Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-26967699-20170718200846/@comment-2153169-20170718203607

CadoDoan wrote: Lady Junky wrote: Ice Magic is not a subcategory of Witchcraft. Elsa is not a witch at all. That's something very specific to Elsa's family, as it was said. If it was Witchcraft, then it'd mean everyone would be able to do it which is not the case.

Belief is not Witchcraft too. That's different. And this is a type of magic very specific from Neverland mainly, and other places in more uncommon moments.

True Love under Magical Abilities? Are we saying True love is an ability? We had a consensus saying it is not the case. So, its own type again.

Potioncraft is the same as Belief. Not Witchcraft, but another type as some no magical people are able to use it.

So, for all these reasons, I disagree as your suggestion is not taking in consideration what they are really. You said "He/She is not a witch" a couple of times before. I don't think you have to be a witch to use Witchcraft. So what, Rumple is a witch? xD

It was mentioned that people can use Ice Magic too. When Ingrid asked Rumple magic ribbons, Rumple offered her to be her teacher. He wouldn't offer it if it was only used by Elsa's family. (He was talking about Ice Magic, not some other thing)

Yes, Belief is definetely not Witchcraft. So is Potioncraft. I didn't say that.

Think like Lily's magic ability. She's not using Witchcraft--->Shapeshifting, only Shapeshifting.

Maybe we can open another section for Belief, Potioncraft and True Love? They may not be abilities, but I refuse to call them "Types" as for the reason I see types as species magic.

I was talking about Elsa. Rumple is a wizard. Witch/Wizard.

Rumple said he could be his teacher, yeah. But, we can't assume he is able to use Ice Magic. While it was said specifically that Ice Magic was for Elsa's magic. We can't just ignore that point for the sake of our category. Rumple is well-versed in Magic, so he can prolly teach a few stuff without being able to use it himself.

Lily's ability is something different. He comes from her lineage, from her mother, so her ability is the same as Maleficent's. What we do for Maleficent should be the same for Lily's.

So, for you, Species Magic = Type of Magic? I think it is a bit reductive to think that way. If you don't want to call them "type" fine, but then how do we call them? Because they are not abilities.