Board Thread:Show-Related Questions and Answers/@comment-31636265-20170331035110/@comment-91424-20170331125149

When a heart is enchanted, it becomes crystal like. Like glass. The heart that Regina throws into the fire at the end of the episode, is a normal human heart. You can see it in this pic (you might have to look at the pic in its full size to see it properly). Which means that the Valet's heart was never enchanted in the first place. I guess that settles the debate?