Board Thread:Rant and Rave/@comment-24593235-20171014032523/@comment-25703308-20171014093556

"Hook could have been on a mission to find his way back to Emma and they wouldn't even need to show their reunion''

What? Seriously now, if that happened you'd be furious on how they handled the reunion without even showing Emma. And frankly, if that happened even I'd be disappointed they did it without showing it on screen.

I agree Hook could have been written off, but he wasn't. We have a brand new version of him that has a story to tell. It's confusing as hell but I'm on board. It's like having two Cinderellas with two different stories, for me. Only this time, both Hooks are portrayed by the same actor.

And now, I didn't only come here to defend the show, I do have some issues:

As I said, I'm okay with Hook being Wish Realm Hook, it was a great twist. My issue is  'Why give him such a big, heavy and sensitive story like searching for a daughter that's been kidnapped by a witch? It only makes things more confusing.

He could have wandered in this alternative realm until Tremaine found him and assigned him to kill Henry, while pretending to be the other Hook. But alas, we have what we have.