Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-28162607-20180412153113/@comment-25926288-20180413224834

Lily wasn’t Emma’s Darkness. (The writers use illogical wording).

Think of it like buckets. Lily has a Lily bucket and an Emma bucket. Lily was filling up both buckets.

Emma had no bucket. The Dark One comes with a bucket. So, when she became DO, the bucket came with. Lily having Emma’s bucket doesn’t relate to Emma’s state of being.

Plus, I think Agnes was pregnant not to long after.