Board Thread:Rant and Rave/@comment-24593235-20171118053131/@comment-24304025-20171121165438

CoolDudeAl wrote: FrancisPaul wrote: Alva Crane wrote:

KnocknickKnock wrote:

8Rob wrote: KnocknickKnock wrote: Alva Crane wrote:

KnocknickKnock wrote:

Alva Crane wrote: I have some questions... In the Wish Realm the curse was never cast... Ok. That's why everybody was 28 years older. But now we see that the realm has some kind of backstory... So, it existed before 6x10? Then, shouldn't they be in the same age that the original characters? Because the curse stopped the time in all the realms except the TLWM and Liam 2's boddy. But I'm going too far now. The New Enchanted Forest (Usurper Forest is how we call it here) exists since...? Because if Wook (Wish Hook) was born by the time of 6x10, how could he had a story with the Witch and Alice like 30 years ago? Moreover, if they lived there at the tower, Wook should still young and Alice should be like Roland, because, again, the curse stopped time in all the realms... Every realm we are currently seeing is part of the Wishverse. In the Wishverse the curse was never cast. Time never Stopped. Also the curse never froze timme in the Enchanted forest either Cora Did with her barrier Spell. Time was frozen in the Enchanted Forest. Cora says it in 2x09. My point is that in a flashback "many years ago" we see Wish Hook travelling todo another realm... But he was born by 6x10 so he never could met the Witch. What are you talking about?

If the magical forest we see is the one that exist in the Wishverse, time would have never been frozen and Hook could have easily meet Gothel. Look at it like this:

OriginalUniverse: An entire Universe with different realms(Oz,Enchanted Forest, Wonderland, etc)

OriginalRealms: Different dimensions within the Original Universe.

Wishverse: A parallel Universe to the Original in which Regina never cast the curse.

Wishrealms: Parallel realms to the original realms.

Meaning there could easily be two Magical forest. One in which Gothel is never freed and another in which she is(The current one). Magic beans and portals can travel not only between realms but also Universes. So with Regina and Emma they didn't just hop realms but also Universes.

What is confusing people is that the show jumps between the Wishverse and the Original verse rather than just staying in one.

To truly understand the Wishverse people first need to brush up on Alternate Universe/Realities. Again, it's not like the Wish Realm always existed. It was created in 6x10

That means its existence begun in 6x10, when SerumQueen made her wish. It has been confirmed in the show and on interviews.

http://www.onceuponafans.com/interviews/be-careful-what-you-wish-for-adam-horowitz-and-eddy-kitsis-tease-whats-next-for-once-upon-a-times-sixth-season

Adam Horowitz: " Yes, it is a real place. When the Evil Queen made the wish that Emma's wish be realized, this realm was created and it now exists"

So, before 6x10, there was not such a thing as the "WishRealm", let alone WHook. Then the question is, how come WHook traveled to the NEF before even existing You still don't understand my precious. I am not saying it wasn't created by a wish ergo me using the term Wishverse. However just because it was created by a wish doesn't mean it doesn't have its own history. Brush on Alternate Universe/Realities to get a better understanding. But the Usurper Forest/ New Enchanted Forest we saw is the only one, there's not a Wish New Enchanted Forest. My point is how WHook travelled to the New EF even before existing, because with backstory or not, he and all the Wish Realm were born by the time of 6x10. Perhaps it is not before 610. Perhaps he traveled to NEF after 610 and, since time moves very fast in NEF, it allowed Alice to grow Problem is WHook is already old in 610/611 and he is not in the FB. Perhaps he went to NEF in the meantime then back to the WR.

In 610 EQ wishes, the realm is created. In a matter of seconds/hours in LWM, Hook goes to NEF, Alice is born and grows, Hook goes old and goes back to the WR in time to meet Emma.