Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-25345262-20160724231934/@comment-25345262-20160822231959

Scarydragonvamp wrote: I agree with the idea that Maleficent lied. I find it hard to believe that she mated in dragon form without ever seeing who he was. Also, in 4B we never got a full backstory of Maleficent (how she became evil, what changed between her and Regina, etc.)

Maybe the reason the writers didn't do this was because they had something planned for when it came time to go over Lily's father. As for the King Stefan idea, it's possible. It was heavily implied during 4x14 that they had a past before Briar Rose. I wonder if in the end he chose Briar Rose and dumped Mal, kind of like with Ana and Will.

However, the timelines do not agree at all. Maleficents pregnancy was after or just barely before Regina stole the dark curse, which is years after the implied love between Stefan and Mal.

So overall, there are several possibilities, As much as I stand by my Jafar is Maleficent's baby daddy theory, maybe while Aurora was slumbering, Briar Rose died of a broken heart and Stefan decided to suduce Maleficent to get her to break the curse she placed on Phillip. Maleficent would actually forgive him for choosing Briar Rose over her and she and Stefan sleep together during which Lily was conceived. But then he leaves her when he finds out that the curse on Phillip was actually broken by Belle. But rather than killing Stefan she shows him mercy and lets him flee, cause she knows that she's  pregnant. So maybe she lied to Lily to spare her the story of a lost love her betrayed her long ago.