Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-1916997-20151017160320/@comment-4821842-20151018012904

Eskaver wrote: Anubis16 wrote: Eskaver wrote: ChocolatEyes613 wrote: Neal sadly died, as the price for his father's selfishness. Rumple always thought that he could have it all, and this was proof that he could not.

Also, it is probably not Emma who is going to die. Similar to what happened with Regina and Robin, in The Price. It was implied that reforging Excalibur, would have a severe cost. My theory.... the price Emma has to pay is Hook's life, but Regina will offer herself instead.

To qoute Hook, "[Emma} sacrificed herself for you, Your Majesty, because she believed that an Evil Queen could be good. Don't you think you owe it to her, to repay the favor?" Yes, Neal clearly died because Rumple did something while he was dead in a pit of darkness.......sure.... Neal sacrficed himself to bring back Rumple after he sacrificed himself to defeat Pan and save everyone  Yeah, but you can't say. It's Rumple fault that NEal brought him back because he did a good thing. That would just mean that Rumple shouldn't have done a good thing, which is counter-intuitive to "being good".

No, that's not what I meant, I meant that it was not Rumple's fault that Neal died