Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-26830263-20170710210232/@comment-25926288-20171008012541

ChocolatEyes613 wrote: Eskaver wrote: What? You didn't accept that Emma was secretly Hook's spleen? XD Huh?

While I think Rogers is the real Hook, you are probably correct that the second one is the "''message in a bottle". ''The question is, why did Emma even need to leave a message? Oh, I was referring to any early crackpot theory in another thread (that was about Hook, but not really since it turned into talks about Emma).

Depends on timeframe of the flashback. I can't imagine that Hook and co stayed in EF2 for 10+ years. Part of the flashback, I assume Emma visits and then leaves before Hook and Regina. It would be weird for her to send the message unless it's right before the curse clouds roll in EF2.