Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-2153169-20171120155605/@comment-24304025-20171128134132

Anonymius wrote: FrancisPaul wrote: Anonymius wrote: I'm sorry, no offence to you Francis, but I'm gonna have to disagree with this. In my opinion, when the wish was made it created a timeline that split off from the main EF timeline at the point when things happened differently, with the passing of time correlating with the EF and the NEF. This I think is the safest assumption to make without making too many assumptions with no real basis of fact. It is possible, but it does contradict what both show and writers told us about the world coming to exist by the time of 610. It is possible, but then we must note in the pages that some info was retconned. What does it contradict what the writers told us? As I recall, what was said that it was a real place made by the wish and if characters thought it wasn't real then they were mistaken. It contradicts when they said that WR came to exist after the wish. Given WHook was old by the time of the wish and he has been young as seen with Gothel, the only way for both things to be correct is time moving extremely fast in those seconds between Queenie's wish and WEmma's birthday giving enough time for WHook and WEQ to age as well as for Alice to grow.