Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24114452-20160511113326/@comment-25926288-20160828213114

Pax Peace wrote: Eskaver wrote: Nope, Rumple returned Robin's heart as he said he did. Even so, Robin's soul was obliterated. The heart just cntains the life force and control of the body, but now his bpdy is decaying, his soul destroyed, and more.

He's dead. You're forgetting something. Dr. Frankenstein can bring people back to life. What does he use? Hearts. You might say there's no proof because he never did it to David in the Enchanted Forest. In Storybrooke however, a new heart was placed in David that turned him crazy.

I think it is very possible Robin could come back to life. If Robin's body decays to dust, there's nothing to shove a heart into. XD

There's a difference between Daniel and Robin. Daniel's soul went to the Underworld and wass able to be brought back when Victor did his stuff with another enchanted heart. Daniel's body was preserved with magic. Robin's body isn't. Robin's soul isn't in the Underworld but destroyed.

Nevertheless, Regina had to kill Daniel due to that unnatural act. Even if Robin's soul wasn't obliterated and his body wasn't decaying, Regina wouldn't want Robin to be brought back in that way.