Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-5679696-20171014023101/@comment-2153169-20180313025842

FrancisPaul wrote: Lady Junky wrote: FrancisPaul wrote: Another thing I think that doesn't make sense is keeping categories apart. We'll have icons and appearances and history of both counterparts in the same page but we should add the categories just in the counterpart they apply? That makes zero sense to me. What's the point in merging if we are still making that kind of distinction? It does make perfectly sense. While we merge the content of the pages, the categories still help to say exactly which counterpart appeared when. Like that, we're not loosing entirely some info/details, without making two appearance sections (which was already ruled out). I agree that two appearance sections shouldn't be used.

But I still think that it's either "that" or "not that". Keeping the category doesn't help to say exactly which counterpart appeared when, because the user would still have to check the episode if he wants to know that. If one thinks that it is important to know which Happy, EF or SB, appeared in S3, I could argue that it is not more important than knowing which Happy appeared in "Souls of the Departed", yet that is not in the page either, so why should the season matter if the episode does not? You may not like this, but many users were concerned by the "loss" of info during this merge.

Keeping the categories separated is an easy way to keep some of these "lost" info.