Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-25491743-20151002171811/@comment-5817180-20151224012622

Lady Junky wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: Killian Jones wrote: No, we won't add during third curse just to consider the curse broken when it's not. The restoring of memories was not breaking the curse, neither is Emma killing Hook and reverting to normal.

And no, so far, we have seen zero evidence that they are currently cursed. The curse was cast to send people from one world to another, nothing else. Its effect was immediate, and did not remain "active" after succesfully transporting people to the LWM. We don't really know that. And besides, what is turning people into trees at the townline, if not a curse? The townline has always been cursed. And in any case it is related to a Dark Curse. S3b, dark curse is used but no curse on the townline, just some monkeys guards. S4, the townline is cursed but no DC. So yeah, the townline being curse is not the point in this discussion.

And, as explained Killian, we have ZERO proof at this point that's they are cursed or still under an active curse. That's a speculation based on the previous curses. Well, not including a during the third curse would defy the canon, and without any reasoning for doing so. The canon exists for a reason, and we cannot simply disregard it just because of the wishes of the few. A dark curse is still a dark curse, and cannot simply be disregarded like that. Besides, the curse plotline isn't technically over yet; the camelot residents are still in storybrooke, and we don't know how or when they are going back, if at all. The dark curse will need to be broken by a savior. First it was Emma, then Regina. I'm still betting it will be broken by either 1 of them and their true loves (hook and robin, respectively), or Henry and that camelot girl. Regardless, just because the curse was cast to transport them to storybrooke, that doesn't mean that entire functions of the curse will be disregarded. And just because a few of them now have their memories back, that doesn't mean that the curse is broken. Don't forget, there were plenty of times when people regained their memories before the curse was broken. Oh, and by the way, technically, Emma cast the curse too; she is a dark one, therefore, like hook, she too, is also Nimue, therefore, she also cast the curse, explaining how she manipulated it to do things like bring over the Camelot residents, and the sword, as the curse was designed to create the perfect world for its caster.