Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-26346951-20150427084633/@comment-25926288-20150602210345

DarkCruellaTheFirst wrote: I think that in season two and three (the time he was still a pirate) he was arrogant and he acted like a jurk, but since heis part of thegoodguys I started to like him, but it was quite weird he was gorgiven so swiftly. All cause he was with emma (I could be wrong it isn't that fresh in my memory).

You are totally right. I actually was fine with the villain Hook, clearly much of his change dealt with doing it to impress Emma (3a proves such) and then since Neal randomly died, Emma fell right into his hands. I may not like Neal, but with Snow pushing Emma towards him and Emma desparately looking for him, I'm certain if he had not died, they would be together. I mean one guy sacrificed his boat and livelihood (admirable) and the other sacrifice's his life. The guy that sacrifice's all dies. The guy who sacrifices his boat gets Emma and even gets his boat back! I could maybe stand it, but they just undermined Hook's sacrifice and ...let me not get off topic!

It's a "let them have their cake and eat it too" syndrome, which even Regina suffers from. In brevity, Regina is wanting to rewrite history or even change the past, effectively destroying not only Henry but Roland and Marian for her happiness. The villains want the same thing, but oh no, it's evil. But Regina decides to not go through with her plan because she gets Robin back with minimal effort. They even make Zelena kill Marian the second time so we wouldn't be like "So, Regina killed Marian both times!".

But back on topic, I'm sure Killian is surely a "hot" topic (pun intended!).