Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-4839682-20140819182912/@comment-24936039-20141103080711

CoolDudeAl wrote: Arctucrus wrote:

-A musical episode. People have requested this, and I would honestly probably at least come close to quitting on the show. The whole point of the show is to be realistic with these stories. It just doesn't fit, IMO. I'd hate to see it. It's the one thing that would solely at least bring me close to quitting on the show, if not quitting on it entirely.

I always thought a musical episode would work well, as long as the explanation was that Emma gets knocked out, and she dreams of all the people she knows as their Disney counterparts singing. It would also make an easy plot as to why it's only in one episode.

A musical worked in Buffy the Vampire Slayer (due to magic). Supernatural is going to have a musical (due to magic). So I don't see why a musical OUAT episode can not happen due to magic again. (OUAT is owned by Disney, it's the Frozen arc and Frozen WAS a musical...)