Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-10663213-20180306175318/@comment-35348769-20180419101925

Matheus1234zx wrote: In my opinion, what killed the show after season 4 was CS (IN MY OWN OPINION) and it's not because Emma didn't stayed with someone else. It's because it was badly done. It's not Colin's fault. He is a wonderful actor and I used to love Hook until season 3.... But after that.... he and his actions, his "redemption arc" that, in my opinion didn't happen as he, on the day of his marriage, still wanted revenge against Gold... For me, they aren't the same because, Nook is truly a hero, who regrets of his past. Who deserves a happy ending (hopefully with Tiana). What made he change from the sick sexist person that he was once, was his daughter Alice.... So, for me, they are completely opposite characters WOOOOOW.... really?

1) He's redemption arc it's much better than just putting a baby in his arms and suddenly, omg! I'm now a hero

2) Of course he wanted revenga against Gold, did you miss the part when he was working with the Black Fairy who was trying to kill Emma all the time and also wanted to get rid of all of them? 

3) When has show Nook regret of his past? I remember very well how he wanted to kill Original Hook on 7x02 to 'take his place' and this means, killing Emma's husband, the step-father of her son and father of her daughter. He spent years looking for Emma to make his plan works, if he hurted her in the process he didn't care, he just wanted to get what she needed from her. COME ON!

4) You really need to rewatch the show if you think Original Hook doesn't regrets of his past

5) Now, seriously with a happy ending with Tiana? Please don't change Tiana's canon true love, a black man for a white man please

6) One episode and just changing because he has a daughter it's not a good redeption arc you know right? Also, Original Hook changed because he wanted to help Henry, to honor Bae's memory, yes he fell in love with Emma, but what make him come back was Bae. Henry may not be his biological son, and still he loves him and cares about him.

7) Also, if 'you love Nook so much because he changed for her daughter', I have news for you, Original Hook has a daughter too!! I'm sure you will love him as much when you watch him with her on the finale episode