Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24892318-20140502122137/@comment-8345449-20140502174926

Ktmae1234 wrote: Emma knew he was he was in danger. Remember 3x17, "no harm will come to him while he's in my charge." She trusted Hook back to Jolly Roger episode with Henry. And she knew he was in danger. That was due to the general threat of the flying monkeys who were targeting everyone. There is a big difference between that and a specific threat from Zelena that she will kill Henry personally. Do you think Emma would have left Henry alone at Granny's if she knew about that? She would probably have sent him off to New York herself.

And I fail to see how Hook could have adequately protected Henry. He knows first hand that he is no match for Zelena so he really should have asked for help from the Charmings and Regina as soon as possible. But instead, he tried to ship Henry off with a shady character he himself admitted is a rat and who would have been attacked by flying monkeys the moment his stolen ship crossed Storybrooke's borders.

Like I said, I find Hook's actions and intentions pretty incomprehensible.

I'm upset that she turned on him on a dime. Didn't even give him a chance to explain himself. It's like she was waiting for an excuse to cut him lose. I'm all for shipping these two but she needs to stop acting like an little girl. She did give him a chance to explain but she wasn't satisfied with his explanation. And she had the right not to be because Hook should have told her the truth about the danger Henry was in. If Emma and the Charmings didn't arrive in time, Henry would likely have been killed already.