Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-5899967-20170927102346/@comment-2054358-20171015215845

The fact that this isn't the Hook we know actually makes a giant plothole. Rogers saw something familiar about Emma Swan's picture in Henry's storybook. And he was interested in Henry's swan keychain. Wish-Hook had only met Emma in two episodes, while the real Hook had been with her since Season 2. The real Hook would be more likely to remember Emma than Wish-Hook. And he told Henry about a woman who healed his wound. While Wish-Hook was there in that scene, it was the real Hook that was stabbed. Those hints really call into question which Hook became Rogers.