Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20171111015844/@comment-31937823-20171114003903

Suburbanprincess wrote:

I loved that Rogers recruited Tilly to find the missing girl/his daughter. And that the show gave more clues to the Alice/Tilly is his daughter theory. She had a black rook in her hand and gave it to him. That was two chess-related clues we’ve gotten. There is no way those were red herrings.

Unless the 'girlfriend' Tilly discussed with Weaver was WHook's Daughter and taught Tilly to play chess while they were together...

The general theory is that Tilly’s love interest seems to be Robin, who is Zelena and Robin’s daughter so that wouldn’t work if the theory is true, which there is a lot of evidence for.