Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-1916997-20171009223757/@comment-1916997-20180713125548

Black Necked Swan wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: Black Necked Swan wrote: Cinderella (104) VS Cinderella (701)

Lady Tremaine (603) VS Lady Tremaine (701)

Clorinda or Tisbe (603) VS Drizella (701)

Clorinda or Tisbe (603) VS Red Queen (Wonderland) VS Anastasia (703)

Alice (Wonderland) VS Alice (701)

Fairy Godmother (104) VS Fairy Godmother (701)

Prince Thomas (104) VS Prince and Henry Mills (701)

Rapunzel (314) VS Lady Tremaine/Rapunzel (701)

Charming as Rapunzel's Prince (314) VS Wish Hook as "Rapunzel's" Prince (707)

Manifestation of Rapunzel's fear (314) VS Witch/Mother Gothel (703)

Jack (213) VS Jack (708)

Blind Witch (109) VS Hilda (712)

Robin Hood (219) VS Robin (710)

Gretel (109) VS Gretel (715)

Hansel (109) VS Hansel/Jack (708)

Woodcutter (109) VS Ivo (717)

Maleficent (102) VS Unnamed Dragon (721)

Aurora (201) VS Princess (721)

Phillip (201) VS Handsome Prince (721)

However, we'got a few more I think!

Let me add these suggestions:

Ariel (306) VS Ursula (411)

Ursula (306) VS Ursula (411)

Elsa (322) VS Ingrid (402)

For the Sleeping Beauties, could Briar Rose be considered? And for the Blind Witches, we first had a Blind Witch in 102. Emma Caulfield's BW rules though! Yes, things like Ariel, Ursula, Elsa, Ingrid, Aurora, Briar Rose, and even more (Phillip was a one of Belle's beasts, for example), were both takes on the same character in various ways, but I didn't include them as they are from the same storybook, whereas Season 7 characters are from an entirely different storybook than Season 1 - 6. Well, that's true, but then again Robin/Baby Hood isn't from a different storybook at all - she was born on Season 5. She has more relevance on Season 7 but she wasn't a new character. In any case, I think there should be two lists (one for S7 new iterations and one for S1-6 version of the same character in the same universe). Yeah, the Robin's are a bit of a grey area, but I decided to include them, since she didn't fulfill the role of Robin Hood until she was in the NEF. People are welcome to discuss Season 1-6 iterations, although I believe many people have talked about those before on other threads.