Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-34360784-20180116101248/@comment-1916997-20180119023857

DatNuttyKid wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: DatNuttyKid wrote:

Furthermore, the statements you're citing are vague in and of themselves, even barring the pre-existing Wish Realm debacle. How would Wish Hook know what Hook's mother's name is? Because the mother is literally the same person! Hook and WHook are the same person, just in different timelines! How can Hook have a different mother, and still be Hook? That's my point! How can Robin be 28 years younger, and still be Robin? How can Snow and Charming have their lives be exactly the same but somehow stop Regina? How can everything have happened exactly the same and Stealthy is still alive? Your talking about entirely different things. Snow would still be the child of Leopold and Eva in the Wish Realm, right? Because if she was the child of let's say Leopold and Cora, then she wouldn't be Snow, or not the Snow played by Ginny. Same thing with Charming. His parents are still Ruth and Robert, right? Because otherwise, how is he still Charming played by Josh. For someone claiming to be so worried about keeping things factual, you certainly don't seem to understand human biology, at least not if you are trying to tell me that WHook can have different parents, and still be WHook played by Colin. I just don't get it.