Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27023843-20170719114129/@comment-6175354-20170806181842

Daviddv0601 wrote: Captain Hook is not supposed to be this Jack Sparrow love machine who wears only black and no red coat at all. He is supposed to wear the hook on his right hand, and have long hair. He is supposed to be a ruthless monster, something that even sirens would fear. OUaT's version is a modern interpretation, but still incredibly accurate to the source material.

The book never states what color Hook's coat is, just that he is impeccably dressed. The only thing Hook has in common with Jack Sparrow is the guyliner. Guess what.... Jason Isaac's Hook also wore guyliner, as did Dustin Hoffman's version. Did it ever occur to you, that Colin O'Donoghue is right-handed? It is difficult enough for him to do everything one-handed on the show. How much more so, if he had to use his recessive hand.