Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20160411010044/@comment-4637931-20160411215812

Eskaver wrote: Beekee404 wrote: I have mixed feelings about Gaston. He seemed like an a**hole but did he deserve to be condemned to the river of lost souls? I felt bad for Belle when she accidently pushed him in there cause it was her first experience of ruining someone's life aside from choosing to save the rock troll's memory rock instead of saving Anna first. Although, I did like that it showed that she wasn't perfect. She makes mistakes like any human being does. At least that's how I looked at it. Also, was it confirmed that Gaston didn't die when Belle cut the rose stem in "Into The Deep?" It was Rumple when he turned him into the rose? Yeah, I mean it was a dead rose/dying because it's not like he turned into a bush XD

To be fair, I wasn't the only one who thought it was Belle who killed him when she cut the stem.