Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-34360784-20180116101248/@comment-25926288-20180118123429

I like using these types of reasoning and I, personally, think Hook's family tree is the same. But..

1. We need a source (to be consistent)

2. The biggest evidence used is that everything was the same ala Wish Hook's statement.

You can get away with Stealthy existing, youthful Robin, and a lot of stuff because...we saw them post curse attempt. But we have a key piece of evidence that says that things were not the same before the curse: Roland.

Roland was born years before the curse (and Marian married Robin long before the curse). That's enough to discredit that idea becuase you can explain a young Robin post-curse fail, but not the story being different before the curse fail.

3. As was said, the wish was not being the Savior, not "What if the Curse failed".

4. As I and others have now said, Wish Hook isn't omniscient, so he has no clue what real Hook went through. With the amount of unreliable characters, I think we need more than a vague statement which already has counter-evidence.