Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20151116014923/@comment-6175354-20151116212041

Mesmermann wrote: 1. Like someone said in this thread: "Seriously even though she saved Hook's life, she turned him into the thing he hates the most" Not only that, but Emma's "altruistic" plan was to murder Zelena. How would that have saved either of them? If Emma was truly selfless in trying to save Hook, she would have run herself through with Excalibur. Which is something I suspect, Hook will end up doing for her.... once he calms down.

Do I understand why Emma turned Hook into a Dark One.... yes, she was desperate. Do I agree with the decision.... hell, no.