Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-10663213-20180306175318

In my opinion, what killed the show after season 4 was CS (IN MY OWN OPINION) and it's not because Emma didn't stayed with someone else. It's because it was badly done. It's not Colin's fault. He is a wonderful actor and I used to love Hook until season 3.... But after that.... he and his actions, his "redemption arc" that, in my opinion didn't happen as he, on the day of his marriage, still wanted revenge against Gold... For me, they aren't the same because, Nook is truly a hero, who regrets of his past. Who deserves a happy ending (hopefully with Tiana). What made he change from the sick sexist person that he was once, was his daughter Alice.... So, for me, they are completely opposite characters 