Board Thread:Rant and Rave/@comment-25733960-20180512073657/@comment-25926288-20180515003357

8Rob wrote: Eskaver wrote: 8Rob wrote:

Eskaver wrote: Both Henry's can use it because they are the same. I don't think this is correct

The Wish chracters are not linked at all to the real ones, except for the Darkness, which is shared by Weaver and W!Rumple

It's like W!Robin and Robin: They made pretty clear they are not the same person at all.

That's why I don't get how W!Henry could use Henry's Quill. They are both Henry. I didn’t say they are exactly the same. Remember when Henry said Captain Hook into a bottle? It went to both Hooks. That was because the Wish duplicated the bottle, so W!Hook had another one

That had nothing to do with Hook and W!Hook "the same" Magic considers them the same.

At the end of the day, you are arguing about mechanics that the writers have made for their show.