Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-36759327-20181104204231/@comment-1581533-20190106211610

CoolDudeAl wrote: Schroeswald wrote: Truest Believer wrote:

Schroeswald wrote: I think it works, one question is if a consensus is reached on this does Treasure Island deserve a page (I think it does). It might be on the List of Minor Stories. It is there, the question is if we consider Liam to take the place of Jim Hawkins does it deserve more than that. I always thought it was enough of an adaptation to deserve a page, but others felt it was too minor. In my opinion it wasn't. They simply named a character after Silver even though they are nothing alike.