Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-6175354-20161010033114/@comment-24674051-20161020140103

Batuhan03 wrote: My money is on either Hook or Regina See my previous post. Regina is not old enough at the point of Daddy Charming's death to have done the deed. She would barely be a teenager, and is probably more interested in riding horses than in killing people. If you go towards a Mills woman, it would be Cora. and then you would still have the question of motivation.

Same with Killian. I don't see any motive that would lead a pirate (who by all appearances is not a sword for hire) to kill some seemingly random Sheep Rancher and then cover it up with a fake wreck. And since he spent most of his time in Neverland, the chances are remote that he would even be in the EF, and in that part of the EF, at the time that Daddy Charming was murdered.

My money is still on Rumple, and on the fact that Rumple made a deal to have Daddy Charming disappear or suffer the consequences.