Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25491743-20181127152213/@comment-34397172-20181128144650

Aine1989 wrote: Just a few points: Your points sound more like a defense. 1. You cannot say Nook changed and Hook didn't. OG Hook has done way more to redeem himself than Nook ever did. If you think he has not changed, please rewatch the show, you missed key details. His only real reversion was the DO.''' We'll I didn't miss details. I watched it more than once. Many have. His other reversions is continuing on lying to others for personal things. He showed too much impatiance to others in a rushy selfish way. He reverted in 6x20 towards Rumple when darting him in his shop saying he would skin himself a crocodile (even though we don't see more of it). He continues lying to people like he did in s7 on Henry, much to Regina's displeasement. He's left still lying to everyone about Ariel, when he never helped her find Eric, but betrayed her, and that the Ariel he met in Storybrooke was not her, but Zelena. Still left lying about it, just like how Regina still left lying about Graham's murder. Throughout David's life, Hook left him under a lie about his dad, until in s6, when he found out who David's dad is, he does it again, before Emma found out and told her dad what really happened herself (even though she hinted she would iie to him too). Which shows he hasn't fully changed on that. Yes, he may have changed in some ways, but not completely. You missed some key details here. And what you said about wish hook did not make it true actually. We saw him evolve more and did things that Hook didn't fully. There many things different between them too. Like how his friendship with Wish Ariel, which seemed better than what their counterparts started. Alot of difference between two counterparts. Even though Hook gave up his ship in s3, he gets it back in s4, and kept it ever since. But Nook on the other hand, gave his up completely. We all saw it. Which proves Nook does better.'''

2. You can't sat "villains lie, Hook lied once, ergo he is a villain". By this logic, every person on this show is a villain. By logic, not everyone.

3. Hook has shown remorse for all the things he did as the DO, including killing Merlin ("If anyone deserves to go to the UW it's me").There was no mention of Merlin actually, despite his remorse.

4. This is a fairytale show where Snow is bffs with the woman who killed her father and tortured her. might not work IRL, but suspension of disbelief applies here. We know he has changed enough not to revert. '''I've already been well aware of it being a fairytale show already. We all know that. And he already did revert more than once. Reverting does not necessarily turning evil again and again, it can refer to more than that. Remember Emma in s1? Cursed Snow said to Emma, in 1x21, that she was reverting. So reverting does not mean going evil again. Cause throughout the seasons, we seen many people revert in their own way more than once, whether it's going evil again or not. Rumple, Emma, Regina, Hook, Zelena, etc for example. We know that no matter how hard they try to change, they revert again, and again, and again.'''

Don't misinterpret this as an argument, it's just a bit of friendly details.