Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25926288-20161205015930/@comment-25926288-20161205194958

Well, HM, Sir Henry doesn't have the sword as Emma takes it with her. Or at least that what was show after Emma froze him.

The issue with wish bouncing was that Wonderland is canon and it gives genies more rules. More rules are better. If obtaining lamp was just the case, Jafar looks stupid as would Ana who had the botttle for a decent length of time.

Plus, as I said, it creates limits. If owning a genie meant anything, Emma could have poofed it far away from Queenie and they'd never have an issue. I rather headcanon it into semantics and offscreen stuff. (And mostly plot: Because Queenie could have easily took the lamp from David at any point.) David giving up his wishes are fine by me.