Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-11464223-20131219231052/@comment-24759429-20140331201711

Killian Jones wrote:

Njcthree wrote: SO here's my question on Lumiere- It was established that "all imagination comes from somewhere" therefore anything thats in movies or stories or anything that we "imagine" has happened already  in another realm and is the "source material" for our "imagination"- therefore Lumiere from the 1991 movie and flciker from The Ice King of Oz is based on the Lumiere we saw last night (according to Once Upon a Time mythology) BUT if the wicked witch JUST cursed him into the candle, how could people have "imagined" him years ago. The only thing i can think of is that the wicked witch cursed him into the candle YEARS AGO and that rumple maybe stole the candle from her or got it as part of a deal before he abdonded her in Oz. Therefore those ivents could have been the source for Flicker in Ice King of Oz and Lumiere in the 1991 Beuaty and The Beast Movie. Why "areadly"? Some people theorize it is the Dark Curse that adds all those stories, somehow altered and shortened, to everyone in the LWM's minds. Like, you didn't really read Snow White before 1983, but when the curse is cast the tale appears in your library and you recall having read it before, same with the movies :D That's an interesting theory- so your saying that only after zelena brought eveyrone to our land- it made everyone think they've known of lumiere for years?