Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-27060727-20180128024732/@comment-32423680-20180204204206

I made a theory, remember the Sorcerer's Hat? Rumple wanted it to break free of the dagger, but he couldn't. My theory is that The Guardian is the one who guards all the darkness inside the hat.

What do you think about the "death of a familiar face"? I bet it's Granny.