Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-28081000-20180331170703/@comment-28081000-20180515060526

CadoDoan wrote: StargateFanBB wrote: CadoDoan wrote: The bottle was Hook’s, not Regina’s. Why would it summon WR Regina anyway?

There may not be a Wish Isaac. Wish Realm has a lot more differences than EF than we think. It cannot distinguish because they are the same person. They share the same genetics. They are exactly the same. The only difference is their history.

Here’s the proof: Merlin warned Emma about multiplying the Darkness, which means it has terrible consequence and very hard to do it. But you think a wish can copy of that? Darkness is NOT an item, or a location, or a character. It’s a dark magical entity which is very hard to destroy. That’s why it can’t create another Darkness and WRumple’s Darkness is connected to our Rumple’s Darkness. The bottle could summon other versions of whoever was summoned by the user, so it really summoned Wish Regina aswell. There's a Wish Cruella there(who wasn't in WEF when the curse failed to be cast) so there should Isaac. the history of the Wish Realm is identical until the curse was cast. There should be a Wish Isaac should still be in the Wish book. If there's a Wish Cruella, that means there had to be a Wish LWM for her to be in so she could show up in the WR later. Same with Wish Peter Pan, there should be a Wish Neverland.

If the people and history in it  are identical up to the point of the Dark curse casting, then the objects and events associated with them had to have happened to in the Wish Realm's past, meaning Wish Merlin should have drunk from a Wish Holy Grail as should Wish Nimue, corrupted herself and create Wish Darkness. The two Darknesses should not be connected in any way. And that's not even going into the alternate versions of all the worlds out there. How many other alternate worlds have an alternate Dark One now? Are they gonna be affected too when Weaver destroys his Darkness now? It's just a cop-out by the writers to wrap up the plot, nothing more. Nope. The bottle was just the message. Regina didn't arrive because of the "bottle magic". Bottle travelled from NEF to SB, to Hook's whereabouts. Hook opened it and heard what Henry said. He then took Regina with him and travelled to NEF. It's just about who the bottle went. In this case, it's Hook and Wish Hook, due to them being the identical and same person.

And again, that's your mistake. There is no Wish Merlin, or Wish Nimue, or Wish Holy Grail, especially Wish Neverland. It's not a Wish Universe. It's a world consisting the EF. The events of the Wish Realm also didn't start from the beginning. It just created a population who's been to EF.

And no, there are looooots of differences. Robin, Cruella, Ariel and the Sheriff are still young. Stealthy is still alive. Marian is dead. Rumple is imprisoned in Regina's castle instead of his original cell. Baelfire didn't go off with the Darlings etc. Their history are not the same.

Also it's not a paralel universe, like we saw on Fringe. It was created by a wish. There are no other alternate Wish Realms. So the Darkness has just two hosts now: Rumple and WRumple. They are identical until the curse failed. That's were they diverge. Also the history and events would have to have happened in the WR instead of just having a population with memories of those events and history otherwise it would no sense and they'd cop on very quickly something about thier lives and world was wrong if after the curse they went to get objects or study histories or find things related to those past events only find they don't exist. That would cause problems for the inhabitants very quickly. Also those characters having different histories would only be different after the period where the curse would have been cast, not before.

And I meant alternate versions of the worlds besides the wish realm. We have alternate verisons of EF and Wonderland. And Henry says for every version of each story in the Authors' books, there are worlds corrosponding to them. Endless possibilities. So at least one those would have their own DO in it.

But I suppose at this point it don't matter since the show's ending anyway.