Thread:FrancisPaul/@comment-5679696-20161212154837/@comment-91424-20161214004046

I know that Emma arrived in daylight, but that does not prove that she arrived in our world on October 23. We know that it took hours for the curse to travel through the EF (because of what we see in Queen...), so therfore, it could also have taken the curse hours to reach earth after Emma was sent through the wardrobe, and Emma could easily have arrived several hours before the curse cloud hit the LWM. Oh, and about canon: If you read the whole section, you can see that it days that the show supersedes what the creators say - creators are specifically mentioned. But anyway: I can see that this is a complicated matter, but since there was a consensus to use October 22, I suggest a discussion before you change it. Especially since the other users may remember or know something we don't.