Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-1916997-20171222202521/@comment-1916997-20171227210435

FrancisPaul wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: FrancisPaul wrote: The 5th curse was cast by the Coven + Regina.

The Coven is formed of Gothel, Drizella, 5 witches we don't know but Gothel does, and one remaining spot, which hadn't been filled yet. The NEF Coven of the Eight was not complete yet, it was called of the Eight because they needed to find the eighth member. Regina was coerced into taking the place of the eighth member, but that's just replacement for that specific purpose, while they didn't have their eighth witch. I can kind of see this point, but if Regina was used to perform a coven ritual doesn't that kind of make her a temporary Coven member, or at least means this point about Regina should be listed somewhere on the Coven's page? But casting the curse is not a Coven ritual. It requires eight witches, but any witch out of the Coven could have performed it herself if some rules applied How do we know that wasn't a coven ritual? Isn't that pretty speculative to say it wasn't, when all signs point to it was.