Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-27060727-20161201052050/@comment-25926288-20170321001723

MBrody wrote: JennaMae wrote: I really don't understand why the writers are making this into a Hook/Emma problem when its really a Hook/David problem. Emma shouldn't even care too much, but they'll probably have her be more upset than David, which doesn't make much sense. I don't really agree. I think as long as Hook is upfront about it, Emma won't find it that hard to forgive him. That's been her MO since the series started. And I also don't agree that it is a Hook/David problem. I don't see any reason why he even has to tell David. David has already made his peace with his father's passing; telling him would do nothing but hurt him. If Hook were to tell him, it would be kind of selfish. I see it more as Hook/Emma problem, since they're in a committed relationship; Hook and David are not. Telling David is the right thing to do. Saying that he shouldn't tell David isn;t some mutually exculsive event to his relationship to Emma. He should tell both, Emma being less so concerned because she doesn't even know the guy.