Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20180317113833

I never really thought about it. Most say the stand-in of the Witch Killer was Caucasian and possibly feminine. Plus, Tilly was hardly seen around, so I really think she is the killer. But why would Gothel who seemingly knows about Tilly's "issues" happy? Because it's exactly what Gothel wants.

I believe that perhaps Gothel intended to find the Witches and do a cult-like mass sacrifice, but Tilly beat her to the punch and is simply being a useful tool for Gothel. Why? Well, I don't know her big plan, but...

1. IF Tilly is the Witch Killer, why else would Gothel annoy Tilly at the station? (Using her hatred and sensing a pattern for her to perform her tasks.)

2. IF Tilly is the Killer (and she had a useful scapel), why would Tilly be snipping pieces of hair unless she's gathering them, which Gothel will swoop in and steal it?

3. Gothel played Drizella like a tool. Why are the other Coven members cursed? They weren't faking it, seeing as Andrea tried to remove the "tattoo".

That's what I'm going with. Either Alice really was that crazy and Gothel is just going to be lucky or Gothel was planning what anyway and Tilly is just a nice tool to use. 