Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-27060727-20170803053127/@comment-25375217-20171027020438

JennaMae wrote: Sneak peek #2 http://www.tvguide.com/news/once-upon-a-time-beauty-exlusive-sneak-peek/ Her one grey streak lol! And here we go, they're addressing Rumple's immortality. Okay... So what goes wrong? They clearly cut that scene off but unlike the sneak peek where Emma revealed she was pregnant, there's no obvious reason. Something has to go wrong or otherwise happen in this scene that they can't show us.

Someone takes the dagger? Unless it's Alice, that wouldn't make sense with what we know about the episode. Rumple changes his mind? But what would the excuse for that be? Or does the wish actually work? I find it hard to believe they'd finally ditch the Dark One this year after almost getting rid of him three times in as many years.

Okay, my two theories: 1) Gideon gets injured and Rumple uses his magic to save him, leading him to doubt whether or not he should give it up. 2) Rumple sees some sort of vision of the future where his powers come in handy (likely related to the curse and Henry), leading him to doubt whether or not he should give it up.