Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20161205015930/@comment-24674051-20161206182838

We don't know for sure if we are going to see WR Hook (** and if we do know, then that would be considered a spoiler and should not be posted here in any case **)  However, I would not expect the WR Hook to be the man we know from Storybrooke. WR Killian should still be a hard core pirate with a single goal, and that is the extermination of Rumple.

As for Regina 'knowing' the WR is fake. I have to disagree. First, She is physically standing there, so whether or not it is fake does not matter (and by the way, it is not fake), because as far as she is concerned, it is real while she is there. And seeing Robin alive and in front of her is going to be a huge shock, particularly since she is still grieving his loss. That kind of shock is going to disorient her, which is exactly what was shown. I felt that scene was very well played and very realistic.

An interesting thing about Emma and Regina being trapped in the Wish Realm is that we are guaranteed to have SwanQueen scenes for at least 1 episode, which are some of the best scenes (in my opinion).