Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-8345449-20151128142008/@comment-25926288-20151128215242

Farerb wrote: Eskaver wrote: CoolDudeAl wrote: I'm confused as to why this is even a thing. Captain Hook is traditionally a villain and a pirate. Pirates do bad things. No one should be shocked that Hook has killed people or done bad things. Honestly, we should see this side to him more often, maybe it will stop some of the Hookers who think he's some kind of god. He's a somewhat redeemed villain, just like Regina. Yeah, and both Regina, Hook, and Rumple still have things that they have to amend. None of them were good, each being kilers in their own right. None greater than the other. Yet, they never made amends about anything. Yep, some truth in that you can't always make amends, like in Hook's case, most of those people are dead. Regina has countless hearts, but I'm sure the writers won't let Regina give them back on screen. (I always wondered what happened what happens to an enchanted heart when the person dies.)

I would say that they aren't making amends, but showing love in a small group setting.