Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24589671-20141027013232/@comment-24674051-20141105182202

I admit the theory is unlikely, but I'm trying to work out how the hat got to the mysterious house. THe house is not Ingrids, but (unless I missed something) the house just magically appeared with the second curse meaning that SOMEONE was brought over. and whoever this someone is just happened to have the Hat.

The question is, who is it. Anna had and lost to the Hat to Ingrid. But Ingrid did not have the hat, so she must have lost it somewhere along the way. So the mystery is, who is the missing person that was the owner of the hat. My guess is Helga.

Also, as for what happened between Helga and Ingrid, I think that Helga was the one that trapped Ingrid in the Urn, and then she herself disappeared  so that Ingrid might never find her should she ever become free of the Urn. I also think that Helga is most likely magical, which is why she and Ingrid are the ones that disappeard, leaving the non-magical Gerda behind.

Now, before anyone else says it, there are enough plot holes in the above to make swiss cheese look solid, so don't poke too hard. :)