Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-1916997-20170901012801/@comment-25926288-20171117233233

8Rob wrote: Eloise Gardener is WHooks daugther, right? And it seems - from filming reports - that's the Witch

So, if Rapunzel is the mother, then that means her daughter would be the Witch Nothing says with any certainty that Hook's daughter is the Witch. I think you're conflating two separate theories. Rapunzel = Mom, Gothel = Daughter. But those are two separate ideas that you've put together. I don't think anyone who thinks either believes both will occur.

On a sidetalk with Jenna, it could be that the Witch (glamoured as Rapunzel) begets a daughter with Hook.