Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-1916997-20151012011036/@comment-25926288-20151015012010

CoolDudeAl wrote: Eskaver wrote: Everyone! Listen up!

http://captainswan4e.tumblr.com/post/131099326649/ouat-plot-holes-add-one-more-to-the-list

The cutlass Hook had was Milah's and that was used to awaken Rumple, when in actuality, Rumple took Hook's sword that touched him when he was a man.

Add this to this season being the biggest retcon-discontinuity filled season. Good catch by the poster.

So, technically they still got it wrong. I was wondering about this. I wasn't sure which of Killian's swords touched Rumple, but I knew their were multiple in play. Whoops on the prop guys part. I knew something was off. I knew that it didn't happen the way they said because back then Rumple had a stealing swords fetish. A devoted fan discovering this is hilarious. I don't blame the prop guys, but the writing team. The prop team could switch swords, but it'll still be wrong because the sword that touched Rumple is in Rumple's possesion of somewhere hundreds of years ago.

Doesn't look good when:

Hook has mysterious potion Regina gave him, when we see that she only enchanted his hook.

Zelena claims that her heart was protected eons ago (but reasonable to explain away).

Belle not finding anything that touched Rumple (which is the most contrived spell of all time)

Hook having a cutlass that he doesn't actually have and then that said cutlass is used to heal him.