Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20171014005708/@comment-28162607-20171020102428

DatNuttyKid wrote: 8Rob wrote: DatNuttyKid wrote: ChocolatEyes613 wrote: 8Rob wrote:

The W!Evil Queen created in that land with wish while the SerumQueen was in SB. There was no Evil Queen in the Wish Realm, only the pre-programed memories of her. The information about Wish!Hook's daughter heavily implies that the Wish Realm always existed and the Serum Queen's wish merely provided access to it rather than creating it. There are some other continuity issues resulting from this -- specifically, Robin -- but it's what we have to go by right now. It was created by the wish. That was made clear It was made clear originally, but that has been brought into unclarity now. You can't just shrug off facts because they disagree with past indications.

The Wish Realm was only said to be created by the wish by Adam and Eddy -- who we know change their mind constantly -- and in-continuity by characters who don't necessarily understand it (Regina, Emma, Charming, etc.) Wish!Hook, who has lived there his entire life, said it always existed, and the timeline now lines up with that. Also, Eddy said it was not real and Adam said it was (or the other way around lol). Even the writers cannot agree on whether or not it was real