Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-10663213-20180306175318/@comment-35348342-20180419132923

Nightlily wrote: Alena765 wrote:

Nightlily wrote: Alena765 wrote:

Eskaver wrote: Aine1989 wrote: Okay......

Thing is, I think it does kind of work that Nook's redemption arc was short handed. Because we saw over the course of 5 seasons how Killian has redeemed himself, so we don't need to see it again. Telling the same story twice would just be boring.

I mean at their core, they are the same person. Agreed. Plus Hook was never one who really required as much to redeem as the mass murdering tyrants that roam about the show. He was a bully and a typicalpirate but he was more opportunistic than deranged.

And...I’m pretty sure “Nook” was not the reason the show was cancelled. Not even within the top 100 reasons. I think the fan goggles need to be removed because both Hooks are the same person and it’s like there’s some cognitive dissonance. Hook was pretty okay when interacting with Ursula until his opportunistic streak broke through. Actin. As though that Hook is somehow “better” than Nook is pretty stretchy.

In addition, “Nook was trying to kill Hook and rape Emma and wasn’t thinking about Alice”.....is completely wrong and ignores the end of the episode. Did the episode cut off early? Nook clearly didn’t kill Hook and was under the assumption that if he could share a TLK with Emma that he could be free to live with Alice. He was trying to get to Storybrooke with Emma! He tried to kill Killian! He definitely wasn't thinking about his daughter at this moment. You know what? He only remembered her when Emma said she was pregnant. Have you watched the episode? Wish Hook says, "A child. That's why I'm doing all this in this first place. I'm trying to find my daughter." and "A vengeful witch trapped her in a prison. Every day, I'd sneak in to play chess with her. But I was discovered and punished. My heart was poisoned, cursed. So I can never save her. I knew that true love was the cure. So I roamed the realms seeking it, but it was futile. Then, I thought, maybe Emma." So he was definitely thinking of his daughter. And that is why he tried "to take the place of Killian" at the same time killing him and to go to Storybrooke to Emma where his daughter is definitely not? Don't see the logic. He didn't think about her at all. Obviously, he was going to return to Alice once his heart was cured. I thought that was obvious. Again, this does not negate the fact that he was planning to go to Storybrooke, and the killing of Killian, to take his place.