Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-3010035-20150701044944/@comment-26346951-20150707160501

Joseph8 wrote:

Rena Charming wrote: Wasn't it just that Rumple needed the tears from someone tempted by darkness but who managed to avoid it? Doesn't necessarily have to be Anna. Could very easily just be Henry, really. He had the chance to alter whatever he wanted with the magical properties of the quill (which could have catastrophic results), but he chose to snap it. Tested, passed. See? That's a long stretch though. :p Rumple wanted to subjugate her permanently because she broke his contract. It is now up to the new Dark One to subjugate her. Why would Emma need to subjutate her because she broke a contract with Rumple? That Emma is now the DO doesn't mean that she wants to avenge previous DO's just for breaking a contract.