Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24271102-20150612100132/@comment-25926288-20150722204638

Farerb wrote: I hope you're joking, right?; that wouldn't make sense.

1. There would have been no Rumple at the end of season 4 since the darkness was removed from him.

2. He wouldn't have shown any feelings toward Belle, Neal and Henry during 3B-4. I know. I rather him have been dead than to watch his son die and experience such terrible writing and the mess of the rest of the season.

I sort of wanted him being reformed in darkness to have affected him, which sort of happened with his heart almost completely black.

I just think that Rumple living happily with Belle with a new son isn't a happy ending I would want for him. That's also because I'm sure he'll get that anyway after they whitewash---I mean redeem his character. I beleive he could have been redeemed and not get everything he wants, because that's not how it should work.