Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24674051-20150420171129/@comment-28017757-20160320194741

Eskaver wrote: Well, she could have had it,  or found Robin's pendant that he stole from her.

Taking Robin's stolen Clover works for me. Just thinking of the timeline, and that could fit. Robin's trip to Oz must have been at least 5 years before the curse, as Rolan's 4 when the curse was cast. The whole Snow & Charming meeting to Regina casting the curse story took, say, 2/3 years. Seem likely that Robin had the Oz Clover when Snow & Charming first meet.