Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-1916997-20151017160320/@comment-26967699-20151017220819

Hmcooper4 wrote: Why does everyone think that the wrong sword was used with Hook? if it is because of the actual prop used, I would just blame the prop department (and the person that is responsible for making sure continuity is maintained). From a story perspective (minus the prop), it works with 0 retcon.

now, the other 2 things are clearly retconned, that I won't argue. We think like that because in "The Crocodile", we saw Rumpel putting Hook's sword (which touched Rumpel before and has a golden handle) in his scabbard. And in futher episodes, we saw Hook using Milah's sword (which has a black handle). But I don't think it is a retcon or goof. They knew this but still they chose this way. Maybe they think we won't realize it