Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27255668-20151207215419/@comment-25926288-20151208165058

CTrent29 wrote: Whatever spell that the Apprentice used to transfer Emma's potential for evil DIDN'T WORK. She still became a thief. She remains in possession of a stolen car with no regard for remorse. She has more difficulty in admitting her mistakes than anyone. She had killed Cruella (and I do believe it was murder) and would have murdered Lily if Regina had not stopped her.

The spell didn't work. The spell didn't move "potential for evil" just funneled any Darkness Emma recieved into Lily. Except when she became the DO. The Apprentice said after he did the spell, that Snow and David would still have to lead her in the right path to be good.