Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-10663213-20180306175318/@comment-32423680-20180801121336

I don't remember seeing that Nook has regret of his mistakes, he cared for Alice, yes, and did good things like (uncknowlingly for him) try to save "Rapunzel", help to defeat the Coven and WRumple (the cases like Nick's are exception, he was cursed).

In the other hand, Hook had regret after falling in love with Emma and tried to fix them.

As Lola said above, it's refreshing to see Killian without Emma, and if CaptainSwan wouldn't have happened, Hook would have the same attitude as Nook.

Hook and Nook are the same person until the Curse, but the differents paths they chose made them regret or not or whatever.