Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-34924658-20170919184815/@comment-25926288-20170919215300

Let's go with the facts.

Appearance: Both are brunettes, Clorinda is wearing green, Tisbe is wearing yellow. So, appearance says nothing.

Story:

Cinderella 2: Anastasia falls in love with a baker, Lady Tremaine and Drizella disapprove. Ana goes to the ball with the Baker.

Cinderella 3: Anastasia switches places with Cinderella.

I think Clorinda liking a commoner is just a common story telling plotline. It's a stretch to say Clorinda liking the Prince's footman is anything like Anastatia falling in love with a baker. That wuld be like saying that Maleficent's agitation towards Stefan is a nod toward Disney's Maleficent (that one), which it really isn't.

They can allude to the Wicked Stepsister and Ana and Drizzy, but there is nothing that is strong enough to prove either case. I can see why some may see Clorinda as Anastasia, but I think the case is too weak.