Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-10663213-20180306175318/@comment-28162607-20180306195622

Matheus1234zx wrote: Aine1989 wrote: Completely disagree. Hook and Nook are the exact same guy just in different situations.

I made a post about it on my Tumblr here:

http://newyearsswifts.tumblr.com/post/169575118399/original-hookwish-hook-similiarities

They have the same personalities and traits, said traits just manifested differently because they were in different situations.

I would like to point out that when Hook threatened Rumple, Rumple was working with the Black Fairy to destroy them all. Heroes threaten the villains, it's kinda the MO.

Snow threatened Regina. Charming threatened Arthur. Emma threatened Pan. Are they all evil sociopaths? One thing s threaten. The other is say: "Now I'm finally going to skin the croc!" Well if someone had murdered my girlfriend, maimed me, repeatedly tried to kill my loved ones, serverely abused my friend and tortured me.... I would hold a grudge. Especially if they had aided someone in harming my fiancee after deceiving us.

Rumple is/was the villain in that situation and Killian was the hero. Therefore Killian owed him no compassion or kindness. Frankly, threanting to skin him is letting him off lightly.