Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-4975807-20140427201855/@comment-1916997-20140429174046

Lady Junky wrote: FrancisPaul wrote: 1= CoolDude and I were NOT suggesting to put Latest Episode Apperance and other latest appearance. We were suggesting that the latest appearance meant only episodes.

2=I realize that, but I think it is arbirtrary to say this goes and that does not go. Let's say "SotQ counts, Reawakened does not". Then what is the rule?

3=I accepted that. I was not imposing my opinion, just expressing it. I don't find it logical otherwise, but of course I will accept what most people decide (I have even undid alone all of my edits and reverted to how you guys thought it should be. I'm not complaining about that). But it does not mean you can be rude because I say I disagree.

1 =

CoolDudeAl wrote: I think the books, while canon, are still suplimentry, and should not be included. Can't we just change latest appearance to latest episode appearance, and that solves the whole problem (the episodes are clearly different from books, recap specials, or any other Once medium that could come out).

He put "Lastest Episode Appearance", I'm not crazy.

2 = That's not really arbitrary, because I don't look what kind of media is it, but the content of the media. That's clearly not the same thing between SoQ and Reaweneked. But, that's not a problem.

3 = Please, don't say I'm rude. I was not, I just told the truth. And, please: "I was not imposing my opinion" -> you tried. When you added the specials everywhere, yeah you tried in the name of "For anyone who finds it nice, it will be there." . When I asked you to stop, and wait the opinion of an admin... Well... You clearly send me away. If Applegirl did not come, well this thread won't ever be created. So, yeah I think if we have this discussion it is because you did that without talk with the other. So, please, don't say I'm rude I was not. Wow. Didn't mean to start World War 3, lol. I did say that, but we don't actually need to change the text (although not doing something on a wiki because you think it will look ugly is not really the best argument, but anyways), it can just be stated in our rules that latest appearance is only for the episodes of the show, or spin off show, basically canon tv entrys only. Besides SoQ is old now, so who's latest appearance would it actually be? Did we even make any pages for the original characters in it? Because basically that's what were arguing over, seeing as it seems most everyone agrees that recap specials, and Reawaked (a retelling of Season 1), should not be included.