Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-2153169-20170909025746/@comment-2153169-20171030211642

CoolDudeAl wrote: Lady Junky wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: Lady Junky wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: I think I figured it out:

Eloise is the mystery woman that will first show up in the Winter Finale. She will be Alice's love interest, WHook's daughter, and possibly the Guardian Rumple is looking for. She was kidnapped by the Witch, who should be Mother Gothel. Mother Gothel had previously captured Rapunzel, who is actually Lady Tremaine, but with the help of WHook, she escaped. She then had two daughters with Lord Tremaine, and after he died, married Cinderella's father. This all should work, but let me know if anything doesn't seem to fit.

The fact that 707 is named Eloise Gardener does not fit. How could this ep be so soon if she does not appear before? It could just be because they focus on Rogers looking for the missing girl in this episode. Maybe he gets a clue to where she is or something. Doesn't mean she has to show up in this episode. Usually, if they name an episode after a character, it is because the character is the main point of th ep.

And we know that this ep is a Witch ep more than Rogers. True, but maybe that's why they did this, to screw with us. Besides, if the Witch is Eloise's kidnapper in NEF, focusing on her would make sense, even if we don't physically get to see Eloise. Then, the ep would be about Rogers/Witch. And, as far as we know, they did not film together? Plus, if it was about the Witch and Hook, I don't see where Rapunzel would fit. And still zero reason to name the ep "Eloise Gardener".

Or why Eloise filmed with Kelly in 711. We know Kelly is Zelena's cursed persona, and Rebecca did film with Emma Booth for 711.