Board Thread:Off-Topic Fun/@comment-25361971-20150109142750/@comment-1894786-20150904011817

CoolDudeAl wrote: Hmcooper4 wrote: I don't know. a musical episode sounds a bit gimmicky to me. And I am probably one of the world's geekiest people when it comes to musicals, particularly Disney musicals. (I danced with my Daughter to "Once Upon a Dream" at her wedding, and I sing many of the classic disney tunes to my granddaughter).

Getting Alan Menken or Phil Collins to write the music would be good, if they'd do it. (There's a reason The Little Mermaid, Beauty and the Beast, and the Lion King do so well on Broadway).

Besides, while we know that the actors are good at acting, we don't know how well they sing. And if they are only average to slightly above average singers, a musical episode would be, in my opinion, an epic failure, regardless of how well the music is written. Wait, forget the music, you have a grandchild!?! I didn't think anyone older than early 40's would even be on forums. Not because they don't have an interest, but forums just seem like something only Generation X and younger would get, having grown up with (and also be so dependant on) technology.

Anyway, back on topic, I still would want to see a musical episode, but as I stated above, I think it has to be Emma (or maybe Henry) getting knocked out, and dreaming of the characters singing. A non-canon special could also work. Early 40's? I can't see anyone past mid-30's being on forums. It seems like a thing people do to kill time 'till they get kids. lol