Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-25762747-20160102074246/@comment-5679696-20161122025341

CoolDudeAl wrote: Ingrid would have gotten sucked back by the curse undone in 3A though, right? Everyone (including people who weren't in the first curse like Hook, Tink, and Neal) went back when it was undone. I don't see why Ingrid would be any different. That sounds reasonable. However, the show says she was not brought over by any curse, and she has a magic scroll which is known to let people cross the town line when nobody else can. Logic can go either way, so we should stick to what they say on the show. If you (or anyone) wants to personally assume that Ingrid was taken to the Fairy Tale Land when the curse was undone and then brought back to Storybrooke when Snow cast the curse again, that is your right, but it would be misleading to let people think we know for a fact that she was cursed, ESPECIALLY when it was very clearly stated that she did not go to SB by any curse.