Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-25926288-20151130132802/@comment-6175354-20151204024427

CTrent29 wrote:

There is nothing special about Hook's potential for evil, as far as I'm concerned. If this is some convoluted campaign to convince everyone that he is unworthy of Emma, I'm no buying it. I'm not into painting characters with some one-dimensional, black-and-white morality. Agreed....

It is like some fans forgot about everything that happened, before Hook learned that Emma turned him into a Dark One. That includes what was happening in Storybrooke. Hook might not have known that he was a Dark One, but he was in control of himself. Excalibur could not control him, while it was in the stone. Heck.... that was why he put the sword back there, in the first place.