Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-6175354-20140212194028/@comment-4589858-20140325022325

Saintfighteraqua wrote: According to the books the Silver Shoes were lost when Dorothy left Oz since they couldn't exist outside of a magic land. (It's later stated when she obtains the Nome King's belt that it too would be lost if she took it out of Oz). So the shoes could be in anyone's hands if they go with that. You have to remember that "The World Without Magic" has magic. More specifically Storybrook does. All magical items from other realms work in Storybrook.

I have no clue if they will show up in Storybrook or not. The power of the shoes return the wearing home. So technically the shoes' home is Oz, it never leaves the realm.