Talk:Authors/@comment-33386384-20180527001035/@comment-26967699-20180527003326

Nope, this is different than the Darkness situation. After the wish is made, the Darkness literally hosted the WRumple, whose Darkness is connected to main Rumple's.

WHenry is not the Author. He was not chosen by the Sorcerer and the Apprentice. In this case, the pen just can't distinguish who is real and who is wish, due to both Henrys being the identical and same person. Just like the bottle went to both Hooks in 702