Thread:FrancisPaul/@comment-5679696-20161212154837/@comment-2153169-20161213235704

Both sides have their own logic, and both are correct.

That's where is your mistake Lily, you are assuming October 22 is the correct date. First of atll, it is just a deduction of yours. We never saw clearly stated at one time the fact that it is October 22. Just how you understand it, it is your respectable way to see but not the only one.

Killian's logic is on October 23rd. And it works too, as Emma was born after midnight. With that info in mind, then the October 23rd works perfectly too, and can not be contradicted by the show.

So the two dates can work. Lily and Killian both proved it. The only issue there? One date is being supported by the writers and creators of the show, while the other is only supported by a post-production added note. So, in this case, as both dates work we have to follow the bigger source we have: Adam and Eddy. So, Emma was born on October 23rd ^^

Plus, I'd like to point out just for the discussion (out of the discussion ^^), that the show does not trump the creators. Our policies can say what they want about that, that's not how work the canonicity of an universe. The show is the creation of Adam and Eddy, meaning their words is as important as the show's word. Saying the show > creators is just wrong on all the rules of how work a canon ^^ It is more show/creator = creators, because the show is their words.