Board Thread:Wiki-Related Discussion/@comment-24304025-20140320112534/@comment-9232373-20140320201439

FrancisPaul wrote: Stonicus wrote: If it requires being cursed to be considered as counterpart, then August and Neal should only get one page as they were never cursed...

If being a new "persona" makes you a counterpart, and granted your own page, then there should be the following:

3 pages for Rumple... EF Rumple, Dark One Rumple, and Mr. Gold.

Only 1 page for Jefferson, Neal, August, as they are always the same person

2 Pages for Emma... Emma Swan, and Savior Emma who can cast magic

4 Pages for Regina... Evil Queen Regina, Mayor Regina, Changed Nice Mayor Regina, Changed Nice Evil Queen Regina... she's been evil, and good, in both worlds... going from evil to good seems like a new "persona" to me... Please, say you're joling

My point was to say the rules for deciding who should have a separate page are completely arbitrary and ambiguos right now, so no, I am not joking.

How would you handle Robin Hood and the Merry Men? They are in Storybrooke now, but remember who they were, so they are the same person. The only justification to give them a new page is that their geography has changed. If that is a criteria, then we need separate pages for everyone who has been to more than one land. Hook, Jefferson, Regina would require multiple pages alone on this basis.

To have any sort of consistency in the wiki layout requires a strict definition why it is justified, and there isn't a consistently applied justification at this point.