Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-34360784-20180116101248/@comment-1916997-20180210221040

8Rob wrote: FrancisPaul wrote:

And who is Whook to confirm anything?

The writers put that line in WHook's mouth for a reason. They were trying to explain how the Wish Realm works. We can't just assume the guy is lying/mistaken. WHook's statement will be wrong until the show itself proves him wrong

Canon vs speculation

That's one of my points as well. The writer's wouldn't have had WHook say that, if they didn't want to establish that Hook and WHook share a past.