Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-25926288-20160915032911/@comment-27060727-20160930063002

ItachiIshtar wrote: DatNuttyKid wrote: It matches Sidney's in design...! Kind of resembles Cyrus's too though, but given the name of the episode... Cyrus was in a bottle, not a lamp. Maybe it is Sidney's lamp, and he was Aladdin's genie? Looking at the screencaps in the gallery, I think it's a total match for Sidney's lamp. But they did change the details a bit and reuse it for a different genie in OUATIW so that could be happening again. Hopefully a Giancaro Esposito announcement is coming?

I really like the idea of Sidney having granted a wish for Aladdin in the past! Most of time, I'm wrong when I get attached to a theory lol, but this one would make total sense. How they not connect Aladdin and the original OUAT genie during an episode referencing "mirror" in the title, right? Haha.