Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-208.65.144.27-20130502002306/@comment-6267274-20130502034242

I think it's a very interesting and fitting theory, specially since we don't know where does Hook and Milah went after she ran off with him. Just remember: if they went to Neverland, the pregnancy (and birth) could not have happened, ever since time stops there (that's more or less what Hook told Smee, the closest thing to immortality). But, if they were to other realms, it all could happen. I do think Hook would eventually notice, and therefore, hate whatever fairy or magical creature that would take the child to Neverland (maybe even Tinkerbell?)