Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-1916997-20171009223757/@comment-30161539-20180312193715

Cinderella (104) VS Cinderella (701) - Ashley just embodied the storyline better

Lady Tremaine (603) VS Lady Tremaine (701) -   the original was good, but Victory sold the backstory of WHY she resented Ella

Clorinda or Tisbe (603) VS Drizella (701)-  This was a no brainer- Ivy is fierce

Clorinda or Tisbe (603) VS Red Queen (Wonderland) VS Anastasia (703)- I think all three of these have been misses so far, maybe Anastasia will pull something out but she's just so 'mousy'

Alice (Wonderland) VS Alice (701)-  I like her character- like she had spent a little TOO much time in Wonderland (We're all mad here...)

Fairy Godmother (104) VS Fairy Godmother (701)- both were gone before any character developed but the first was more true to story I thought

Prince Thomas (104) VS Prince and Henry Mills (701) - I liked Thomas, however I think it only makes sense that Henry be with a Cinderella as he a Prince Charming (being that Emma,who is in essence Emma Charming [gave herself the surname Swan], since she never married Neal )

Rapunzel (314) VS Lady Tremaine/Rapunzel (701)- Victoria as Tremaine is great, as Rapunzel good, but the original was better... too many alternate identities for one person was overwhelming at best.

Charming as Rapunzel's Prince (314) VS Wish Hook as "Rapunzel's" Prince (707) - this one I am not referring to Belfrey or Gothel as Rapunzel, but Alice- after all Alice is now the princess trapped in the tower and most girls' first Prince Charming is their daddies.

Manifestation of Rapunzel's fear (314) VS Witch/Mother Gothel (703)- still not sure where she's going or why but Gothel is GOOD

Jack (213) VS Jack (708)- although I am anticipating my mind being changed on this in coming episodes, if rumours are true

Blind Witch (109) VS Hilda (712) - I LOVED the first blind witch- her singsong voice was creepy and yet to little ears I am sure would be as alluring as gingerbread- Hilda is more like the creepy cat lady who runs the bakery but whose house NO ONE trick-or-treats at.