Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20180317005816/@comment-34463805-20180317085706

The way Gothel talked about WHook's detour seemed really significant, like it was the reason she banished him. She even says that he's not good enough. I have a theory that Gothel actually believes Alice is the guardian, and didn't want any possible corrupting influences around her. So when WHook gets tempted by darkness, he is no longer allowed to visit his daughter (since clearly Gothel knew he was there the whole time).

I may be wrong, but I don't actually recall Gothel saying that she thought Ana was the guardian. Maybe she just needed Ana for her magic, as she's the only one who has it? Anyway, just my speculation.

Didn't love the episode, but always enjoy some Tilly & Ivy. I want some more Tilly and Weaver scenes.