Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-5106672-20150427031408

Okay, follow on my train of thoughts.

So, we have strong implications that the Apprentice wasn't cursed and he travelled to the Land Without Magic on his own account (sucks to be you, Rumple!) to track Lily and help her out a bit. I mean, although it was not confirmed on-screen, we know that a) people in Storybrooke except Regina couldn't leave town with the Curse still on (and we have no on-screen diverging information about this, with Henry being an exception because he wasn't cursed or born in FTL to begin with), and b) he does have realm-jumping powers that reach as far as the Land Without Magic. Therefore, he likely wasn't cursed and the rule for such cases is to only have one page per character.

BUT – here comes the funny part – the mansion or anything Sorcerer-related wasn't in Storybrooke during the first Curse, as Belle mentioned in 4x01. So what happened? Did the Apprentice get swiped back o Fairy Tale Land with the undoing of the first Curse and then got back, this time, by means of Snow's Curse? In which case, we need The Apprentice (Enchanted Forest) and The Apprentice (Storybrooke) pages as they are now.

That is, unless he wasn't in Storybrooke at the time, like Cruella and Ursula, so he would remain in the LWM and we would need only one page again.

This opens a big question about Ingrid: she was native of Fairy Tale Land, she was in Storybrooke when the first Curse was undone (nothing in the show suggests she got out), therefore she must have been swept back to Fairy Tale Land with the undoing of the Curse (we have on-screen evidence that ALL Fairy Tale Land natives except for Emma would be taken back, and zero about Ingrid somehow being able to escape the undoing of the Curse). She is back to Storybrooke after the second Curse, so by logic, that's how she should have returned too. Does this mean we also need an Ingrid (Arendelle) and Ingrid (Storybrooke) page, with the first containing all the information up until and including the first Curse and the second only what happened after the second Curse?

Yeah, this is a mess. Any thoughts? 