Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-32423680-20180625010006/@comment-25491743-20180627151452

I know WHook said a line about how their stories were same until the Dark Curse, but we know that can't be said for all Wish Realm characters because the curse isn't the only thing making the Wish Realm different from the Enchanted Forest (e.g. Robin Hood and Sheriff of Nottingham are younger than they should be, etc). The Wish created a world in which Emma Swan was never the Savior, not one in which the Dark Curse was never cast (it just so happens that the DC never was).

There's not really any evidence to support that OG Hook's mom and WHook's mom have the same name.