Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-3574574-20180520053645/@comment-1916997-20180521013938

Kunica wrote: DonnaBrooks1 wrote: Kunica wrote: And i feel bad for Nook since he will never have any grandchildren of his own. First of all, Nook is HAPPY Alice & Robin are in love. Evidence: 1) After that charming scene when Robin gives her the bracelet and it's obvious how sweet they are on each other, Nook confronts Rumple who was watching from afar, and he said, "You saw her with Robin!  She's happy!  She finally has a chance at a normal life and I won't let anyone, including the dark one, threaten to take that away from her!"  2) After Rumple stops Alice from becoming immortal by interrupting her before she can destroy the dagger, some months have passed and Hook again finds Rumple, who is AGAIN watching Alice & Robin from the woods and smiling, and this time he says, "I heard about what you did for Alice and Robin....I owe you a great debt." AND ROBIN. 3) After he gets out of the hospital, Alice calls him from across the street, and he asks, "How are you; how's Robin?"  These are NOT the words & actions of a man who is disappointed that Alice's love interest happens to be a woman.  So don't feel bad for Nook!  If Alice is happy, he's happy, and he knows Robin treats her well.  I think that's the most important thing to any parent.  I can't imagine a parent wanting to keep their child from the person they love, and worse, pushing them to marry someone they don't love, just so the parent can have grandchildren!  That's really selfish and Hook is anything BUT selfish toward Alice.  Also, if Alice married a guy, there's still NO GUARANTEE that they could or would have children!  (Edited to remove a section of the quoted comment which I did not address in this post.) Donna-Nook is happy now since he knows Alice truly loves Robin,but dont you really think that at one point in his life he will realise that he chould have grandchildren but cant.Good people or Heroes allways want at one point from there children to have there kids so that both can reproduce and have the bloodline of each family alive.Tell me isnt true that after both Robin and Alice die out of old age there wont be any more of Wish Jones bloodline to follow.Thats the truth evean thought he is happy now and in future years from now,Nook will at one point question himself about "how wonderfull whould have been to have grandchildren".Also if Alice was married to a guy it dosent matter if it worked out beetwen them or not the only thing that matters is that she cant get pregnat and have kids,so that Wish Jones family will survive in future.And thats a fact,but hey at least main reality Hook wont expirence that fate with his daughter.

And like Esk said lets not go to far into religion debate. You know Alice can still get pregnant right? Lots of same sex couples (male or female) simply use sperm (for female couples) or egg (for male couples) donors, and have children that are biologically related to one parent. So really, your whole argument falls flat, because Alice can have a biological child, if she so chooses.