Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6208134-20130131201108/@comment-98.114.235.92-20130201025344

Pretty positive it's the dagger... The teacup is broken and he has Bae's cloak. There's nothing else he treasures more than his power. He probably hid it somewhere, not expecting the ladies to find it - In fact, maybe Cora couldn't find it, without Regina, and Rumple never expected them to work together.