Board Thread:Show-Related Questions and Answers/@comment-25974054-20150303234022/@comment-26184517-20150309013424

After Unforgiven, I am nearly certain she is Maleficent's daughter. Emma and Lily are they same age, and Snow and Maleficent were pregnant at the same time. Maleficent knew before Snow, so Lily could have been born shortly before Emma, aka before the Curse. Someone, maybe Snow, Charming, or Maleficent got her to safty in the land without magic.

And due to the fact Lily has a star birth mark, I have a feeling the Sorceror was behind it. (Or the blue Fairy, but not as likely). Who else has the uncanny ability to transport people between worlds.

Maybe Lily was sent there by the sorceror because of her ability for great good. (To save Emma or stop Emma).

The Episode after Lily is titled "Mother". I hope that we get to see an emotional reunion between Lily and her mother, and or her with Emma.

Young Lily and Young Emma will be in Lily, so their time in their "house" may be explored or maybe their paths crossed again later. Cruella and Ursula both were outside Storybrooke without their memries, maybe one of the found Lily. (The adoptive parents Lily hated?)

Which then brings the question, why were they not in Storybrooke?