Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27255668-20151207215419/@comment-27255668-20151208171823

ΚΟΜΙΞ wrote: Guys I think Rumple split Excalibur and the Dagger before giving it to Emma. Then Excalibur looked as if it was whole because of the magic he used on it. But Rumple had the REAL Dagger all this time. This explain this. This also means that Emma is still a DO since she can hear the Dagger and Rumple ONLY showed one side of the Dagger. I bet in the other side it's Emma's name on it. Actually I though Rumple enchanted the dagger so the darkness will be transfered into him, not the one using the dagger to kill the dark one.

Also I'm asking myself 2 new questions now:

1. You can see, the Darkness all went into Excalibur. But as far as they told us before that episode, the darkness has to be inside a person and then the person has to be killed with it.

2. Actually, the thing said above wouldnt even make sense. Because, when a person has darkness, the other person kills that person with the dagger/Excalibur, that person would get the darkness.

So if Emma would've killed Zelena with the darkness inside Zelena... wouldnt the darkness just be transfered back into her? Like it happened to Gold after "he" killed Hook? (Emma did, but the enchantment made it look like he did for the dagger)

Also why would Excalibur turn into dust anyways? Was it just another trick of gold, to make them believe it worked?

If so, it would make sense. But then again, why was the darkness in Excalibur, not in Hook? Also, why did Emma transform into normal Emma after Hook was killed, not after he pulled the darkness out of her?