Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-25315804-20161129043202/@comment-25375217-20161129060101

Lady Junky wrote: The difference between your argument and my argument is that I am basing mine on facts, and what we know.

You are basing your argument on what we don't know, which is the flawed logic. If we think like you, then we can put as unknown all our information, because if we think like you, then nothing is confirmed ^^

When we use the facts, we do know Ursula's mom was a mermaid and that her father was a deity. We also do know that she was not a demigoddess. The same can be applied there. We do know that Rumple as clearly nothing of a fairies in him. We don't even know if it is a possibility for him to have some fairies parts, as we never saw a male fairy on this show, which seem to show that male can't be a fairy.

Again, we have more arguments showing that he does look like to be human rather a half human or half fairy. That's why this info should just stay in the trivia section ^^ How do we know she was not a demigoddess? When was her species ever stated to specifically not be demigoddess? The definition of "demigod(ess)" is a half-deity, half-mortal. And we know that's what Ursula is. That makes her a demigoddess with mermaid blood.

Rumple also has the attributes of a shapeshifter who took human form, or a dragon-person who is unable to transform (like Lily in the LWM or Depressedicent). But his attributes are irrelevant, because his bloodline and therefore his genes and species are half fairy and half human, because he was born to a fairy and a human. How do you know he doesn't look half-human and half-fairy? He's the only known example. The only other half-human is Hercules, who looks mostly human... but so do deities, so that's irrelevant. Rumplestiltskin is a unique case, so your comparisons are heavily flawed.