Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-24304025-20150202171011/@comment-24674051-20150427171126

Agree. Robin, up until the End of Lily, was under the impression that Marian is his long dead wife returned. Once he decided to make a legitimate go of the marriage, there is absolutely no reason for Robin and "Marian" not to consummate the relationship, again. No Magic, other than the Glamour spell. (And I guess those spells must be real good to handle the private situations).

Now, the first question is if Zelena is lying. When did they find out (was it before or after Gold got Belle's heart back). Because Emma, Regina, and Lily were somewhere between Boston and Storybrooke when Regina got the call from Maleficent regarding Belle. So there were at least a couple of hours, in which time Gold could easily have alerted Zelena. She then could concoct the story and feed it to Robin.

The next question is how, once he recovers from the SHOCK of discovering that his wife was still dead and that he slept with her killer, will Robin respond. Yes, that may be his child Zelena is carrying, but can he, in good conscience, stay in any kind of relationship with Zelena. I doubt his code has anything to cover this situation.

Third, a totally off track, How do you explain all of this to Roland? Robin just thinks he had a mess before when he thought it was Marian vs Regina.