Board Thread:Show-Related Questions and Answers/@comment-34924658-20150517221728/@comment-25077005-20150518023106

Farerb wrote: Dark Fantasy1990 wrote: Eskaver wrote: Dark Fantasy1990 wrote: Killian Jones wrote:

Dark Fantasy1990 wrote: With season 3 I think she got out of Storybrooke just before everyone excluding Emma & Henry return to the Enchanted Forest then return after the second curse was activated. She couldn't have. EVERYONE from the EF was taken home, even if they hadn't been taken by the curse in the first place, excepting Emma. Ingrid was from Arendelle, and wasn't affected by the first curse since she arrived in the LWM in 1982. And neither was Doctor Whale, etc. She is fromthe same world as EF. I really don't want to start a argument. I was just pointing it out that she could have left Storybrooke before everyone from the EF was taken home. No, she couldn't. Just like Neal, Hook and Tinkerbell. But if I recalled she still had the Sorcerer's Scroll that magically materialize her to Storybrooke.