Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5965318-20141208022925/@comment-32390199-20141214190535

I somehow think that Lily is a relative of The Sorcerer, only because of the star-shaped scar she has. And that she was send away to the LWM by her (grand)father (dunno if The Sorcerer will be young or old) as she actually was fated to become friends with Emma and stay with her.

But ultimately the people make the choices. So just like how Regina decided not to meet Robin in the past, Emma and Lily didn't become friends in the past.