Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5790697-20131105172911/@comment-24138799-20131108100147

Pan's shadow wrote:

A thought that's been racing my mind, if they are the Darling brothers, I get that John is glasses because he wears them, but why would Michael be Keychain?

We don't know what happened to Michael after they saw Baelfire fly off to Neverland, so it could be anything linking Michael to the name Keychain.