Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24589671-20140707192733/@comment-5834856-20140710153359

ChocolatEyes613 wrote: DZAV21 wrote:

If there's a ship it could be the Jolly Roger because it's suppose to come back. While that is the prop for the Jolly Roger, it might be a different ship in the episode. OUaT does not have a largest budget, so recycling is necessary. Long story short.... that ship might not be the Jolly Roger.

Though, one does have to wonder which storyline Hook's flashback will fit into.... Arendelle or Sherwood Forest? If so, I'm fine with a flashback  but an idea came to me. Back in Good Form  it was revealed to us that Hook before becoming a pirate was a first lieutnant in some king's navy. He wanted his soldiers to gather the medicine Dreamshade which is actually a poison for him. The king hoped to gain advantage using it at war. However, if I remember correctly, the producers, so far never told us which king had send Killian and his brother on the mission. There are many possibilities.

I know it's unlikely but it might be that the Jewel of the Realm (renamed Jolly Roger) was the King of Arrendale's HMS. Hook sold his ship to gain a magic bean. What if the king has learned of that and managed to reclaim his ship? Hook stole it from him after all.

I would regret to see the Jolly Roger sinking though. It might be best if it's another ship.