Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24674051-20141121060938/@comment-24674051-20141217151328

Well, going with the old mantra that "Evil is not born, it is made", I am going to say that I suspect she will fall to the villian side. (assuming, of course, that she is in fact Regina and Robin's daughter.)

1. She was given up as an infant, and doesn't know her bio parents.

2. Unlike Emma, she was adopted, but evidently she does not care for her adoptive family. Of course we don't know the full story there, but running away from an adoptive family is not the same as running away from foster parent's, since there should hopefully be some sense of stability in the adoptive family.

3. She has no way of finding her parents, because she is in the wrong timeline. So she is probably always feeling alone.

And yes, by our timeline, she is the same age as Emma.

She would probably be a redeemable villian, though. 1. Emma could regain her trust as a friend. 2. Assuming that they can determine her story, the Robin and Regina in THIS timeline could maybe help give her some hope.