Board Thread:Show-Related Questions and Answers/@comment-2153169-20150328222518/@comment-26255666-20150329072304

Lady Junky wrote: Okay people, I need some opinions about that. I begin to think the Shadow from 308 (when young Rumple is at Neverland) is not the shadow we saw in the others eps of 3a. Some elements give me this impression:

1 - The Shadow from 308 is able to talk, it is voiced by Marilyn Manson. The other shadow never talked, which is a bit strange to me.

2 - The Shadow obeys to me; it is one of his servants (Belle's appearance for exemple, bring some boys to Neverland, etc...). The talking Shadow does not seem under Pan's orders in its episode. Pan makes a deal with this Shadow to be young again. If the Shadow was under his orders, why he would make a deal with it?

3 - the most important point: this scene https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mWmMSfKcQx0 Rumple says Pan lost his shadow, just like him. Rumple removed his shadow; but so Pan removed it too. But the talking shadow was already there before Pan arrives in Neverland :/

So that's it. Maybe it is just me, but i would like some opinions about it :)

I think you make excellent points and I think it's a script hole. Sometimes I think the fans pay more attention to the details of the show then the writers. Like the writers need to keep a timeline in front of them with all of the facts when they write so they stop contradicting themselves in the future.