Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-26443838-20160105035933/@comment-26159109-20160107152203

ChocolatEyes613 wrote: Farerb wrote: I thought that at least they would made it sensible that Zelena pretended to be Marian through out the entire S3 finale and not just at the end. That is what most fans originally thought happened, when Marian randomly showed up in the S3 finale. Exactly! It would have made much more sense.

It would explained:

1. Why Robin didn't know that Regina imprisoned his wife.

2. Why Marian suddenly care about Snow while Robin doesn't even recognize her.

3. Why Marian wasn't with her child.

4. Why they way she "died" contradicts how Robin explained it to Regina.

5. The previous points from my last post.