Board Thread:Character Discussion/@comment-26289323-20150424022920/@comment-91424-20151122004343

The writers... The thing is: The writers are sometimes wrong. They are only humans, and sometimes they say things that are contradicted by their own show. For example, some people tried to change the trivia for Emma because Adam said that her birthday was October 23., even though the show itself clearly proves that it is October 22.

As for the missing year, well, "New York City Serenade", "Witch Hunt" and "Quiet Minds", take place "one year" before season 4B, "The Jolly Roger" and the first part of "The Tower", take place nine months before 4B, and the first part of "A Curious Thing" and the second part of "The Tower" take place eight months before 4B. A year could mean anything from nine - ten months to more than twelve months. So who knows.