Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-27060727-20170222030619/@comment-6175354-20170503235238

FrancisPaul wrote: d) As to LDSAC, I think the melody didn't work well, it should have been a bit "darker", "heavier".  The melody sounds like it was inspired by Time Warp from The Rock Horror Picture Show. When is comes to classic musicals, it does not get much darker than that.

To be fair, the only thing that made Hook's song work, is Colin being an actual singer. It also helped that it was set in a tavern, where it is not too uncommon for people to randomly burst into song. Despite the song being inspired by Queen, I did not think it was rock-and-roll enough for Hook.