Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-141.114.141.147-20130322034037/@comment-7319346-20130324170743

Utter solitude wrote: It was totally deserved! He still lied to her. I'm sorry, what do you expect her to do? Nothing? That's ridiculous. The man lied, and robbed her of her chance to raise her child.

How do you think Snow would have reacted if Geppetto explained that the only way he would build the wardrobe would be if his son was one of the two in it? She would have made that deal. But he didn't, he lied, and the reasoning doesn't really matter, at least not to MM. The logic in Gepetto's doing is that he is not royalty, they wouldn't have cared about what he wanted and what he cared a about.

He waited for so long for a son, and having the chance to save him was the only thought in his mind. Lying was the only way.