Thread:Totalsolitude/@comment-14150721-20120516030938/@comment-4975807-20120516033459

The issue is that when the Huntsman existed, he was in Fairytale Land. Everything you see that happened in fairytale land in the show is all flashbacks--meaning it's all the past. How could Graham exist if the Huntsman already died in the past? It isn't like two alternate universes showing what's happening at the same time. The Huntsman would be classified as alive because he shown to be alive--at least until the dark curse was cast, and everyone's memories was erased, and they were given new lives in Storybrooke. When he's Graham, he is not the Huntsman. Yes, he does regain his memories, I know, but his role is not the same.