Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-27060727-20171014181959/@comment-6175354-20171018135941

Eskaver wrote: The thing is Robin is literally an infant as Hook-W has a daughter that's already kidnapped by a witch. Robin would need to travel back in time after aging up, which is ridiculous. (In other words, regardless is Hook-W's daughter aged naturally or sprung into existence by the wish, we literally saw baby Robin toted around by her mum. XD) Look, I completely agree with you, Esk. However, we both know how inconsistant the OUaT writers are, when it comes to keeping track of their timeline. If Zelena's daughter is revealed to be the Witch, this would not be the first retcon nor the last.