Thread:Lady Junky/@comment-5239487-20171028192348/@comment-25375217-20171028194422

While Gideon is definitely not Russell, I'm inclined to agree that he's not Carl and Ellie's child either because Carl and Ellie never have a child. When they try, she finds out she is barren. It would be like saying Emma is based on Snow White and Prince Charming's child when they don't have a child in the original story.