Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-10663213-20180306175318/@comment-1916997-20180419124915

Alena765 wrote: I can't believe what I read here. I'll never prefer such a vile character as Nook over Killian. Killian is so much better than him! He has five seasons of redemption and it's so perfect! Unlike Nook. God, he did NOTHING to redeem himself. He's only suffers due to the loss daughter, bur he does nothing. And redemption in 5 minutes, really? However, he planned to kill Killian and rape Emma, very cool. He didn't even think about the daughter. And he's definitely not a smart character, unlike Killian.

All comments in support of Nook come from people who hate Killian, everything is clear. Just don't forget that Nook is one f the reasons why this show was cancelled, bc peaple hate him and they will forget about him when it's all over. Killian and WishKillian are literally the same person in different versions of the same EF. People who hate one and love the other (in either direction), kind of don't make sense. Basically, it means you don't actually like or hate the character as an individual, you like or hate the idea of Emma's love interest.