Thread:FrancisPaul/@comment-5679696-20161212154837/@comment-91424-20161214000319

But the thing is: The date on the newspaper does not mean, in any way, that Emma was born on October 23. The curse hit at night (after Emma was sent through the wardrobe), as witnessed by Owen and his father when they're camping, and we don't know whether this happened before or after midnight. So the date on the morning newspaper does not actually prove anything, and does not contradict what "Selfless..." says.