Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27255668-20160105023421/@comment-25926288-20160105025031

Eselyx wrote: Eskaver wrote: Wishes can kill. Noone said that they couldn't. Just couldn't bring them back to life.

Noone says a genie is invulnerable. It is presumed that if Will's heart was crushed, he would die and the killer would become the genie or it's simply void.

So, none of them are plot holes. 4 Rules of Magic - Cyrus told them Alice, as well as Sidney told them Leopold:

1. No bringing a dead person back to life.

2. No killing.

3. Can't make a person fall in love with you.

4. No changing of the past also a genie is apparently invulnerable, or how did Cyrus survive all those things, like jumping into the sea?  No it's not. It's no raising the dead, no making someone fall in love, no changing the past and no wishing for more wishes. That's it.

Cyrus survived because Wonderland is a land without logic and fell into water. Some thought he was dead, but he jumped into water. If Cyrus told Alice the wish could kill, him, then it can. Nothing else to it.