Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-25926288-20170915180959/@comment-25926288-20170922114152

Chameleon-Guy wrote: I doubt the villain selects a couple of residents who are in Storybrooke for his curse, those who are still in EF2 get cursed IMO. And even if Emma wasn't part of the curse (which she probably is, somehow), she'd surely come to help them in Seattle, she's not the type to stay behind.

Seeing that Snow randomly brought Will from Wonderland to Storybrooke for the second time via the Dark Curse, it's highly possible.

We don't know who casted the curse or anything about it, so anything is possible.

So.

1. Depends on who casted it. Someone could be mad at Henry, the Pirate, the Queen, and the Dark One for foiling their plan. Then they return and drag them all :"somewhere" to get their happy ending.

2. Let's suppose the curse drags Hook, Regina, and Rumple from where they were. It's not like Emma, Snow or anyone will know where the curse took them. Why would they know they are in Seattle? How do we know if they weren't randomly frozen in time?

There are a lot of assumptions on both sides. Let's not discredit one another since neither of us are in the minds of Adam and Eddy.