Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-25926288-20151211170125/@comment-25926288-20160419162239

Aine1989 wrote: Eskaver wrote: Vid is okay, but you don't really even need that when in 517 (this most recent episode) you had Hook: "You idiots don't have a plan."

Emma: "I have a crazy idea."

Hook: "Yes, love. I can never doubt you, my love. Never ever."

It's hilarious because he's being harsh towards the people that he almost killed that came to help save him and risked their lives. I'm honestly wondering if what you'd have been like if Hook had said "No Emma I don't believe you." Probably something along the lines of "blah blah how dare he not believe in Emma." Also I must have missed the part where he said 'idiots.' How very dare he be skeptical of Regina's plan, which he did not doubt after she explained it.

And I'm assuming you're referencing Henry here, so I'll bring him up. Yes, Killian is so awful for not treating Henry like a precious special snowflake. Henry's not a baby, he wants to be taken seriously, meaning he can take a little "You should be doing what you said you'd be doing."

I'm pretty sure Killian could run into a burning building and die saving a bunch of orphans and you people would still find a way to twist this into 'HE'S A VILLAIN!!!!!!!' Nope, not at all. It would go with how things were presented. First scene: Hook's doubting everyone's ideas. Next Scene: Hook decides that he should not doubt Emma. The issue there isn't his agreeing or disagreeing, but going from one point to another. I'll provide exact quotes in a matter of time so you can see for yourself. Just balance and yes, I know those you like more tend to get a biased response, but Hook's episode was all about putting people on pedastals that he couldn not reach.

And I wasn't talking about Henry specifically, but Killian did straighten up and thanked David for coming down to help save him.