Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-28011742-20170329211301/@comment-31231929-20170330020708

I don't think they broke up. Emma just called off the engagement, which doesn't necessarily mean breaking up. From Killian's viewpoint, they're still together, but from Emma's side of things, she's hurt and confused about why he didn't come home but I think she believes they are still together, just taking an involuntary break of sorts.

But when speaking of how the scene went, I thought it was done very well acting wise, but didn't like how Emma immediately called off the engagement insted of trying to work through things first.