Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-4877635-20150304180627/@comment-6344309-20150316211713

Hmcooper4 wrote: All good points, and I rather think that Emma is a true Charming. I threw the alternate Idea out as I do many, to see which ones float, and which ones sink. While the writers could possibly make the idea work, it does leave a lot more unanswered questions, so I am going to put this idea in my "sink to the bottom of the ocean" category.

Of course, I still think there is some sort of connection between Emma and Lily (and I still think Lily is quite likely Mal's daughter). However, I think we can now safely rule out Stefan as the Father. It's kinda hard to have children when you are nothing more than charred ashes. He's not charred ashes, Maleficent decided to let him live to see his daughter put under a sleeping curse, with no true loves kiss to ever wake her up.