Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6208134-20130130173409/@comment-4975807-20130202052748

HarryPotterRules1 wrote: Well, Cora is "The Miller's Daughter" and Ruth says that The Miller's daughter is available for marriage in The Shepherd.

This means that, at the time of those events, Cora is unmarried and available, thus she and Charming MUST be around the same age. This means that Charming must be older than show - perhaps even 20+ years. And that proves what? Do you honestly think Cora is the only miller's daughter in the whole enchanted forest world ? It could very well be another miller's daughter Ruth was speaking of. There is no "must be around the same age" just because Ruth happened to mention a miller's daughter. She did not say the miller's daughter, Cora. That proves nothing in your theory. You are throwing Cora and Charming together based on your assumption *that* miller's daughter Ruth was referring to must be Cora. There is absolutely no factual evidence to support that miller's daughter was referencing to Cora.