Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-2153169-20170909025746/@comment-27060727-20171030200411

Lady Junky wrote: DatNuttyKid wrote: But if the Witch is Hook's daughter, then what were they doing with Tilly? It seems like a really dumb red herring.

Idk. I do like that this is a mystery we can't quite figure out. We've been pretty good to solve these types of things in the last few seasons. Clearly, the scene with Tilly is supposed to be a red herring. Even before this discussion, as soon as I saw this scene, I was certain it was a red herring. This was a waaaaaaaaaaay too big to not be a red herring ^^ I'm definitely also on the "Alice is not the daughter" train. That would end up being the big twist at this point. xD