Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-25926288-20161101150057/@comment-24674051-20161116174633

NickyHelp wrote:

Hmcooper4 wrote: So we get some CaptainCharming going on? nice.

I still don't think Killian is PapaCharming's murderer, though. Any conflict between them may be more related to methods, secret keeping (David's secret, not Killian). In fact, you might see a bit of a role reversal, where David is going to be hell-bent on revenge, and Killian is trying like crazy to stop David from doing something stoopid. Particularly if George is somehow involved, since there is still a lot of unresolved Bad Blood between George and David. (Not only from what happened in the EF, but also for his actions in Storybrooke)

I'm still on the fence about George's involvement, though. I'm thinking any involvement on George's part will be linked to information provided by Rumple. I have to slightly disagree with you on that. After all, Josh already spoiled that something will affect his relationship with Hook. Just like what he did about his bromance with King Arthur (and it came true). So that sounds close enough that possibly Hook was the culprit. If Killian is trying to stop Charming from getting his revenge on whoever killed his Papa, that would have at least short term impact on their relationship, and not in a good way. Also, I'd have to go back and look at exactly what Josh said (and maybe even how he said it), because Killian preventing David from doing something really stupid would have a positive impact to the relationship (at least in the long haul).

Now, I could be dead wrong about Killian, but I'm just not seeing any Motive, and very limited opportunity, for him to be involved with the original murder. I guess we'll have to wait and see how this story spins.