Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-4975807-20150427164031/@comment-4975807-20150502212513

Lady Junky wrote: Killian Jones wrote: Keith and Nottingham is definitely a no imo. Different names are clearly different pages, the way I understood this lol

I agree with you. The only fact we have one name for each counterpart is a reason to keep them separate.

I'm fine with either merging his page or not. I agree that merging two pages into one can be problematic if both counterparts were credited under different names and we have to choose which page name to use. Technically the same rule used for Zelena's page name could be used for Keith/Sheriff (in that the most recent press release name for the character is used), but that could be messy since Keith hasn't appeared since "Lacey" and his most recent credit for "Heart of Gold" is as the Sheriff. So if Keith were to appear in a future episode after the Sheriff's appearance, would that mean his merged page would have to be renamed to Keith?

Yet, Keith was only seen post curse, so we know nothing about his cursed self, which could be considered as Keith and the Sheriff not really having two distinguishing identities. It's known he was cursed, just like Will was, but the whole point of merging Will's pages is because his two counterparts weren't shown to have any different identity characteristics.