Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24114452-20160511113326/@comment-25926288-20160718180927

Meganmorse wrote:

Michu1945 wrote:

ChocolatEyes613 wrote:

Revontuli wrote:

Robin never had his Heart inside him when Hades hit him with olympian crystal. In episode firebird we saw Rumple rip his heart out for Peter Pan. Maybe, just maybe Rumple still has Robins unharmed heart in his possession and our heroes will be able to resurrect Robin or something... Gold claimed to Pan, that he returned Robin Hood's heart. It would not be the first time he lied. Your theory could be a possibility, but it seems that Sean Maguire is too upset to want to make a return appearance. Sean won't return but another actor can portray Robin. True, they could always put the heart in another body. But what would that do for his brain? Snow and Charming share a heart and not brains so that's a major flaw. Rumple returned his heart. Robin is dead.

Plus, they've showed that the heart isn't needed for ressurection because Daniel's heart was crushed, yet he could be partially ressurected. It's about the soul.