Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-7246129-20130318091100

I'm calling it now!!... Here's my theory on Neal/Neverland/Hook/Emma and how this stuff is going to play out in the future.... I've been thinking about this since last week's episode...and maybe a little before. But, in light of tonight's episode, I'm excited to see if it comes true. There's been a lot of talk (and questions) about who Bae/Neal is, did he go to Neverland, what was he like there and his relationship to Hook. From what I've read on this board and others, a lot of people are expecting/assuming that there will be major tension between Hook and Bae (probably because of the "Bae is Peter Pan" theory). However, I don't think that will be the case. I think (get ready for it), thatBae/Neal and Hook are not enemies at all, but possibly allies, friends or that Hook may have even been a mentor/big brother (lost boy turned pirate?) or even "father figure" to Bae (or at least he was, once upon a time). Here's why:

1.) We've all pretty much figured out Bae/Neal went to Neverland (because he stated he didn't stop here first and he didn't age). And we know for sure Hook was there

. 2.) In the "Outsider", when  Belle was discussing Rumpelstiltskin's  son with Hook, he said "What makes you think his son wants to be found? I'm doing that boy a favor."  Based on the way, Neal acted when the fam came to NY (running away) and his resentment to Rumple, we all could see clearly he did not want to be found.

3.)  In "Tallahassee", Hook speaks about the Lost Boys with compassion and empathy...not disdain. I also don't think it was coincidence that we got this lil bit of info on the same episode we got Emma's backstory, as well as Neal's. It was one of the most talked about- and I think- best written shows of the season. The fact that Hook and Emma's convo, as well as interaction centered on themes of love, loss and trust, makes me think there is sooooo much more to this story and everything in that episode is connected.

4.) Neal knew how to sail his ship. Now granted, he could've learned from just being in Neverland, but it just leaves much to speculation that he seemed more than confident to sail Hook's ship...the jokes from Emma about him now being a pirate may also be a hint. He also didn't look that surprised to see him in New York. (Also, how did someone tell Hook Gold went to Manhattan? I don't remember but please remind me if that happened). I just think Neal may have some secrets! lol (like does he realllyyy know who is fiancee is?? hmmm).

I'm not saying Bae is not Peter Pan...he very well may be. I just think whatever the backstory is with him and Hook, it will have a twist...i.e. if he is Pan, he and Hook may not be complete enemies. He did seem a bit angry when he saw him in New York, and not just because he stabbed his dad. :/. But,  I just think the possibilities for a complex storyline are endless!!! If he and Hook were once close, in essence, Hook would've taken both Rumpel's wife and son; even more to tick off Rumpel! Bae could've been mad if he found out his mom ran away with Hook...but then became even more mad at his father if Hook told him he killed her--OR maybe he still doesn't know, and will become even more pissed at both for the betrayal (rumpel for doing it and hook for keeping the secret). Also, it just makes the possible Hook/Emma/Neal triangle even more juicy! lol.

I think one thing I've learned from this show is that the creators love to put a twist on everything. Another thing, is that nothing in the show is a coincidence...almost anything could be foreshadowing, as was tonight's ep with Greg/Owen (Star Wars ring tone because he loved Star Wars as a child?...subtle, but nice :)

And to link all this to tonight (ep. 17): I think Henry is going to Neverland. He's clearly tired of all the magic and confusion! (Poor child..smh) I think he will run away and accidentally (or purposefully, perhaps) end up in Neverland...or he'll be tricked into going there (Mr. Gold, maybe?) He'll fit in because he is a boy, and if he disowns his family (he's become increasingly disappointed by their actions), he will be a "lost boy". That will give a reason for the characters to head there. And--just a guess-- Emma, Neal and Hook will be the one's to go.

What do ya think?  