Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-91424-20180501022106/@comment-24304025-20180501130219

Summarizing it

1. About the infobox, the issues are:

a) The top name and the color - when no name is added in that parameter, the color doesn't work right. Lady and Ruben are trying to make it work. The plan is to have Evil Queen - Regina Mills - Roni as the top name, being each of them a tab that, when you click it, will change the infobox pic.

Tha plan is *not* to have the infobox change colors or the world name to change when you change the pic. The color and world name are supposed to remain the original ones, no matter which counterpart pic you use.

Likewise, there will be no such distinction as "Original" and "Cursed", nor "Enchanted Forest" and "Storybrooke".

Possible solutions are:

I. Lady and Ruben finding a way to make the above work in the coding.

II. In case the latter doesn't happen, we could have a generic name for each and every page, like this, which would fix the color and the name problem and allow us to change pic by clicking the name of the counterpart.

III. We could choose to have just one pic instead of various infobox pictures. That would fix the issue as well. We would add all names in the top, but use just the most recent as the infobox pic. It is a good compromise, I assume. Similar to this option, isn't there a way to add a kind of "gif" thing as the infobox thing? One that alternates automatically from one to the next to the next to the first, allowing us to have three counterparts in the infobox while having "one pic" coding-wise? The options her being "the most recent as the pic" or "the gif-like thing".

2. About the page name:

My personal preference is the following:

a) the credited name of the character by the time the first curse hit. That would often coincide with the "fairytale" identity, the "Disney" counterpart, the most well-known version of the character. It would also be a clear, solid way to deal with it. We would have Peter Pan instead of Malcolm, Pinocchio instead of August Booth, Owen Flynn instead of Greg Mendell, Baelfire instead of Neal Cassidy, Jiminy Cricket instead of only Jiminy, Snow White instead of Mary Margaret Blanchard etc.

When the character is credited both by their name and by a title, we'd probably use the name, so Zelena instead of Wicked Witch of the West, Killian Jones instead of Hook, Will Scarlet instead of Knave of Hearts, Ingrid instead of Snow Queen, Elsa instead of Ice Queen and Jefferson instead of Mad Hatter etc. (or, in this cases, we could use the most common credited name.)

b) The character's birth name, if the actor was ever credited as that, followed by the known last name or, when the name was only credited with the title, keep the title. Like Nurse Ratched instead of Severe Nurse, Sir Morgan instead of Hank Morgan.

c) I'm not a fan of having two pages with the same content when the source code is in one and the others are just "fake" copies. Like currently. We have the EQ page, the RM page and the Roni page, but you can only edit the EQ, the others just display the original one's content. However, I know that people agreed, so let's keep it - unless a new discussion is worth it.

Conclusion

If neither options a) nor b) are viable (I know they are personal opinions, I just wanted to express them here so that others could know them), then I had to choose between Lily's four options, I'd choose Number 2, followed by Number 3. They are the simplest.

1 is not the best, we might end up having Kelly as the main title when she was in 10% of Bex's episodes.

4 is tricky. We can't always know what the character chooses to go by. Whale answers to both Whale and Frankenstein, but not Victor, so what would we use? Ruby is called both Ruby and Red. What does Gold prefer? People call him Gold and Rumple all the time, more often than either Mr. Gold or Rumplestiltskin. Who knows how Jim wants to be called? Is it Ava because we last saw her as Ava or Gretel because we never saw her after the curse broke, therefore she hasn't had a chance to "choose" which she wants to be called? Marco and Geppetto have been used interchangeably, same with Blue and Mother Superiro. Keith was never said on-screen. Nick probably preferred Hansel, and the Old Prisoner would definitely like Sultan better etc.etc.