Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20171111015844/@comment-27001284-20171112162403

Seasrmar wrote: 8Rob wrote: Seasrmar wrote: Ok time for a crazy out of left field theory about Lucy origin.

I remember when people compared Victoria to Regina of Season 1. Both dominating head of the town female figure who has an intense hatred of the main protagonist, want the kid away from their mother, and want the kid to stop believing the fairy tales were real. Lately people compare Ivy/Drizella to Regina. But what if I add another similarity between Victoria and Season 1 Regina.

Season 1 Regina may have been antagonistic toward Henry but deep down she still love him. Likewise what if Victoria despite being antagonistic love Lucy. What if Lucy was her cat, Lucifer from the animation. The saying is cats have nine lives. What if Lucifer was given a year of age for every lives and transform into human? And that's how we got Lucy. Crazy theory I know.lol Having Lucy being an animagus would be one hell of a twist

Can you imagine Lucy turning into Lucifer only for Jacinda to realize she never had a daugther?She is alone. She has no one to fight for. No reason to go on, to keep fighting. Everything was fake

They would have to create a new Emmy category only to award that. Like "Best Twist in a TV Show" or something Well, here's another twist to that. What if Tremaine willingly, abeit begrudgingly gave up Lucifer so the cat can be Cinderella and Henry's daughter and in the process break the curse.

This will parallel Season 1 with twists/differences. Snow willingly giving up Emma so the curse can be broken. This time not quite a daughter be giving up but Tremaine does love her cat giving the cat up. Emma was the main protagonist who gave up Henry who was adopted by the antagonistic Regina. This time, again not quite a son be giving up, but something love by the antagonistic Tremaine so the main protagonist Henry can "adopt." So the similarities in that something given up so the Curse could be broken and adoption play a key role. The twists the relationship between the person giving up and the things they gave up and who gave up and who adopt. Oh My Gosh! I LOVE THAT THEORY!