Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-187.172.138.83-20130506222109/@comment-8954026-20130508201611

187.172.138.83 wrote: OldBid wrote: 156.99.55.125 wrote: I hope the writers don't go for a love triangle with hook it wouldnt work with the show and I think the writers know not to mention emma'a character in general she isnt the type to quickly move on to another guy after finding out the guy she's loved for 11 years still loves her. emma has a block on her heart and as the writers stated emma saying I love you is a powerful thing and it's true she doesnt say it much to anyone she hasnt even stated it to her own parents just neal and henry. Fans of hook want her with him but really look at her character before you jump to storylines like that. Hook would be nothing more than a stand in. Like tamara was with neal which was obvious. I love swanfire and I was both happy and sad at sundays episode I don't think neal's dead I hope not I suppose that the only was they could make the triangle is if Emma thinks Neal IS dead (is this what you were thinking?)  She's not mentioned (on camera) that he was alive, albeit shot, when he went into the portal- she's not mentioned the portal at all!!! All she's said is he's gone, he's dead! So I suppose this COULD lead to her letting him go an starting anew on someone else! . . . oh dear!! I don't really think this would happen. I'd love it and all, they tend to make things more intense and interesting, the love triangles. But, wouldn't they all give Neal a proper burial if he were dead? They'd go for the body and bury it on the cementery. Now, Emma would need to give them an explanation as to why his body is not there. So, when the Charmings and Henry hear that he has landed on another world, perhaps they would nonstop try to make their way to him, save him. They're like the most hope-y characters in OUaT.

I guess I'm thinking of that still that went round a couple of weeks ago, with Emma in the hat! I think they do have a funeral for him. I suppose it depends if she said he was alive when he went through - if she states that he was dead then they prob won't think twice and just accept that he's dead - if she says that he was alive but wounded then yeah they'd definitely still have hope! . . . I love the term hope-y!! It defines their souls!! :D

Just thought - this'll have been the second time she's told Henry his dad was dead when he's not (hopefully)!! Oops!! ha ha