Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-34360784-20180116101248/@comment-25375217-20180119023208

CoolDudeAl wrote: DatNuttyKid wrote:

Furthermore, the statements you're citing are vague in and of themselves, even barring the pre-existing Wish Realm debacle. How would Wish Hook know what Hook's mother's name is? Because the mother is literally the same person! Hook and WHook are the same person, just in different timelines! How can Hook have a different mother, and still be Hook? That's my point! How can Robin be 28 years younger, and still be Robin? How can Snow and Charming have their lives be exactly the same but somehow stop Regina? How can everything have happened exactly the same and Stealthy is still alive?

The Wish Realm proves over and over again that it is not the exact same. Several on-screen facts don't get disproven just because one character had one line claiming otherwise. To use your own slippery slope argument, we should list that Lancelot is dead because Cora said he was, so obviously she must have been telling the truth even though we've seen otherwise.

At this point, I'm almost entirely convinced that every single word I've said has been outright ignored because I don't understand how this isn't clear. How in the world does it make sense to assume something is true when there's so much evidence proving how dangerous and unprofessional it is to claim that it's true? Quite frankly, this argument is, in my opinion, ridiculous and embarrassing. I'm unfollowing this thread before I get much more honest than that, but I'm going to be heavily disappointed if I see we've ignored encyclopedic standards to add unproven "facts" to an article just because some people are too impatient to accept a vague listing.