Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25896389-20150514071947/@comment-5635908-20150726024051

Eskaver wrote: Warning: Long Post. On thing this thread teaches me is that I underappreaciate Adam and Eddy....

Anyway, Walsh is better because it's original. If Zelena's name is changed then why not the wizard?

I won't say much on all the shippy stuff because in an outside view of ships it's really terrible in how it's biased.

Rumple cannot be Zelena's father because that makes no sense timeline-wise and you must not understand Rumple's character if you think he'd leave a child fatherless aka not his forever and ever more especially after losing Bae.

But going in order,

1) So if you replace Johanna with Gaston, that makes no sense and kills all the emotion. Who cares about Gaston? (I mean the characters, not the viewers). Cora wouldn't threaten to kill Gaston in front of Snow because that's idiotic. Belle doesn't even really are about him and even cut off his legs via rose.

2) Will didn't even exist in season 2, so you can't use him since he didn't exist....unless you mean a Will like character. Same with Seb Stan will be filming higher grossing films, so you can't really change that.

3) Milah is a better name. Unique sounding to me.

4) Why Hook? Regina making Tink lose her wings is perfectly fine.

5) Wonderland was perfect how it was minus the beginning's acting and the CGI. IMO

So, since I like to be brutally honest, I like some of the innovative ideas you have, but it would be worse than what we had. It seems like your changing a lot, but not making it better. To put it in better terms, a story consists of Plot, Characters, Setting, and all lead to a conflict. I see conflict and setting as being fine, but where are the other characters? The plot is none existent. Where would the character growth be?

Like What happened with magic being released? What happened to Snow? Is she a villain now? What do the other characters do about it? How would this lead into your season 3?

Alright, Snow is consumed by darkness, but wait we need to travel to Neverland to save Henry? Forget you, Mary Margaret! and forget this world, too!

Then there are character arcs and such. Rumple can't just randomly be killed because he's a popular character and he's one of the four core characters of the show. Especially to a secondary character that seems to disappear in your ideas.

Just reealized what it was: Where are the main characters? They are the ones that run the show.

Wonderful job, keep it up! 1. I wasn't going to literally have johanna replace gaston. I just meant Gaston dies instead of Johanna.