Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-6175354-20140420035659/@comment-4993393-20140424001813

Hmcooper4 wrote:Actually, in thinking about it, I'm thinking that it might actually be Hook after all. And the heart of the thing he loved most would not be Emma, but the Jolly Roger. There's nothing in the Dark Curse that said it had to be a person, or even a living thing. Just the Heart of the thing that you love Most. And I think we can tell that (even though it bothered him) his love for the Jolly Roger eclipsed even his love of Emma (at least at the time).

I'm going to have to disagree. He got his ship back and it was a let-down. He realized he needed Emma. Granted that's good motivation, but he still wouldn't have the ability. It can't be Rumble because Neal/Bealfire is what he loves the most.