Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-24413185-20140112065900/@comment-4975807-20140112070229

Though they are the same person, the counterparts are counted separately on this wiki. He did not die as Rumplestiltskin. He died as Mr. Gold. Same case would be applied to the Huntsman and Sheriff Graham. The Huntsman is listed as alive while Graham is listed as dead. It's listed as such to distinguish which counterpart the person died as, and which counterpart is still considered "alive" in the flashback sense.