Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-11464223-20160522134756/@comment-27060727-20160523052046

3B > 3A > Season 1 > 5A > 5B > Season 2 > 4A > 4B

Season 3 is by far my favorite season overall. I feel like I /want/ to say that season 1 was the best, but honestly, there was a bunch of stuff in there that I don't care too much about these days. My season 1, 5A, and 5B placements could be easily changed, with season 2 not too far behind. I don't like S4 as much as the other four though. Other than the season 4 finale which I thought was a lovely two hours, I will pretty much never choose a S4 episode for a rewatch.

For the finales: S3 > S1 > S4 > S2 > S5. I'm really not too set on these xD And I definitely don't dislike the S5 finale but it came off more like a premiere when you look at 5x21. The other 4 finales tied better into the story that was finishing - the S1 curse breaking, the S2 "stop Greg & Tamara" thing, the S3 time portal, the S4 Operation Mongoose.....and then we had S5 "Henry decides to destroy magic on a whim and we introduce 2 new people that have nothing to do with 5B." Idk. I guess you should argue that the UW arc ended in 5x21 and they were free to move onto the next plot, but it still seemed a bit weird to me.