Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-25315804-20180519053838/@comment-35641650-20180520202241

Lady Junky wrote: If (and, only if) we have a clear source stating that they are engaged, we can add them.

Otherwise, we don't. Even if they are endgame, that is not the point of our trees :/

For example, Dorothy and Ruby are endgame but they're not on each other family tree ^^' What source is acceptable? I can ask Rose during the live chat tomorrow night (although there's no guarantee the hosts will ask my question). She's a guest on the Afterbuzz TV network's Once Upon a Time review show. All 4 hosts have been gushing about Alice & Robin since 7x10. So they might want some clarification from her, even if I don't ask. Would video of her confirming their engagement be an acceptable source?

Or how about if I track down that (I'm assuming print) interview someone mentioned in which Rose talked about them being engaged and that she wore the ring at the coronation? Would that be a clear source? Would a tweet from Rose be acceptable, or does it have to be from Adam or from OUAT?

I don't put Dorothy & Ruby in the same league as Alice & Robin! I never even used the term, "endgame" to describe Alice & Robin. Those are your words, and AnimationFan18's words. Alice & Robin were a lot more than just endgame. They had a well-developed love story that transcended time and space and they were together even as different characters and in multiple realms. I'm happy for Ruby & Dorothy, but their story doesn't even come close, even if they were endgame.

What is the point of your trees? Why is Alice's uncle considered important to include on her tree? Do they only show blood relatives? If so, is there some area where romantic relationships between unmarried people who did not produce offspring are listed?

OK, I just checked Regina's page and I see that Daniel is included b/c they were engaged, even though they didn't have children, but her relationship w/ Robin Hood (M) is not, even though, to my knowledge, he was her great love, so I'm a little clearer on that now.