Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-4772791-20160306082435/@comment-4427410-20160307024736

I think it's obvious that Regina, the Charmings (Snow, David and Emma), Belle, Robin and Hook have more or less redeemed themselves. As for Rumpelstiltskin and Zelena - I guess we have to wait and see.

I don't need to watch the color of Regina's heart or the hearts of the Charmings or anyone else to see whether or not they have redeemed for their past actions. All I have to do is watch their actions and reactions to their past deeds.

'I don't know what the show's logic on that matter or if there is any cause we saw Rumple's darkness being removed from his heart. In my opinion, doing something good should not erase bad things you have done in the past. You can't undo what you did, you can't control Z your actions in real life. Some of them did horrible things and they can't be erased when they do something good, they need to live with what they did everyday, to atone for it and it should be an everyday battle.'

I agree.