Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20171128150502/@comment-24304025-20171222104837

Anonymius wrote: FrancisPaul wrote: KnocknickKnock wrote: Eskaver wrote: Another update (though some is obvious).

Wish Realm is not NFTL/NEF.

Wish Realm's timeline does not start at 1983.

If I do a little extrapolating then Francis' thoughts are more than likely to be the leading idea.

link: https://twitter.com/AdamHorowitzLA/status/939916046101659648

Adam fails again. Dude should just stop talking.

This wishrealm or Verse was already confirmed to be a realm created in which Regina didn't cast the curse. We physically see this on screen. In the enchanted forest they don't use Our world time system such as 1900's. However the year Regina didn't cast the curse in the enchanted forest would be the equlivant to 1983.

Hook hooked up a couple of days(Weeks) later with Gothel who at this point was trapped in the tower. IDK the how much time Gothel was trapped in tower and that is irrelevant. However 7x09 would have happened before 7x07.

Time wise the Wishrealm/verse and Regular Story timelines would be the same. When Regina went to save Emma in 6x10 from the wishrealm, Emma was still the same age she was in Storybrooke Realm which was 28+. Henry was the same age in each Universe too. Henry would have been 10+. At the very least we can say Anastasia, Drizella and Ella is older than Emma given they were born before the day the Curse was suppose to be cast. This is obvious given Gothel backstory. So at the very least if no speed age involved 18 years older than Henry.

Also the only way WishHook and Gothel could have logically meet before the wish was if and only if Gothel is part of the Wishrealm. Otherwise we have a gapping Plot hole. I guess you could argue:

1. The Wishrealm wasn't created by the wish and always existed. However it wouldn't work as another version of Emma seperate from out Emma should be walking around. Not to mention the writers said it was created by a wish.

2. The Wishrealm altered the Original realm timeline somehow. However this creates problems itself.

Eitherway though there would still be plot holes with Jaconda(Ella), and Drizella ages. The youngest they should be is late 30's no matter what Universe. The easiest way to conciliate both timelines is to accept that the WR was indeed created by the wish and all of its backstory happened in a matter of LWM seconds up to the point when Emma blew the candle. Probably the earliest point of the WR's history was something around Bae's childhood that changed Rumple's participation in the curse, therefore not making Emma the Savior and allowing Bae to be alive years later for Emma to concieve Henry, not forgetting that Adam confirmed that WBae never left for the WLWM/LMW. I thought the earliest point in WR's history was when regina failed to cast the curse. No, because the wish was for Emma not to be the savior, not for Regina not to cast the curse.

Anything leading to Emma becoming the Savior must have changed (which possibly includes Rumple's motives)