Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25379261-20160506225151/@comment-26116863-20160506230541

The person would have to be either openly or secretly evil, because one of the brothers is evil. Or they could both be nice enough to reincarnate as a humans, but they wouldn't remember their past lives. Then Post-reincarnation Hook could find Emma, because they're soulmates, but he wouldn't  know why he was so attracted to her. That would be interesting.