Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-30235980-20161015165325/@comment-26159109-20161016053743

DatNuttyKid wrote: Farerb, I'm honestly curious. Why do you even watch this show? You seem to hate everything they do.

Please explain why they couldn't have meto in 2001.

Pregnancy takes 9 month, the Tallahassee flashbacks + NPLH make it pretty clear that we see events that happens in the span of months (you don't decide to live the rest of your lives with someone you spent time with only a day), so there's no possible way that Emma and Neal met in 2001, not even if it is January 1st, 2001, spend months (or even weeks) together and Henry was born on August 15th (or any other date before October 22nd) unless Emma had eaten magical onion rings (which I'm sure some people would theorize about that now because there is no possible way that A&E made a mistake)