Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27704373-20161201191159/@comment-25758988-20161201205733

I have a theory that the hooded person is Emma's darkness. I mean we have had a dark side theme this season with EQ and Hyde and people working through their dark secretes and histories like Hook with Nemo and Cinderella with her Step Mother.

I don't think it will be Emma as a Dark One but I have a inkling the person could very well be Lilly. I know a bit out there but consider this: Lilly is officially Emma's darkness, the writers have hinted we may get answers to Lilly's untold story about her father so she will be about and lets be honest it will be a suprise.

Other then Lilly I think it could be Gideon from the Dreamworld ( I dont think he really is who he says he is, and he seems dodgy), it could also be Aladdin (being forced to do it by a wish, the stabbing wont kill Emma so it won't be breaking the rules of magic), or on this assumption regarding a wish it could also be Jafar, of course it could be someone random like Robin Hood or even more random Granny lol.