Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-3393671-20141109223833/@comment-1916997-20141203073038

Rwo wrote:

Sonofaphrodite wrote:

Walsh is an exceptional case. He was, indeed, sent to our world before the second curse was cast. However, because of this, he has no affiliation with the curse whatsoever, but Phillip and Aurora do. Alright, perhaps this is an implication that Zelena could transport individuals by other means. It doesn't prove that Phillip and Aurora are still immune to the curse's effects simply because they were flying monkeys at the time. Also, we don't know if Zelena sent them to Storybrooke in this manner because it was never explicitly shown. It's still possible that they both may have been transported via the second curse. Again, yes, if the curse affected them, they would have been turned back into their human form! And the fact they were bringed to Storybrooke via the curse was never explicitly shown either.

Sonofaphrodite wrote:

Since she was in the form of a flying monkey during the time the curse struck, I doubt she was given modern clothing. It still could be an exception despite being cursed like everybody else. How convenient.

Sonofaphrodite wrote:

Just because it wasn't hinted that she lost her memories doesn't mean anything. We don't know what it is like from the point-of-view of being a flying monkey. Perhaps she is aware of her surroundings and who she is, as well as her missing memories, but has an uncontrollable urge to obey Zelena. How convenient again for you. It's useful to show or not to show something only when you want it. That's cheating. We can say the same thing about you. You are using things that were never shown as proof that her and Phillip weren't cursed. Your trying to find a difficult answer when the easy answer is usually the correct one. And in this case the easy answer is: they were brought to our world from the curse but they didn't turn back into humans because Zelena had already figured that into her transforming spell. And as we have already established Zelena did not forget her memories because she took a potion beforehand.