Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-26830263-20170710210232/@comment-6175354-20171010070416

Emillian Swanones wrote: However, I think that if Rogers is a cloned doppleganger or another duplicate of Killian, he would still be the same character.

That being said, I think that in order for Emma and Killian to keep their happy ending, they can't be separted by realms, they have to be reunited at some point. A doppleganger or clone just looks like the person. However, it is a completely different character. It would not be Hook.

This is no longer Emma and Hook's story. This is now just Hook's story of what happens after the final battle. He is never going to be reunited with Emma on-screen. So, why even bother hinting at the possibility?