Thread:Nightlily/@comment-2153169-20150928180008/@comment-2153169-20150928232307

Nightlily wrote:

Lady Junky wrote: I think that the biggest majority of our users - including our most present ones or even me - do not know all dialogues from the episodes. So this format name would create a lot of problems for the users: Huh? What happened to visual scanning? If people want to find a pic, they take a look at the gallery and when they see the pic, they hover over the pic, and the name appears. I doubt anyone would try to find a pic by reading through the names. Well, let's see it from another point of view :) They're looking at a gallery. They notice a mistake, and they feel that they need to edit the gallery. Well, they go on edit mode with the list of our pics by their names. These names would be the dialogue with the new format, so it would be quite hard for them to edit on this page. If the name was just a description, they could identify immediatly where is the mistake they noticed, and they would fix it. But not, if they do not know the transcripts, well... They would have to open in another page the gallery - to see it in reading mode - just to fix a little mistake?
 * With the current policy, the name is supposed to describe the picture. When an user wants to find a pic in one our list, like a gallery, they will only find a list of dialogues from the episode, which would never help them to find easily the pic they want (unless they know perfectly the transcript of each episode?). When someone is trying to find a pic, especially a new user, they will want a description of the pic, they will have the idea of the scene in their heads, and they will try to find it. So, if the name is a description of the pic, it is gonna be easier. Not with dialogues.

Again, that would not be a good way to edit these pages, not a good way to work, it would be hard for them. Just because they do not know the transcript or the dialogues? That's again the same problem: making the possibility to edit a simple gallery really hard, just because we're forcing them to know dialogues from the episode.