Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-2153169-20151220172901/@comment-91424-20151221222742

I think not being able to suggest a new pic/quote as long as a suggestion for another pic/quote is already ongoing on the page, is a bad idea. It would mean that those who want to suggest another, possibly better, pic/quote, will have to check on the discussion all the time to see if it's over. And if someone beats them to it, they will have to wait even longer. It is first come, first served. It will be very frustrating for everyone. It also means that the process of choosing the best picture/quote will be even longer, because people can only vote for one pic/quote at a time.

However, I agree that the process should be better organized and less chaotic. Killian's suggestion is good. I, too, think it's a good idea to let counter-suggestions be allowed within the same comment thread, but not a new suggestion altogether in a new comment.