Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-5679696-20171014023101/@comment-25926288-20171016114659

SeanWheeler wrote: I had just noticed something about Rogers that contradicts him being the Wish-Hook. If he's the Hook that only met Emma twice, why is his memories of her so strong? That could be a problem if we merge Rogers with Hook (Wish Realm), and then it's revealed that he's the real Hook all along. And we are still really early in Season 7. Do you think we should wait until the end of the season before we merge pages? My real issue about the separate pages is that in the list of appearances, it says "Absent" when only the counterpart appears. But I think it should say "Cursed" in those appearances. That's speculation and pretty much confirmed to not be the case by the writers. That isn't what this thread is about.