Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20180324005809/@comment-24264679-20180325003721

Eskaver wrote:

'''Timeline: Alice and Robin are both almost 18 when Lucy was born, plus 8 years. Robin and Alice almost 26, but as Robin says "I'm 25".'''

So, Robin and Alice are fine.

I don't know about Robin but I know for sure Alice couldn't have been no 18 when Lucy was born. She was concieved and born around the exact same time Emma was born. They stopped Regina(Wishverse) from casting the curse which we know took place around he same time Emma was born. So they either stopped WishRegina they day of or before Emma was born. In the Wishverse Emma was the same age as she was in Storybrooke which was 28+ years old. Within the same week Nook travels to gothel tower has sex and Alice is born. At this point WishRegina hasn't even changed clothes yet. So the youngest Alice could have been at this time was around 27-28 years old.

The episode was okay. Nothing bad to talk about. Besides the timeline issue I just seriously don't have much issue.