Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24894881-20140503034318/@comment-26237024-20150323163757

''Yep, useless to guess. Age isn't indicative of number of murders. Hook is as old as Rumple, roughly, and he hasn't killed more than Regina. ''

Maybe it was wrong for me to assume that Rumpel had killed more, based upon his age. But how do you know that Regina has killed more than Hook? Let's face it. We really don't know how many people he has killed before he first met Regina and Cora. We don't know if he has killed others, while hanging out with Cora during those 28 years when the Enchanted Forest was frozen in time.

Like you said, it's useless to guess.