Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20151116014923/@comment-6175354-20151116235237

Edward Zachary Sunrose wrote: See... I don't know why everyone in the show and in real life is mad about Hook being another Dark One. Yeah, Emma turned him into the thing he hates most, but she did it because she loved him and didn't want him to die.

I'd do the same thing for my boyfriend. Without hesitation. Hook begged Emma, not to turn him into the Dark One. His dying wish was for her to destroy the Darkness. Hook was at peace, and hopeful that Emma would be able to move on.

Emma might have done this out of love, but it was selfish and desperate. We all know, that Hook would never have done this to her. There is a reason one of the first things he said, after he snapped, was "so much for our future, Swan". She created a monster who hates what he is.... and that makes him very dangerous.