardian postion.So i am still betting on Chad. There is no reason why a LWM person from California would be the Guardian. That makes no sense. It is more likely to be Facilier or Gothel than to be Chad. It makes sense if in a weird and unexpected twist is reveald that way,do you remmber your idea that "Candy Killer is Jack/Hansel" that you predicted on your theory and hunch that nobody belived or saw including when all evidance was pointing to Mr.Samdi or Drew was in yesterday confirmed correct.Will see in next 3 episode who shall be reveald as a Guardian and to who the evidance points to. A lot of people agreed with the theory, and besides that the difference is there were things pointing to Jack really being Hansel and the killer. Nothing points to Chad being anything other than a LWM love interest for Zelena, and if anything the writers specifically point out that he is normal, as that is something they haven't done before. Notice how the writers never really said anything about Jack. With Chad they were super clear who he was. As you pointed out that Writters already confirmed that Chad was not a magical-fairytale love intrest but just a oridnary LWM guy this whould mean that they were clear about that,but i still i cant shake of the feeling that like with what they did with Jack they wont slowly do the same thing with Chad.Like instead of popular theories regarding Guardian and evidance that will probably point to Alice,"bumm suprise twist ,its not Alice its Chad"so i am just preparing myself. I agree it might not be Alice (it can be Henry, Ella, Lucy, Robin, Tiana, etc.), so that would still be a twist. Chad just doesn't make sense, plus, he isn't even in this episode, as far as we know. So we may get a twist, but it being Chad is almost not what the twist is. I agree that it dosent have to be a Alice it can be Robin,Lucy or Tiana but Henry not so much,but as you said it whould still be a twist.But the reason why a Guardian twist revealing Chad whould make sense because"it just whouldent make sense" and it whould be totally unexpect than any other theory since all previous characters are from NFTL while he is a LWM character,and it will also connect to Zelena/Kelly reveal to him and how he will strugle to acept that"Magic exist,that his fiance is a witch from fairytale,he is a magical being known as Guardian and that because of his now found powers 3 parties are trying to get to him".

But also the Guardian is said to be yes a hero of pure of heart ,but also some one who will have knowledge,wisdom and magic in regarding Darkness,since as we know the relased Darkness will not go down without a fight.Lucy is maybe innocent and pure of heart but still very young,inexprinced and not ready for that title while Tillly is yes in right age  and pure of heart but since she shot Wevear in a state of "fused fairytale-lwm cursed person" mind she was starting to loose her sanity and in previous flashbacks in wich was reveald she inherted the magic if she was the Guardian "Before Anastasia" then why dint Gothel act then.Eithere way i have created a " New Guardian" thread were we can disscuse this theories there and not here.