Lily (Episode)

"Lily" is the nineteenth episode of Season Four of ABC's Once Upon a Time. It was written by Andrew Chambliss & Dana Horgan, and directed by Ralph Hemecker. It is the eighty-fifth episode of the series overall, and premiered on April 26, 2015.

Synopsis
Emma’s potential for darkness is looming over everyone, but when Emma realizes Maleficent's daughter Lily is in fact her closest friend from her foster care days, she resolves to find Lily and reunite her with her mother. Regina joins forces with Emma and together they set out to track down Lily and to warn Robin about Zelena. However, neither of them is prepared for the harsh realities they’ll encounter in the outside world. Meanwhile, in Storybrooke, Gold faces a crisis involving Belle. In a foster care flashback, things are looking up for young Emma with her new family until Lily’s appearance threatens to destabilize everything.

Recap
In the past, Emma is happy in her foster home when she goes into the garage to get something for their family camping trip. She hears something and takes a bat to see what it is. She finds Lily hiding and asks what she's doing there. Lily says she is in trouble and needs Emma's help. While they are arguing, Emma's foster father comes in and asks who it is. Lily tells him she is an old friend of Emma's and her foster family just moved into the neighborhood.

Lily stays for dinner and lies about how they met. Emma is angry and takes her into the kitchen, where she sees Lily on the news as a suspect for an armed robbery. Lily begs her to get a necklace from her boyfriend's house, since she doesn't want to see him as he was the one who made her do the robbery.

When Emma returns, she discovers Lily has left and stolen their vacation money. Her foster parents are angry and when her father makes a comment that makes Emma feel like an outcast, she leaves. Lily finds her sitting at a bus stop and tells her that she freed her from the burden of family life. When Lily begs Emma to join her and run away together, Emma tells her she's done helping her and is better off alone. Later, Lily is riding the bus and examines her necklace. A elderly man tells her it is a lovely necklace and compliments the birthmark on her hand. He is the Apprentice and tells her he has many answers for all her questions. He admits he is partially responsible for her misery and offers to tell her all about her life, starting with her mother.

Emma watches as Gold and the Author bury Cruella. At the restaurant, she vows to retaliate against Gold while her parents, son, Regina and Hook were all seated, looking very uncertain as they regarded her. Maleficent enters and tells her she can help with that. She reveals her daughter is alive and wants Emma to help find her. After learning her name is Lily, Emma researches the archives and discovers it is the same teenager she knew. Regina finds her and realizes it is the same friend Emma told her about, the one she pushed away. Regina tells Emma there are powers they can't understand and asks her to come with her and push back at fate. They ready to leave for New York as Gold approaches Will in his shop. Threateningly, he orders Will to steal back Belle's heart from Regina. Emma and Regina say their goodbyes to Henry. Mary Margaret tries to give her a hug but Emma gives her the cold shoulder and tells her to watch Henry. David promises they will. Regina brings the Snow Queen's scroll and they leave to find Lily. They get an old address but upon arriving, they learn that she has died. Emma gets angry when the man calls Lily a monster and nearly punches him but Regina stops her. Later, they are driving when a wolf in the middle of the road causes them to stop and get a flat. They go to a local diner while Regina gets the car towed. Emma notices the star birthmark on the waitress's wrist and realizes that Lily is not dead. She approaches her and Lily lies, telling her she is happy and Emma doesn't need to be sorry for her misery. Emma knows she is lying, steals her address and they go to her real house. Meanwhile, Mary Margaret and David go to the mayor's office and apologize to Maleficent. Bitterly, she tells them they should apologize to Lily, but it is unlikely that she will forgive them.

Back in Massachusetts, Emma and Regina discover a map and pieces of information in Lily's room that reveals she knows the truth about her and what Emma's parents did to her. They hear their car being stolen and rush outside as Lily drives away. Emma steals another car and they chase after Lily. Upon cornering her, they question how long she has known. Lily taunts Emma and they fight until Emma pulls a gun on her. Lily tells her to pull the trigger but Regina begs her not to since it will turn her dark just like Gold wants. After a tense moment, Emma lowers the gun.

Gold goes to the mayor's office and confronts Maleficent. Maleficent tells him if he wants Belle's heart to come in and get it. He reaches forward through the door but is blocked, revealing Regina's protection spell. Maleficent tells him she won't release Belle's heart and Emma is already on her way to find Lily and will be fine. Gold implies Lily will help make Emma dark. As they talk, Gold distracts Maleficent as Will sneaks in and escapes with Belle's heart. Maleficent is irritated at this and Gold leaves. Later, Gold finds Belle and Will, who has shown Belle her heart in a box, and apologizes for deceiving her. He tells her he won't hurt her anymore and that Will will protect her now before returning it to her chest.

Regina discovers she no longer has leverage over Gold, and tells Emma and Lily they have to warn Robin about Zelena. At his apartment, Regina sees Robin and asks if Marian is home. Learning she is not, Regina quickly tells him Zelena killed Marian and has been posing as her. Robin can't believe it and moments later, Marian comes home and acts frightened. Regina threatens her and Robin tries to calm the situation before Zelena reveals herself. Regina tells him to get Roland so they can go, but he says he can't. Reveling in the moment, Zelena grins wickedly as a shocked Robin reveals she is pregnant.

Starring

 * Ginnifer Goodwin as Mary Margaret Blanchard
 * Jennifer Morrison as Emma Swan
 * Lana Parrilla as Regina Mills
 * Josh Dallas as David Nolan
 * Emilie de Ravin as Belle French
 * Colin O'Donoghue as Hook
 * Jared S. Gilmore as Henry Mills
 * Michael Socha as Will Scarlet
 * Robert Carlyle as Mr. Gold

Guest Starring

 * Kristin Bauer van Straten as Maleficent
 * Agnes Bruckner as Lily
 * Patrick Fischler as Isaac
 * Christie Laing as Maid Marian
 * Rebecca Mader as Zelena
 * Sean Maguire as Robin Hood
 * Timothy Webber as The Apprentice
 * Nicole Munoz as Young Lily
 * Abby Ross as Young Emma

Co-Starring

 * Cameron Bancroft as Bill
 * Kendall Cross as Katie
 * Phil Granger as Landlord
 * Sidney Shapiro as Max
 * Parker Magnuson as Zach
 * Zoey Siewert as Brunette Girl
 * Jonathan Adams as Disembodied Voice

Uncredited

 * Carlton Cuse as TV news reporter (Voice)

Quotes
Emma: Do I wish I could change what I did to Cruella? Yes, but that's regret, not darkness. I think we've all done things we regret.

Regina: I knew Gold couldn't keep the dragon on her leash for long.

Regina: I have to save Robin from my insane sister.

Hook: As someone who started on the side of good and went dark, take my advice—Vengeance is tempting, it always is. Resist it.

Maleficent: Well, you've been so worried that the Dark One might turn Emma into a monster, you forgot, that's exactly what you did to my Lilith. So if I won't forgive you, why would she?

Lily: (To Emma) Your parents deserve to be punished!

Mr. Gold: (To Belle) I'm returning your heart, but it's his job to guard it.

Lily: (To Emma) It's like I'm hardwired for bad decisions.

Trivia

 * -|Production Notes=

Production Notes

 * The title card features Emma's yellow bug.
 * This title card was also used for "Smash the Mirror".
 * This episode contains the most difficult scene for Lana Parrilla in the entire series.
 * A gravestone in the Storybrooke Graveyard says:

Remembered Always

CYRIL HARGROVE

1902 - 1987


 * According to the microfiche Emma is reading, Lily was baptized around August 14. 1983. Her adoptive parents are James and Priscilla Page.
 * The outdoor Storybrooke scene with Mr. Gold, the Author, Belle and Will was filmed in Fort Langley, British Columbia.
 * A Fort Langley bus stop doubles as the Polar Star Intercity Bus stop for the final scene with young with Emma and Lily.
 * The news report on Lily's robbery says "Convenience Store Robbery in the Blue Ridge District". According to the security footage, the robbery took place in a store called Pawtucket Mini Mart & Deli on 1437 Belkin Avenue.
 * Interestingly, the gas station next to The Coffee Mug diner, where Lily is working as an adult, is called the Pawtucket Gas Stop.
 * Lily's "daughter" is wearing a star printed dress.
 * Lily's billboard includes:
 * Notes on Emma, Snow White, Prince Charming, the Evil Queen, Maleficent, Ursula, Cruella De Vil, Rumplestiltskin and the Author.
 * Two illustrations from Sneewittchen (1905), a German edition of the "Snow White" fairytale, illustrated by the German book illustrator Franz Jüttner. One illustration depicts the Evil Queen, while the other one shows Snow White and the seven dwaves.
 * "Schneewittchen" ("Snow White"), an illustration by the German illustrator Alexander Zick. It depicts Prince Charming and the seven dwarves gathered around Snow White's glass coffin.
 * "'I know what you want' said the sea witch" (c. 1910), an engraving by the Irish stained glass-artist and book illustrator Harry Clarke. It depicts the a scene from Hans Christian Andersen's fairytale "The Little Mermaid", with the titular character and the sea witch (although most of the little mermaid herself is obscured by a note, so only her face can be seen).
 * A newspaper clipping says "Boy spotted in the United States - but where?". A Weekly World News front page reads: "Toy becomes a real boy".
 * Above the clippings, there is a photograph of a merman's trident.
 * Attached to a note which says "the Author", there are two pages from the book News from Nowhere (1890), written by the English novelist and socialist pioneer William Morris. In the book, the narrator falls asleep and awakes to find himself in a future society based on common ownership and democratic control of the means of production.
 * The sign on Lily's trailer house says "Broadmore". The address number is 9.
 * The vanity license plate on Lily's car reads "SYLVIA".
 * -|Episode Connections=

Event Chronology

 * The Enchanted Forest events take place after "Best Laid Plans" and before the casting of the Dark Curse in "Pilot".
 * The Land Without Magic flashback scenes take place in 1999, the year after "Breaking Glass" and before "Tallahassee" and "There's No Place Like Home". The story also takes place in the same year as the flashbacks with Emma and Ingrid in "Shattered Sight".
 * The present day Land Without Magic events place after "Sympathy for the De Vil".
 * -|Cultural References=

Biblical

 * Emma and her foster family say grace before dinner.

Fairytales and Folklore

 * This episode features the Sorcerer and the Apprentice from the Sorcerer's Apprentice story, and Captain Hook from the Peter Pan story.

Lost

 * Emma and her foster family have takeout from Mr. Cluck Chicken Shack for dinner. This is a famous fast food franchise in the show.

Popular Culture

 * Pinned to Lily's billboard is a cover story from Weekly World News, a largely fictional news tabloid published in the United States from 1979 to 2007.
 * There are Cobra seats in Lily's car.
 * Lily sarcastically addresses the Apprentice as "Yoda"; a reference to the famous alien from the Star Wars franchise.