Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-6274680-20171113235602/@comment-25926288-20171115135940

And as I say elsewhere, Alice is very unlikely to be Hook's daughter. \

1. They have never went through the trouble of giving a person three credited/script names in a given season.

2. Eloise is Hook's daughter. We already know that Alice isn't Eloise as Sam Ochotta warned someone that he was trying to find her and that he would know what Eloise looks like (he has all the details on the filed missing reports, etc. Rogers isn't that oblivious.