Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-6175354-20131205143032/@comment-1916997-20131216210724

As far as the which witch (hee hee) are we getting debate, I think it would be best to stick with only book canon with some 1939 Wizard of Oz movie mixed in (like the green skin). As much as I like other adaptations of her, I don't want Elphaba, Theodora, or any other later adaptation of her on Once, they are other people's takes on the original character, and I want Eddy and Adam's. Besides, it makes much more sense for her to be something like the Black Fairy or Cruella or Morgan Le Fay, with the way Once works. I just hope people remember this when they see her, and don't go all crazy because "that's not how Elphaba would act", or "Theodora wasn't evil because of this", etc.