Board Thread:Show-Related Questions and Answers/@comment-5571357-20140512054818/@comment-24788250-20140512182819

Stonicus wrote: Johntoxable wrote:

Toma Cre wrote: Well, the writers tend to play very fast and loose with the rules of magic. I mean you have three basic rules of magic that can't be broken, except sometimes they can under certain conditions. Yeah, they really do, and it's really gotten worse this season.

Indeed... I'll accept any rules they give us as long as they stick to em. What's the point of even having rules if they can just be broken so willy-nilly? Best example, Regina used magic to bring David back to life when Snow crushed his heart.

In this case, Regina\Snow acted quickly enough to split Snow's heart in half, and put half of it back into David.

I wondered briefly why Regina didn't do something similar for her Father (which would mean ripping her own heart out)? I suspect that because Regina's heart is very black, splitting it wouldn't of worked. The other thought was why didn't Regina have an extra heart on hand (I'm sure by the time the dark curse #1 was cast, she would have plenty of extra hearts on hand) to shove back into her father? or that matter David?