Board Thread:Spoilers!/@comment-2153169-20170909025746/@comment-2153169-20171114141801

Rwo wrote: I don't totally get why it became so "popular".

Like, Hook tells his original that his daughter was trapped in a tower by a witch, which would obviously make that daughter Rapunzel, but people start to think instead "Hey, what if Tremaine is Punzie? She has blond streaks". In French you'd talk about a "hair-pulled" (far-fetched) theory.

It is so much more simple to have: Rapunzel as Rapunzel The Witch as the Witch Lady Trémaine as Lady Trémaine (with one of the first two being Hook's daughter, even more so likely Rapunzel then)

Hook didn't say he raised or even saw his daughter before she got trapped in her tower, so he might not even know who she is to him before he meets her properly as a young girl.

Rapunzel is not Hook's daughter.

Hook's daughter = Eloise Gardener. In 711, Eloise has a scene with Kelly (Zelena's cursed counterpart). Meeghan did not film for 711, she was not even present at Vancouver for this episode.

There is nothing else to add. Rapunzel is just not Hook's daughter.