Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24386552-20161126003458/@comment-26443838-20161126014044

Dan Fox wrote: He may have initiated it, but Snow and Charming were still responsible. As confirmed by Jane Espenson herself. I still find that storyline really distasteful. Had this all been thought out prior to S4, I do think it could've been a lot more awesome. But... it only seemed to add to the dreary arc and really change the way we look at Season One and onwards. I also believe now, Emma being born early was karma for what had happened with Lily. She didn't get to be raised by her mother/parents and neither did Emma. They were partially but not fully (only Isaac was fully). It was unfair judging. And what Jane said was only her story (not a true fact). And the only reason why both were not raised by their parents was because of Regina and Isaac. We'll I hope that one day Lily will know the real truth and probably will kill Isaac for this for good.

And now that Jane is writing ep 12, I can see her and her co writer writing a tragic and foul events. Since it shows that something will affect Charming (which seems to have something to do with the murder of his father).