Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24892318-20140610050421

And does it matter?

As much as Hook believes in Good Form, I do believe he'd trade it to an enemy in order to get a magic bean quickly and get back to Emma. I think he'd believe ending the curse and saving Emma would outweigh any future problems that his actions may cause.

If the writers to go this route, it will challenge his relationship with Emma when she realizes what he's done and it will further his character development.

Then again, it's possible he made the deal with the Black Fairy and he wasn't even aware of who she was.

Additionally, if this person had one magic bean, it's probable they've got two, and therefore have a portal to Storybrooke. This could be how our villain for 4B gets to SB.

Any thoughts on who it might be? 