Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-4877635-20150304180627/@comment-24674051-20150316144535

All good points, and I rather think that Emma is a true Charming. I threw the alternate Idea out as I do many, to see which ones float, and which ones sink. While the writers could possibly make the idea work, it does leave a lot more unanswered questions, so I am going to put this idea in my "sink to the bottom of the ocean" category.

Of course, I still think there is some sort of connection between Emma and Lily (and I still think Lily is quite likely Mal's daughter). However, I think we can now safely rule out Stefan as the Father. It's kinda hard to have children when you are nothing more than charred ashes.