Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25491743-20181127152213/@comment-28162607-20181128075244

Just a few points:

1. You cannot say Nook changed and Hook didn't. OG Hook has done way more to redeem himself than Nook ever did. If you think he has not changed, please rewatch the show, you missed key details. His only real reversion was the DO.

2. You can't sat "villains lie, Hook lied once, ergo he is a villain". By this logic, every person on this show is a villain.

3. Hook has shown remorse for all the things he did as the DO, including killing Merlin ("If anyone deserves to go to the UW it's me").

4. This is a fairytale show where Snow is bffs with the woman who killed her father and tortured her. might not work IRL, but suspension of disbelief applies here. We know he has changed enough not to revert.