Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24339224-20141128015634/@comment-413929-20141128045224

For me I keep seeing that Ingrid wanted two magical sisters like her, she had Elsa, but Elsa at the time did not embrace her powers, and let herself get trapped in the urn, causing Ingrid to panic and become the monster everryone feared at the time.

When Elsa embraced her powers for what they were, she then in turn helped Emma embrace her powers as well, then the ribbons show up and drain them both of their magic. Why ? Ingrid did not want two magical sisters, she wanted their MAGIC to begin with.

My confusion now abounds with Lily, and where she is included in all this mess. In Shattered Sight we see young Emma again, and possibly Lily according to the A&E; What if Elsa or Emma, or both, were not even meant to be Ingrids sisters ?

What if Emma and Lily were meant to be Ingrids sisters ? or just Lily ? Or maybe Lily is Helga returned ?

I think I need sleep