Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-29344333-20160805112858/@comment-25926288-20160805144025

Delightful!

Ideas are always intriguing, but TV networks aren't going to do anything close to this. Two separate genres of TV shows, two different stations, two different companies, two different mega-corps, and the fact that there's no incentive. Other than that, the stories don't mesh, the worldbuilding greatly clahes, and I'm sure the intended audiences are different. Monetary-wise, it will likely make them a loss, rather than a profit because all the expesnes going into it would not be worth increasing the price of a DVD and surely they won't stream it. So, it's very far-fetched as a business move...because Disney.

Now, that the technical stuff is out of the way, I will say that I enjoy both shows! Regardless of how the narrative and worldbuilding clashes, could it happen?

Well, based on your fabulous ideas (very well-put together!), it does mesh, if you ignore most of both shows. XD. SPN has a whole bunch of things whicb is what most of your ideas is based on. However, Once doesn't really match and it becomes more fanfictiony than anything else.

First, they'd have to be in two separate worlds. Then, none if this would actually happen, lol. I assure you that Sam and Dean definitely do not live in the Enchanted Forest. Even if in the same Universe, it wouldn't make sense that they would even know the Dark One who's just some crazy wizard in an entirely different world. But then again, they are resourceful.

Second, all the witches don't know each other and wouldn't. Ingrid and Zelena don't know each other. Zelena and Mal don't know each other. Most of them aren't in covens. Most weren't even in the same area.

Next, Magic works differently on both shows. Any Once Witch would probably easily defeat/ kill any witch on SPN. And Rumple can't ressurect and he's probably an anomaly in the making as magic in SPN can do these things, but in Once they do different things.

Lastly, I do love the idea. Great premise of a great story and 100% agree with the opening phrase of "Outrageous and Bold". Though cameos are far more likely, like really likely.